Understanding the Concept of "Purest" Water
When asking, "what is the purest water to buy?," it's essential to define what "pure" means. For a chemist, pure water is just H₂O, with virtually all dissolved solids and contaminants removed. For a nutritionist, this level of purity can be problematic, as it also removes the beneficial minerals your body uses for hydration. For consumers, it often means water free from any harmful contaminants, like pesticides, bacteria, or heavy metals. The answer to which is "best" depends entirely on your specific needs, whether for medical equipment, laboratory use, or daily drinking.
Distilled Water: The Scientific Gold Standard for Purity
Distilled water is created through distillation, a process that involves boiling water and condensing the steam back into a liquid state. This leaves almost all impurities, including minerals, behind. While this process effectively removes non-volatile contaminants like salts and heavy metals, it is less effective at removing some organic compounds with lower boiling points, such as certain pesticides, which can vaporize along with the water.
Reverse Osmosis Water: A Highly Effective Filtration Method
Reverse osmosis (RO) purifies water by forcing it through a semi-permeable membrane at high pressure. This membrane has extremely small pores that block larger molecules and particles, including dissolved solids, bacteria, and most viruses. While RO removes a high percentage of contaminants, it is not as exhaustive as distillation and often leaves behind some residual minerals. Many modern RO systems include a remineralization stage to add healthy minerals like calcium and magnesium back into the water for better taste and nutritional value.
A Closer Look at the Health and Taste Debate
One of the main arguments against drinking ultra-pure water like distilled water is the removal of essential minerals. Your body primarily gets minerals from food, but water can contribute a small amount. However, drinking demineralized water over the long term, without a sufficiently mineral-rich diet, can lead to concerns about mineral leaching from the body.
The taste is another significant differentiator. Distilled water is often described as having a "flat" or bland taste because the minerals that give water flavor are absent. Conversely, RO water, especially when re-mineralized, often has a crisp, refreshing taste that many people prefer. Water quality standards, like the EPA's recommendation of less than 500 ppm of total dissolved solids (TDS), help ensure safety and taste. A lower TDS level is generally equated with purer water.
Comparison Table: Distilled vs. Reverse Osmosis Water
| Feature | Distilled Water | Reverse Osmosis (RO) Water |
|---|---|---|
| Purification Method | Boiling water, collecting and condensing steam. | Forcing water through a semi-permeable membrane under pressure. |
| Purity Level | Removes virtually all dissolved solids, contaminants, and minerals. | Removes 90-99% of contaminants, though some minerals may remain. |
| Energy Consumption | High energy usage due to the heating and boiling process. | Lower energy consumption compared to distillation, using pressure. |
| Waste Product | Concentrated impurities left in the boiling chamber. | A significant volume of "brine" or wastewater containing contaminants is flushed away. |
| Taste | Often described as flat or bland due to the lack of minerals. | Often has a crisp, clean taste, especially with re-mineralization. |
| Cost | Typically more expensive for home production and often pricier to buy bottled. | Home systems can have a higher initial cost but are more cost-effective per gallon over time. |
Other Pure Water Options to Consider
Beyond the two most scientifically pure types, other bottled waters offer a balance of purity, minerals, and convenience. Naturally sourced options include spring water and artesian water, which are collected from underground aquifers and contain a natural mineral composition. Some bottled brands, like Aquafina and Dasani, use reverse osmosis on municipal tap water before adding a precise blend of minerals for taste. Others, such as Smartwater, use a process called vapor distillation followed by the addition of electrolytes. The label is your best guide, so check it to understand the source and purification method.
How to Choose the Best Pure Water for You
Your choice should be based on your personal priorities. If you need water with absolutely no dissolved solids for specific applications, such as for a CPAP machine or scientific use, distilled water is the correct choice. If you are seeking clean, refreshing drinking water with contaminants removed but still want the benefits of minerals, consider an RO system with a re-mineralization filter or certain bottled brands that add electrolytes. For those concerned about plastic waste, investing in a home filtration system, either RO or distillation, is a more sustainable option than relying solely on bottled water. Ultimately, a balanced diet is the primary source of necessary minerals, making safety and taste key factors for daily hydration. You can further investigate the specifics of water quality certifications and testing by consulting resources from the NSF International.
Conclusion: Making an Informed Choice
The question of "what is the purest water to buy" has no single, simple answer. From a technical standpoint, distilled water is the purest, but this level of purification removes both the good and the bad. Reverse osmosis offers a highly effective purification method that is often more practical for daily consumption, especially with re-mineralization. Ultimately, the best choice for you depends on balancing the need for purity against flavor, cost, and the presence of health-supporting minerals. Read labels, understand the purification process, and consider a home system for long-term purity and convenience.
Brand Examples Based on Purification Method
- Distilled Water Brands: Nestlé Pure Life, Glaceau Smartwater (vapor distilled).
- Reverse Osmosis (RO) Brands: Aquafina, Dasani, Kirkland Signature.
- Natural Spring/Mineral Brands: Fiji Water, Acqua Panna, Mountain Valley Spring Water.