Why Does Cheese Contain Tyramine?
Tyramine is a byproduct of the breakdown of the amino acid tyrosine, a process that occurs naturally in foods that are aged, fermented, or stored improperly. In cheese making, the aging and ripening process, especially with certain bacteria, significantly increases the concentration of tyramine. For most healthy individuals, tyramine is broken down harmlessly by an enzyme called monoamine oxidase (MAO), and large quantities are required to cause a reaction. However, individuals taking MAO inhibitor medications cannot effectively break down tyramine, leading to a dangerous buildup that can cause a hypertensive crisis.
Aged and Fermented Cheeses
Aged and fermented varieties are the primary types of cheese that have tyramine. The longer the cheese ages, the higher the tyramine content tends to be.
- Cheddar: Aged cheddar is a classic example of a cheese with a high tyramine content. The concentration varies, but it's a known concern for those on low-tyramine diets.
- Blue Cheeses: Cheeses like Gorgonzola, Stilton, and Roquefort are aged with mold and consistently show high tyramine levels.
- Swiss and Parmesan: Both Swiss and Parmesan are hard, aged cheeses where the concentration of tyramine increases over time.
- Feta and Camembert: These are also known to be high in tyramine, with feta being preserved in brine and Camembert ripened with mold.
- Gouda: While commercial Goudas may vary, aged Gouda can have significant amounts of tyramine.
- Goat Cheese: Some ripened varieties of goat cheese have been found to contain higher amounts of tyramine compared to cheeses made from cow's milk.
Fresh and Pasteurized Cheeses
On the other end of the spectrum are fresh and pasteurized cheeses, which typically contain very low or negligible amounts of tyramine. The minimal fermentation and aging mean there is less opportunity for tyrosine to be converted to tyramine.
- Cottage Cheese: As a fresh, unripened cheese, cottage cheese is an excellent, low-tyramine option.
- Ricotta: Similar to cottage cheese, ricotta is a low-tyramine choice made from whey.
- Cream Cheese: This soft, fresh cheese is also safe for those on a tyramine-restricted diet.
- American Cheese: Processed cheese products like American cheese, made from pasteurized ingredients, have low levels of tyramine.
- Mozzarella: Fresh mozzarella is generally safe, especially when eaten shortly after being made.
- Paneer: This fresh, non-melting Indian cheese is a good choice for those needing to avoid tyramine.
Comparison of High and Low Tyramine Cheeses
| Cheese Type | Examples | Tyramine Level | Production Process | Suitable for Low-Tyramine Diet? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| High Tyramine (Aged) | Aged Cheddar, Blue Cheese (Gorgonzola, Stilton), Parmesan, Feta, Camembert, Aged Swiss | High | Extended aging and fermentation, bacterial action on tyrosine | No |
| Low Tyramine (Fresh/Processed) | Cottage Cheese, Cream Cheese, Ricotta, American Cheese, Fresh Mozzarella | Low/Negligible | Minimal or no aging, pasteurized milk, controlled processing | Yes |
Potential Health Risks of High Tyramine Intake
For the majority of the population, consuming tyramine is not a health risk. However, it can pose significant issues for specific groups.
MAOI Drug Interactions
Patients on MAOI medications, typically prescribed for depression or Parkinson's disease, must follow a strict low-tyramine diet. These drugs block the enzyme that breaks down tyramine, causing it to build up in the body and trigger a hypertensive crisis. Symptoms include a severe, pounding headache, palpitations, chest pain, and rapid blood pressure increase, requiring immediate medical attention.
Migraine Triggers
For some individuals, especially those prone to migraines, tyramine is a well-documented trigger. The compound can cause nerve cells to release norepinephrine, a chemical that affects blood vessels and can lead to a migraine attack. While not everyone with migraines is sensitive to tyramine, a low-tyramine diet is often recommended to help identify potential triggers.
Factors Influencing Tyramine Content
Several factors beyond just the type of cheese influence its tyramine content:
- Bacterial Species: Specific bacteria, particularly certain strains of Enterococcus faecalis and lactic acid bacteria, are prolific tyramine producers.
- Milk Source: Studies have suggested that cheeses made from goat's milk might contain more tyramine than those from cow's milk.
- Storage Time and Temperature: The longer a cheese is stored, and the higher the temperature, the more tyramine can accumulate. This is why fresh is best for a low-tyramine diet.
Conclusion
Understanding which cheese has tyramine is crucial for certain individuals, especially those on MAOIs or sensitive to migraines. Aged, fermented, and artisan cheeses like aged cheddar, blue cheeses, and Parmesan consistently contain high levels of tyramine. In contrast, fresh, unripened, or pasteurized varieties like cottage cheese, ricotta, and American cheese are safe alternatives. By being mindful of the cheese-making process and storage conditions, those who need to manage their tyramine intake can make informed dietary choices and avoid potential health risks. Individuals with concerns should always consult with a healthcare provider or a dietitian to create a personalized low-tyramine diet plan.
Visit the Mayo Clinic for a comprehensive guide on MAOIs and diet.