Understanding the E-Number System
E-numbers are codes for food additives approved for use within the European Union, and the system is also adopted in many other regions. They are organised into groups based on their function, such as colours (E100s), preservatives (E200s), and emulsifiers (E400s). While many E-numbers are derived from plant sources or are synthetic, a significant number originate from animals, insects, or can have mixed origins, creating confusion for vegans.
E-Numbers that are Always Non-Vegan
Certain E-numbers are consistently derived from animal sources, and vegans must learn to recognise and avoid them. Some of the most common include:
- E120: Cochineal, Carminic Acid, Carmine. A red food colouring derived from the crushed female cochineal insect.
- E441: Gelatine. A gelling agent sourced from the collagen in animal bones, tendons, and skin, typically from pigs and cows.
- E542: Edible Bone Phosphate. An anti-caking agent obtained from ground animal bones.
- E901: Beeswax. A glazing agent produced by honey bees.
- E904: Shellac. A resinous glaze secreted by the female lac beetle.
- E913: Lanolin. A greasy substance derived from sheep's wool, which can be a source of Vitamin D3.
- E966: Lactitol. A sweetener derived from lactose, or milk sugar.
- E1105: Lysozyme. A preservative enzyme typically sourced from chicken egg whites.
E-Numbers with Mixed Origins
Perhaps the most challenging category for vegans are the E-numbers that can be sourced from either animal or plant products. Without a vegan certification or manufacturer confirmation, it is impossible to know for certain. These often include emulsifiers and fatty acid derivatives.
- E101: Riboflavin. A colour that can be sourced from plants, animals, or fungi.
- E270: Lactic Acid. An acidity regulator that can come from plants or be created synthetically, though the name is often confused with dairy products.
- E322: Lecithin. An emulsifier commonly made from soy or sunflowers, but can also be from eggs.
- E422: Glycerol. Can be derived from either plant oils or animal fats.
- E471: Mono- and diglycerides of fatty acids. Emulsifiers typically from plant oils but potentially from animal fats.
- E631: Disodium inosinate. A flavour enhancer often sourced from meat or fish.
The Importance of Certification
Because of these inconsistencies, relying solely on an E-number list is insufficient for a strict vegan diet. The most reliable way to ensure a product is vegan is to look for official vegan certifications from organisations like The Vegan Society or Vegan Action. These labels guarantee that all ingredients, including potentially ambiguous E-numbers, have been confirmed as non-animal-derived.
A Comparison of Vegan vs. Non-Vegan E-Numbers
| E-Number | Function | Source | Vegan Status | Common Alternatives |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| E120 (Carmine) | Red Colour | Crushed Cochineal Insects | Non-Vegan (Always) | Beetroot Red (E162) |
| E162 (Beetroot Red) | Red Colour | Beets | Vegan (Always) | N/A |
| E441 (Gelatine) | Gelling Agent | Animal Bones/Skin | Non-Vegan (Always) | Agar (E406), Pectin (E440) |
| E406 (Agar) | Gelling Agent | Seaweed | Vegan (Always) | N/A |
| E471 (Mono- & Diglycerides) | Emulsifier | Plant or Animal Fats | Mixed/Potentially Non-Vegan | Soy Lecithin (E322), if verified plant-based |
| E901 (Beeswax) | Glazing Agent | Bees | Non-Vegan (Always) | Carnauba Wax (E903) |
| E903 (Carnauba Wax) | Glazing Agent | Carnauba Palm Leaves | Vegan (Always) | N/A |
Practical Steps for Vegan Shopping
For a vegan, reading labels requires more than just checking for explicit animal products. Here are some steps to follow:
- Look for the Vegan Trademark: The most straightforward method. This symbol guarantees the product is free from animal ingredients and derivatives.
- Scrutinise the E-Numbers: Familiarise yourself with the list of 'always non-vegan' additives. If you see E120, E441, or E904, put the product back.
- Investigate Ambiguous Additives: For E-numbers with mixed origins like E471, look for further confirmation. Is the product labelled 'suitable for vegans'? Is there a disclaimer? If not, proceed with caution or contact the manufacturer.
- Use a Mobile App: A number of mobile applications can help you scan barcodes and instantly check if a product and its E-numbers are vegan-friendly.
- Prioritise Whole Foods: To avoid this complexity altogether, focus on whole, unprocessed foods like fresh fruits, vegetables, and legumes, which naturally contain no additives.
Conclusion: The Final Verdict
No, not all E-numbers are vegan. For those committed to a plant-based lifestyle, a careful and informed approach to reading food labels is essential. While many E-numbers are harmless, a significant minority are derived from animal products, and many others have ambiguous origins. By learning the key non-vegan additives and seeking out certified vegan products, consumers can navigate the grocery aisles with confidence, ensuring their food choices align with their ethical principles. Always remember that transparency varies between manufacturers, and when in doubt, a little extra investigation is warranted.