From Artificial to Natural: The Great Color Shift of 2016
For decades, the famously vibrant orange hue of Kraft Mac & Cheese was achieved using a blend of artificial food dyes, most notably Yellow 5 and Yellow 6. These synthetic colorings, derived from petroleum, faced increasing scrutiny from consumers and advocacy groups over potential health concerns, particularly regarding hyperactivity in children. In response to this consumer pressure, Kraft Heinz quietly reformulated its classic product, replacing the artificial dyes with natural alternatives in its U.S. recipe by January 2016.
The New, Naturally-Sourced Colorants
To maintain the iconic cheesy color without synthetic ingredients, Kraft turned to natural food colorants derived from spices and seeds. The key players in the new recipe include annatto, paprika, and turmeric.
-
Annatto: This vibrant yellow-to-orange coloring agent comes from the seeds of the achiote tree, which is native to tropical regions of the Americas. Annatto contains antioxidant compounds, but in rare cases, it can cause allergic reactions or trigger symptoms in individuals with irritable bowel syndrome (IBS). The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) lists annatto extract as a color additive "exempt from certification," and it is commonly used in many other processed foods like butter and margarine.
-
Paprika: A spice made from dried red peppers, paprika naturally adds a reddish-orange hue. It is also a source of antioxidants and other beneficial compounds.
-
Turmeric: This yellow spice from a ginger-related plant is well-known for its vibrant color and is a staple in various cuisines. It also possesses anti-inflammatory properties.
A Deeper Look at Annatto: Source, Safety, and Science
Annatto is a fascinating ingredient with a long history. Used for centuries for coloring food, cosmetics, and even as body paint, it is extracted from the reddish outer coating (arils) of the seeds of the Bixa orellana tree. The pigments responsible for its color are carotenoids called bixin and norbixin. Bixin is oil-soluble, while norbixin is water-soluble, allowing annatto to be used in a wide range of food products.
While generally recognized as safe, it is important to note that "natural" does not always mean risk-free for everyone. The Center for Science in the Public Interest (CSPI) notes that annatto allergies, though rare, appear to be more common than reactions to many synthetic food dyes. Symptoms of an annatto allergy can include hives, swelling, and abdominal pain.
Comparing the Old and New Recipes
For the curious consumer, a side-by-side comparison of the ingredients reveals the significant shift in Kraft's approach to food coloring. This table highlights the change, focusing specifically on the coloring agents used.
| Feature | Original U.S. Recipe (Pre-2016) | New U.S. Recipe (Post-2016) |
|---|---|---|
| Coloring Agents | Artificial Yellow 5 and Yellow 6 | Natural Annatto, Paprika, and Turmeric |
| Sourcing | Synthetically produced from petroleum | Naturally derived from plant sources |
| Key Health Concerns | Linked to hyperactivity in sensitive children, potential cancer risks for some synthetic dyes (though Yellow 5/6 were permitted) | Annatto has been linked to rare allergic reactions and IBS symptoms in sensitive individuals |
| General Nutrition | Remained a processed food with high sodium and saturated fat content | Still considered an ultra-processed food with similar sodium and fat content despite the color change |
The Bigger Picture: Nutrition and Processed Foods
Removing artificial dyes was a step toward simpler ingredients, but it did not fundamentally alter the nutritional profile of Kraft Mac & Cheese. The product remains a processed food, often high in sodium, saturated fat, and refined carbohydrates, which should be consumed in moderation as part of a balanced diet. Health experts recommend limiting ultra-processed foods, regardless of whether their coloring is artificial or natural. While the change to natural colorants is a positive move for those specifically concerned about synthetic additives, it doesn't transform the product into a health food. Consumers should consider the overall nutritional content and place of such products in their diet.
Conclusion
To directly answer the question, "Are there dyes in Kraft mac and cheese?" the U.S. version of the iconic blue box does contain dyes, but they are no longer artificial. As of 2016, synthetic colorings Yellow 5 and Yellow 6 were replaced with natural alternatives like annatto, paprika, and turmeric. While this addresses a significant concern for some consumers, particularly parents, it is important to remember that the product remains a processed food. The nutritional value beyond the coloring agents, such as high sodium and fat content, is a more crucial consideration for a balanced diet. This shift reflects a broader consumer trend toward more recognizable ingredients, but it’s a reminder for health-conscious individuals to look beyond a single ingredient change when evaluating a product's overall nutritional impact. For further reading, an article from the Environmental Working Group provides excellent context on this reformulation: The Real Deal Behind Kraft's "New" Mac & Cheese.
