Skip to content

What Makes Five Guys Unhealthy? The Nutritional Breakdown

3 min read

According to a 2024 analysis, Five Guys served the unhealthiest cheeseburger and fries in America compared to other major fast-food chains. This reputation is primarily due to extremely high levels of saturated fat, sodium, and total calories in its popular menu items, raising important questions about what makes Five Guys unhealthy.

Quick Summary

A typical meal from Five Guys is laden with excessive calories, saturated fat, and sodium, contributing significantly to a diner's daily recommended limits. Factors like multiple beef patties, high-calorie toppings, and large portions of fries cooked in peanut oil all contribute to a less-than-healthy nutritional profile.

Key Points

  • Saturated Fat: The double-patty burgers are very high in saturated fat.

  • Excessive Sodium: A meal can easily exceed the daily recommended sodium intake.

  • High Calorie Count: Large portions and calorie-dense toppings result in high-calorie meals.

  • Large Fry Portions: Contribute significantly to the calorie and fat content.

  • Rich Add-ons: High-fat toppings and sugary milkshakes increase the unhealthy profile.

  • Customization Adds Up: Toppings can add significant fat, sugar, and sodium.

  • Bunless Option Is Key: Ordering bunless with vegetable toppings significantly reduces fat, calories, and carbs.

In This Article

The Hidden Dangers in a Five Guys Meal

Five Guys is known for its customizable burgers, but a typical meal can contain high levels of fat, saturated fat, and sodium. This is due to a combination of factors, including portion sizes, high-fat ingredients, and cooking methods.

The Burgers: More Than Just Two Patties

Standard Five Guys burgers come with two patties, contributing significantly to the high calorie and fat content. Toppings like bacon, cheese, mayonnaise, and sugary sauces further increase the unhealthiness of the meal. A bacon cheeseburger can exceed 900 calories and daily saturated fat recommendations.

The Fries: A High-Calorie, High-Sodium Side

Five Guys' fries are cooked in peanut oil and served in generous portions, making them a major source of calories and sodium. A large order can contain over 1,300 mg of sodium.

Milkshakes and Add-Ons: Pushing Nutritional Limits

Adding a milkshake to a Five Guys meal significantly increases calorie and sugar intake. Milkshakes with mix-ins can contain over 80 grams of sugar. Even the free peanuts contribute extra calories and fat.

How Five Guys Compares to Other Chains

Five Guys often has larger portion sizes and higher saturated fat content compared to other fast-food restaurants. While their ingredients are fresh, this doesn't automatically make the meal healthy.

Feature Five Guys McDonald's Burger King
Saturated Fat (Cheeseburger) Very High (Often >100% DV) Lower (e.g., Quarter Pounder with Cheese is 45% DV) Lower (e.g., Whopper with Cheese is 45% DV)
Sodium (Large Fries) Very High (Often >50% DV) Moderate (e.g., Large Fries is 12% DV) Moderate (e.g., Large Fries is 13% DV)
Calories (Typical Meal) Very High (often 1500+ cals) Moderate Moderate
Customization Extensive Moderate Moderate

The Conclusion: Moderation is Key

Five Guys meals are high in calories, fat, and sodium due to generous portions and high-calorie ingredients. While the ingredients are fresh, the nutritional impact is significant. Enjoying Five Guys in moderation and making healthier choices like a "Little Hamburger" in a lettuce wrap can help reduce the unhealthiness.

Healthier Alternatives at Five Guys

  • Go "Little": Opt for the single-patty "Little Hamburger".
  • Lose the Bun: Order a lettuce wrap instead of a bun.
  • Add Veggies: Choose low-calorie vegetable toppings.
  • Skip the Fries: Avoid the large, salted fries.
  • Water Over Shake: Choose water over a milkshake.

What makes Five Guys unhealthy? A list of key contributors:

  • Excessive Calories: Meals can exceed 1,500 calories.
  • High Saturated Fat Content: Burgers are particularly high in saturated fat.
  • High Sodium Levels: Items like fries and burgers are heavily salted.
  • Large Portion Sizes: Standard burgers have two patties, and fry portions are generous.
  • High-Calorie Toppings: Cheese, bacon, and sugary sauces add significant calories and fat.
  • Peanut Oil for Frying: Adds to the high total fat content of fries.
  • Sugary Milkshakes: Provide empty calories and added sugars.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: How can I make my Five Guys meal healthier? A: Order a "Little Hamburger," use a lettuce wrap, and choose vegetable toppings instead of cheese, bacon, and sugary sauces.

Q: What is the main issue with Five Guys' burgers? A: They are high in saturated fat and calories due to multiple patties and high-calorie toppings.

Q: Are the Five Guys fries bad for you? A: Yes, they are high in calories, fat, and sodium due to portion size and cooking method.

Q: Is peanut oil unhealthy for cooking fries? A: While peanut oil is a healthier fat, the large volume used results in fries that are high in total fat and calories.

Q: How much sodium is in a Five Guys meal? A: A meal can easily exceed the daily recommended limit of 2,300 mg.

Q: Does the freshness of ingredients at Five Guys make it healthy? A: Fresh ingredients don't outweigh the high fat, sodium, and calorie content from generous portions and toppings.

Q: What is the lowest-calorie option at Five Guys? A: A bunless Little Hamburger with only vegetable toppings is the lowest-calorie main option.

Frequently Asked Questions

Five Guys' prices are generally higher than other fast-food chains due to their commitment to using fresh, never-frozen beef and high-quality ingredients. The portions are also very generous, which is reflected in the price.

Yes, Five Guys uses real bacon on its burgers and hot dogs. It's the same high-sodium, high-fat bacon found on many other fast-food items, contributing to the meal's overall unhealthiness.

The generous portion of fries is a signature part of the Five Guys experience. The company prides itself on giving customers an extra scoop in their bag, which is a marketing strategy that reinforces their reputation for abundance, even though it adds to the meal's high caloric load.

Yes, but with significant modifications. A keto-friendly option would be a bunless burger with no cheese, bacon, or sugary sauces. Focusing on the beef patty and vegetable toppings helps keep carbs low.

While peanut oil contains monounsaturated fats that can be part of a healthy diet, the large volume used for cooking the fries means that a Five Guys meal is still very high in total fat and calories. The oil itself is not inherently bad, but the preparation method is.

Five Guys provides a comprehensive nutrition and allergen guide on their official website, typically in PDF format. This resource allows you to calculate the nutritional values for custom orders by adding and subtracting different toppings.

The veggie sandwich is a lower-calorie and lower-fat option compared to the burgers, but it is still high in sodium due to the bun and toppings. To make it healthier, consider ordering it bunless and skipping high-sodium sauces.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.