Sulphates vs. Sulphites: A Critical Distinction for Drinkers
Many people confuse sulphates with sulphites, but they are entirely different chemical compounds with distinct origins and health implications. A sulphate is a mineral salt of sulphuric acid, often found naturally in water. On the other hand, sulphites are typically used as food preservatives and are the primary source of sensitivity concerns. The key to understanding the potential risks in your beverages is knowing which one you are dealing with.
Sulfates in Drinking Water
Sulphates occur naturally in groundwater, and while they are essential minerals for the body, high concentrations can cause issues. At levels exceeding 500 milligrams per liter (mg/L), they can impart a bitter or medicinal taste to water. The primary health effect associated with high sulphate water is a laxative effect, particularly when magnesium levels are also elevated. This is most noticeable in individuals who are not accustomed to drinking water with high sulphate levels, such as travelers or infants on formula. Health agencies often set maximum recommended levels based on taste rather than significant health risks for the general, non-sensitive population. Treatment options like reverse osmosis or distillation can effectively remove sulphates if necessary.
Sulfites: The Real Cause for Concern
For a small segment of the population, sulphites are a more serious health issue. Sulphites, which release sulphur dioxide gas, are added to a wide range of foods and drinks to prevent spoilage, discoloration, and bacterial growth. They are particularly common in beverages like wine, beer, cider, and many fruit juices. Adverse reactions to sulphites are not a true allergy but an intolerance or sensitivity that primarily affects people with asthma. Research suggests that up to 3-10% of asthmatics may experience adverse reactions, including wheezing, chest tightness, and coughing, after ingesting sulphites. Other symptoms can include hives, stomach pain, and, in rare cases, anaphylaxis. Due to this risk, food and drink containing more than 10 parts per million (ppm) of sulphites must be declared on the label in many countries.
Sulphates vs. Sulphites: A Quick Reference
| Aspect | Sulphates | Sulphites | 
|---|---|---|
| Composition | Mineral salts of sulfuric acid | Preservatives that release sulphur dioxide | 
| Origin | Naturally occurring in groundwater and some foods | Added as a preservative to inhibit microbial growth and oxidation | 
| Found In | Drinking water (especially from wells), some mineral waters | Wine, beer, cider, dried fruits, some juices, processed foods | 
| Primary Health Effect | Laxative effect at high concentrations; unpleasant taste | Respiratory irritation (especially in asthmatics), hives, gastrointestinal issues | 
| Sensitive Population | Infants, new consumers of high-sulphate water | People with asthma; those with a sulfite sensitivity | 
Common Drinks and Their Sulphite Content
Identifying sulphite-containing drinks is crucial for those with sensitivities. While some beverages, like white wine, typically contain higher levels, even those labeled 'no added sulfites' will have trace amounts due to natural fermentation. Here are some common examples of drinks that may contain sulphites:
- Wine and Beer: Sulphites are used to prevent oxidation and bacterial growth, with higher levels often found in white and sweet wines compared to red.
- Cordials and Fruit Juices: Added to maintain color and prevent spoilage.
- Soft Drinks and Cider: Often used as a preservative to extend shelf life.
- Lemon and Lime Juice Concentrates: Sulphites prevent browning and spoilage.
- Instant Tea: A potential source of sulphites as a preservative.
Conclusion
The verdict on whether sulfates in drinks are bad for you is clear: for most people, the risk from sulphates is minimal and relates primarily to gastrointestinal effects at very high, unpleasant-tasting levels. The real cause for adverse reactions is sulphites, a completely different additive used as a preservative. If you have asthma or a known sulphite sensitivity, it is essential to read labels carefully and be aware of your triggers. Consulting with a healthcare professional can help you navigate this issue effectively. For the general public, the focus should remain on overall diet rather than disproportionate worry over the trace amounts of sulphates found in most beverages.
Learn more about adverse reactions to sulphite additives from the National Institutes of Health here.