Comparing Skittles vs. M&Ms: A Nutritional Showdown
When faced with the choice between a classic pack of Skittles and M&M's, the decision often comes down to personal taste. However, for those concerned with their diet, the choice might seem more complicated. While both are highly processed treats with little nutritional value, a closer look at their ingredients and macronutrient profiles reveals some key differences. The following breakdown explores what is actually inside these popular candies, comparing them side-by-side to determine which might be the 'lesser of two evils.'
The Core Ingredients: Fruit Flavors vs. Milk Chocolate
The fundamental difference between Skittles and M&M's lies in their base ingredients. Skittles are a fruit-flavored candy, primarily made of sugar, corn syrup, and hydrogenated palm kernel oil, with a variety of artificial and natural flavors and colors. M&M's, on the other hand, are a chocolate-based candy. Standard M&M's contain milk chocolate, which provides slightly more in the way of protein and fat from dairy and cocoa butter, alongside sugar and other additives. This difference in base ingredients is the primary driver for all other nutritional disparities between the two snacks.
The Numbers Game: Calories, Sugar, and Fat
Looking at the numbers per serving size, some clear distinctions emerge. For a standard 1.5-ounce (42g) bag of original M&M's, you're looking at around 210 calories, 8 grams of fat, and 28 grams of sugar. A similar-sized 1.8-ounce (51g) bag of Skittles has about 200 calories, 2 grams of fat, and 41 grams of sugar. These figures illustrate a common trade-off in the candy world: chocolate candies like M&M's often have a higher fat content, while pure sugar candies like Skittles can pack more sugar for a similar calorie count. When considering Peanut M&M's, the nutritional profile shifts again, with the added peanuts contributing protein and healthy fats, providing a small amount of substance compared to the refined sugar of Skittles.
Beyond Macros: Artificial Ingredients and Concerns
Both candies rely on a range of artificial ingredients to achieve their signature vibrant colors and flavors. Consumers have increasingly voiced concerns over ingredients like artificial food dyes. Skittles and M&M's sold in the U.S. use a variety of these, including Red 40, Yellow 5, and Blue 1. Some of these dyes have been linked to behavioral issues in children, although research is mixed.
In recent years, companies have begun to adapt. For example, Mars removed the color additive titanium dioxide from Skittles in response to regulatory concerns, with Europe already having banned its use. This highlights a growing trend toward cleaner, more natural ingredients. M&M's once controversially removed and then reintroduced red dyes, but have since also adapted their formulations.
Other ingredients, such as high-fructose corn syrup and palm oil, are also common in these candies. Palm oil, a component in Skittles, is often a point of contention due to its environmental impact. High-fructose corn syrup, prevalent in Skittles, has been associated with various health concerns when consumed in excess.
Making the Best Choice: Moderation and Consideration
Ultimately, no dietitian would recommend either Skittles or M&M's as part of a healthy, regular diet. Both are calorie-dense, sugar-laden treats that offer little to no real nutritional benefit. The "healthier" choice between the two depends on what health factors you prioritize.
For someone strictly watching fat and calorie intake, the lower fat count in Skittles might seem preferable. However, the higher sugar load can cause a sharper blood sugar spike. On the other hand, M&M's, particularly the peanut variety, offer a slightly more balanced profile due to the fat and protein content, which can help mitigate a sugar rush and provide a slightly greater sense of satiety. The higher fat and calorie count must be taken into account, though.
How to Enjoy Your Treats Mindfully
- Practice portion control: Instead of eating directly from a large bag, portion out a small amount into a bowl. A fun-size pack or a handful is a reasonable treat.
- Savor each piece: Don't mindlessly munch. Enjoy the flavor and texture of each individual candy. This helps with conscious consumption.
- Consider alternatives: If you're craving something sweet but want a healthier option, consider dark chocolate, dried fruit, or homemade snacks with controlled sugar.
| Nutritional Aspect | Original Skittles (1.8 oz bag) | Milk Chocolate M&M's (1.5 oz bag) | Peanut M&M's (1.74 oz bag) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Calories | ~200 | ~210 | ~250 |
| Total Fat | ~2 g | ~8 g | ~13 g |
| Saturated Fat | ~2 g | ~5 g | ~6 g |
| Total Sugars | ~41 g | ~28 g | ~25 g |
| Protein | 0 g | ~2 g | ~5 g |
| Fiber | 0 g | ~1 g | ~1 g |
| Key Ingredients | Sugar, Corn Syrup, Palm Kernel Oil, Artificial Flavors/Colors | Milk Chocolate, Sugar, Cornstarch, Corn Syrup, Cocoa Butter, Lactose, Peanuts (in Peanut M&Ms), Artificial Colors | Milk Chocolate, Sugar, Roasted Peanuts, Cocoa Butter, Cornstarch, Corn Syrup, Lactose, Artificial Colors |
Conclusion: Which is the 'Better' Choice?
Ultimately, there is no truly healthy answer to the question, "What's healthier, Skittles or M&Ms?" Both are sugary confections designed for taste rather than nutrition. However, a mindful consumer can analyze the trade-offs based on their personal diet. Skittles offer lower fat but a much higher sugar content, while M&M's, particularly those with peanuts, provide slightly more nutritional value from protein and fat, even though they are higher in calories. The real takeaway is that these candies should be enjoyed as an occasional treat and that understanding what's inside is the first step toward making more informed dietary choices. For a healthy diet, these candies should be consumed in moderation, allowing for a healthy relationship with food and preventing them from displacing more nutritious options like fruits and lean proteins.
Making the Best Choice: Alternatives and Moderation
For a balanced and healthy lifestyle, moderation is the keyword when it comes to these types of treats. Being mindful of how much you consume is far more impactful than agonizing over the minor nutritional differences between two sugary candies. For a sweet craving, many people find that a small handful of peanut M&M's is more satisfying due to the protein and fat from the peanuts, which can lead to eating fewer overall. On the other hand, if you prefer a lower-fat option and can control your serving size, a small amount of Skittles won't significantly derail a healthy eating plan. Regardless of your choice, prioritizing whole, nutrient-dense foods should always be the focus of your daily nutrition diet.
This content is for informational purposes only and is not medical advice. For personalized nutrition guidance, consult a registered dietitian.
USA Today: The 'healthiest' Halloween candy is an American favorite
