Fruiting Body vs. Mycelium: A Fundamental Difference
To understand the best part of the mushroom for supplements, it's essential to grasp the fundamental distinction between the two main parts of a fungus: the fruiting body and the mycelium. The fruiting body is the visible, above-ground structure—the stem and cap that people recognize as a mushroom. Conversely, mycelium is the vast, root-like network of filaments that grows unseen, typically underground or within a substrate like wood.
The Case for the Fruiting Body
Supplements made from the fruiting body are highly regarded for their superior potency and purity. This is where the mushroom concentrates its most powerful bioactive compounds, such as immune-modulating beta-glucans and anti-inflammatory triterpenes. Furthermore, fruiting bodies are the only part of the mushroom exposed to sunlight, allowing them to naturally produce beneficial Vitamin D. A key advantage of fruiting body extracts is the absence of grain fillers. When cultivated in controlled environments, the fruiting bodies are harvested, ensuring a more consistent and nutrient-dense product. This practice is rooted in thousands of years of traditional medicinal use, particularly in Asia, where the fruiting bodies have long been revered for their therapeutic properties.
The Mycelium-on-Grain Dilemma
While mycelium is a vital part of the fungal lifecycle, its use in supplements is often problematic. Many manufacturers grow mycelium on grain substrates like rice or oats for faster, cheaper production. A significant issue arises because it is nearly impossible to separate the mycelium from its grain substrate during harvesting. This results in the final supplement containing a large percentage of inert grain filler and starch, diluting the active compound concentration. Scientific studies have confirmed this, showing that mycelium-on-grain products have much lower levels of beta-glucans and higher levels of unwanted alpha-glucans (starches) compared to fruiting body extracts. Some exceptions exist, such as the Cordyceps CS-4 strain, which is grown via liquid fermentation, allowing for a purer mycelium product that mimics the wild version.
The Importance of Extraction Methods
Even when using the right part of the mushroom, the extraction method is critical for unlocking its full therapeutic potential. The tough cell walls of fungi are not easily broken down by the human digestive system, so extraction is necessary to make the beneficial compounds bioavailable.
- Hot Water Extraction: This method is used to pull out water-soluble compounds like polysaccharides, including beta-glucans. Many reputable suppliers use a long, hot-water simmering process called decoction.
- Alcohol Extraction: For woodier mushrooms like Reishi or Chaga, an alcohol extraction is needed to release non-water-soluble compounds like triterpenes.
- Dual Extraction: The most comprehensive method uses both hot water and alcohol to capture the full spectrum of beneficial compounds.
Comparison: Fruiting Body vs. Mycelium
| Feature | Fruiting Body | Mycelium (on Grain) |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Function | Reproductive structure (cap and stem) | Vegetative network ('roots') |
| Potency | Higher concentration of key compounds | Lower concentration due to grain substrate |
| Active Compounds | High in beta-glucans, triterpenes, antioxidants | Can contain unique compounds, but often low concentration |
| Nutrient Density | Nutrient-dense, free of starch fillers | Often diluted by significant grain filler/starch |
| Production Cost | More time and costly to produce | Faster and cheaper to produce |
| Traditional Use | Extensive history in traditional medicine | Relatively new as an ingestible supplement |
What to Look For in a Quality Supplement
Given the significant differences, discerning consumers should look for specific indicators of quality. Prioritize products that explicitly state they are made from 100% fruiting body extract. The label should also provide details on the extraction method and, ideally, list the standardized content of active compounds, especially beta-glucans. Be skeptical of labels that use vague terms like “myceliated biomass” or “full spectrum,” as these can obscure the inclusion of low-potency grain. The color and taste can also be a clue; bitter compounds like triterpenes indicate a proper fruiting body extract, whereas a lighter, starchy product likely contains more grain. For cognitive benefits from Lion's Mane, look for standardization of hericenones (in fruiting body) and erinacines (in mycelium).
Conclusion: Making the Best Choice
For most health and wellness goals, the overwhelming evidence and traditional wisdom point towards the mushroom's fruiting body as the superior choice for supplements. Its higher concentration of potent, bioavailable compounds and freedom from grain fillers makes it the most effective option. While mycelium plays a vital ecological role, the commercially expedient method of growing it on grain often yields a diluted and less potent product for human consumption. By prioritizing fruiting body extracts and checking for standardized compound percentages, consumers can ensure they are investing in a product that delivers the powerful benefits medicinal mushrooms are famous for.
Here is a reputable source on the topic of mushroom sourcing.
