Skip to content

Navigating the Menu: Which Sauce is Healthiest in Subway?

4 min read

According to nutrition data, a single serving of the highest-calorie creamy Subway sauce can add over 100 calories and significant fat. Choosing a healthier meal means understanding which sauce is healthiest in Subway, as this seemingly small choice can dramatically impact your sandwich's overall nutritional value.

Quick Summary

This guide compares Subway sauces based on nutrition, from the lowest-calorie dressings like mustard and vinegar to the highest-calorie creamy options. Make an informed choice for your next meal.

Key Points

  • Lowest Calorie Options: Red Wine Vinegar, Yellow Mustard, and Buffalo Sauce are the most calorie-friendly sauce options available at Subway.

  • Creamy Sauces are High-Calorie: Dressings like Mayonnaise, Ranch, and Chipotle Southwest contribute the most fat and calories to a sub and should be limited or avoided for weight management.

  • Sweet Onion Teriyaki is a Good Compromise: This popular sauce adds a lot of flavor for a moderate calorie count, making it a good choice for those who want more than just plain condiments.

  • Consider Oil & Vinegar Sparingly: The 'oil' part of this mix adds fat and calories, so be mindful of portion size, even though vinegar itself is calorie-free.

  • Build a Healthier Sub with Other Elements: Pair your low-calorie sauce with whole-grain bread, lean protein like turkey, and plenty of fresh vegetables to maximize health benefits.

In This Article

Understanding the Nutritional Impact of Subway Sauces

When building a sandwich or salad at Subway, it's easy to focus on the meat, cheese, and vegetables. However, the sauces and condiments can be a hidden source of calories, fat, sugar, and sodium, which can derail your healthy eating goals. For instance, a single 6-inch serving of mayonnaise can add up to 100 calories and 11 grams of fat, while a dash of red wine vinegar adds virtually zero. By paying close attention to these choices, you can create a satisfying meal without a nutritional afterthought.

The Healthiest Sauce Choices: Zero to Low-Calorie

For those watching their calorie or fat intake, several Subway options are excellent choices. These add flavor without the nutritional cost of creamy dressings.

  • Red Wine Vinegar: The gold standard for a healthy, flavorful addition. It contains 0 calories, 0 fat, and 0 sugar, providing a tangy, acidic kick to your sandwich or salad without any guilt.
  • Yellow Mustard: A classic choice with minimal calories. At just 10 calories per 6-inch sub serving, it offers a distinct, zesty flavor that pairs well with many meats.
  • Buffalo Sauce: For those who crave some heat, this is a great low-calorie option. A serving contains only about 5 calories.
  • Marinara Sauce: Primarily tomato-based, this sauce is another low-calorie choice, especially on a meatball sub or with chicken. It typically adds around 15 calories per serving.
  • Sweet Onion Teriyaki: A popular choice that adds sweet and savory flavor for only about 30 calories per serving. While not zero-calorie, it is a much lighter alternative to creamy sauces.

The Middle Ground: Moderate Calorie Sauces

These sauces offer more flavor depth than the lowest-calorie options but come with a moderate calorie count. They can be a good compromise if used sparingly.

  • Barbeque Sauce: Adds a smoky, sweet flavor for around 30 calories per 6-inch sub serving.
  • Honey Mustard: A step up in calories from plain mustard, at about 60 calories per serving, but still a much better choice than full-fat options.
  • Oil & Vinegar: This combination adds a dressing-like quality. While vinegar is calorie-free, the oil contributes around 45 calories per serving.

Sauces to Limit or Avoid: High-Calorie and High-Fat Options

These creamy dressings and aiolis are where the calorie and fat counts can quickly climb, potentially transforming a healthy sub into an indulgent meal.

  • Mayonnaise: A significant source of calories and fat, adding 100 calories per serving.
  • Ranch and Chipotle Southwest: These creamy, flavorful sauces are high in fat and can add 80 to 100+ calories per serving, depending on the specific product and serving size.
  • Garlic Aioli: Often a delicious but high-calorie choice, adding around 80 calories and 8g of fat per serving.

Comparison Table of Subway Sauces

Sauce Name Calories (per 6" serving) Fat (g) Sugar (g) Notes
Red Wine Vinegar 0 0 0 Calorie-free tang.
Yellow Mustard 10 <1 <1 Zesty flavor, minimal impact.
Buffalo Sauce 5 0 <1 Spicy kick, very low calorie.
Marinara Sauce 15 <1 2-3 Low-calorie, tomato-based.
Sweet Onion Teriyaki 30 <1 7 Sweet and savory, moderate sugar.
Barbeque Sauce 30 <1 7 Smoky flavor, moderate sugar.
Honey Mustard 60 5 3 Creamier, higher fat and calories.
MVP Parmesan Vinaigrette 60 6 1 Adds fat from oil base.
Baja Chipotle 70 7 1 Higher in fat and calories.
Peppercorn Ranch 80 8 1 Significant calories and fat.
Roasted Garlic Aioli 80 8 1 Rich, but high in fat and calories.
Mayonnaise 100 11 0 Highest in calories and fat.

Building a Healthier Sub Beyond the Sauce

While sauce choice is crucial, remember it's just one component of a healthier Subway meal. Here are some other tips:

  • Choose the Right Bread: Whole wheat or multigrain breads offer more fiber than white options. For an even lower-carb meal, consider a salad or wrap.
  • Load Up on Veggies: Pile on the lettuce, spinach, tomatoes, cucumbers, and peppers. This adds volume, fiber, and essential nutrients with very few calories.
  • Select Lean Protein: Stick with lean options like turkey breast, oven-roasted chicken, or roast beef to keep protein high and fat low.
  • Go Light on Cheese: Cheese adds significant calories and saturated fat. If you want it, consider a light sprinkle or go for a lower-fat option.
  • Portion Control: The 6-inch sub is almost always the healthier option over the Footlong, helping manage your overall calorie intake.

Conclusion: Making the Right Choice for Your Goals

Ultimately, the 'healthiest' sauce depends on your specific nutritional goals. For those focused strictly on the lowest calories and fat, Red Wine Vinegar and Yellow Mustard are the clear winners. If you want more flavor without a major calorie penalty, the Sweet Onion Teriyaki or Barbeque sauces are good compromises. For a comprehensive list of all nutritional information, consult the official Subway website. By being mindful of your sauce selection and overall sub ingredients, you can ensure your Subway meal remains a healthy, satisfying option.

Frequently Asked Questions

The lowest calorie sauces at Subway are Red Wine Vinegar (0 calories), Buffalo Sauce (5 calories), and Yellow Mustard (10 calories).

Subway's Sweet Onion Teriyaki sauce is a moderately healthy option, containing around 30 calories per 6-inch serving. It's a flavorful alternative that is much lower in calories than creamy dressings.

The sauces with the most fat are the creamy options, including Mayonnaise (11g fat), Roasted Garlic Aioli (8g fat), and Peppercorn Ranch (8g fat) per 6-inch serving.

While it's possible, you should be mindful of the portion. Ranch is one of the highest-calorie sauces, adding significant fat and calories. Using it sparingly or opting for a lower-calorie alternative is a better choice for a healthy diet.

The Oil & Vinegar dressing is moderately caloric. The vinegar part has zero calories, but the oil adds about 45 calories per serving. It's healthier than creamy dressings but not as light as vinegar alone.

Yes, some sauces contain more sugar than others. The Sweet Onion Teriyaki and Barbeque sauces, while low in fat, have a notable amount of added sugar.

In addition to a low-calorie sauce, you can make your order healthier by loading up on fresh vegetables, choosing lean protein like turkey breast, and opting for whole wheat bread.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.