Why Werther's are not vegan
Most people assume that because a candy like Werther's is hard or chewy, it may not contain dairy. However, Werther's Original candies rely heavily on dairy for their classic taste and creamy texture. The core ingredients across the product line include:
- Cream: Fresh cream is a primary ingredient used to achieve the signature creamy, rich caramel flavor.
- Butter: Real butter is another key ingredient that contributes to the candy's smooth texture and classic buttery taste.
- Condensed Whey and Whey Powder: These are dairy byproducts used to add flavor and texture.
- Condensed Skim Milk: This is used in certain varieties to enhance the creamy mouthfeel.
These ingredients are found in the hard, chewy, and even sugar-free Werther's candies, as confirmed by both the manufacturer and ingredient analysis apps. For strict vegans, any product containing these animal-derived ingredients is unsuitable.
Are the sugar-free Werther's vegan?
Many people turn to the sugar-free version of candies, hoping they might be vegan. Unfortunately, the Werther's Original Sugar-Free Butter Candies are not vegan either. They also contain buttermilk and cream, which are derived from milk. The presence of these dairy ingredients, despite the absence of traditional sugar, means they are not a viable option for a plant-based diet.
What about other Werther's varieties?
The situation doesn't change with other popular Werther's products. For example, Werther's Soft Caramels and Werther's Chewy Caramels also contain milk and other dairy ingredients. The 'creamy' aspect of all Werther's candies is a direct result of using fresh cream and butter, making a vegan version from the original recipe impossible.
Vegan alternatives to Werther's
While no Werther's candies are suitable for vegans, the caramel craving doesn't have to go unanswered. Several brands offer delicious, cruelty-free caramel and butterscotch-flavored candies.
- Cocomels: This brand specializes in coconut milk caramel, which is a perfect vegan substitute. They come in various flavors and textures, including chews and mini-bites.
- Jeavons: This UK-based brand offers vegan toffee, including caramel options, that can satisfy a craving for a traditional caramel flavor.
- Grownup Chocolates / Mummy Meegz: For those looking for a caramel-filled chocolate experience, some brands offer vegan versions of classic treats, often made with oat milk.
- Hard Candies: Many classic fruity hard candies are vegan, such as Jolly Ranchers, Smarties (U.S. version), and Dum Dums. While not caramel, they can be a great sweet treat option.
When searching for vegan alternatives, always be sure to check the ingredient list for dairy products, as recipes can change.
Vegan vs. Vegetarian: A crucial distinction
It's important to understand the difference between vegan and vegetarian when considering Werther's. Werther's Original are technically vegetarian because they do not contain animal flesh, but they are not vegan due to the dairy content. The manufacturer even states that its products are suitable for vegetarians, except for specific bites with a coating of animal origin. This is a clear indicator that dairy is present throughout the standard product line. Vegans avoid all animal products and byproducts, including dairy, eggs, and gelatin.
Comparison of Werther's vs. Vegan Caramel Candies
| Feature | Werther's Original Hard Candy | Cocomels Coconut Milk Caramels | Vegan Town's Cotswold Caramel Fudge |
|---|---|---|---|
| Vegan | No | Yes | Yes |
| Dairy-Free | No | Yes | Yes |
| Key Ingredients | Cream, Butter, Condensed Whey | Coconut Milk, Organic Cane Sugar | Vegan Butterscotch, Caramel |
| Texture | Hard and smooth | Soft and chewy | Fudge-like and creamy |
| Flavor Profile | Creamy, buttery caramel | Rich, creamy coconut caramel | Buttery, sweet caramel |
Conclusion: No Werther's are vegan, but alternatives abound
In summary, for individuals adhering to a vegan lifestyle, Werther's Original candies—including their hard, chewy, and sugar-free varieties—are not an option due to their inclusion of dairy ingredients like cream and butter. While this classic candy remains off-limits, the growing market for plant-based sweets means there are numerous delicious and satisfying vegan caramel and butterscotch alternatives available. By carefully reading labels and exploring dedicated vegan brands, you can easily find a suitable and equally tasty treat. Don't be discouraged; the perfect cruelty-free caramel is out there, just not wrapped in gold.
What are vegan Werther's alternatives made of?
Vegan caramel alternatives often replace dairy with plant-based ingredients such as coconut milk, cashew cream, almond milk, or soy-based products. To achieve a creamy texture, alternative fats like palm oil or coconut oil may be used. The flavor is then crafted using a combination of natural and artificial flavorings that mimic traditional caramel.
How to check if a candy is vegan
When in doubt, the best approach is to read the ingredient list carefully. Look for common animal-derived ingredients such as:
- Milk, cream, butter, whey, or casein: Any product containing these is not vegan.
- Gelatin: Sometimes used for texture, this is derived from animal collagen.
- Confectioner's glaze (shellac): A coating made from the lac insect.
Mobile apps like Fig can also be very helpful for instantly checking if a product is vegan-friendly by scanning the barcode.
