Introduction to Nutritional Scoring
Nutrient profiling systems are designed to classify or rank foods based on their nutritional composition, providing a simplified visual summary for consumers. Instead of requiring a deep dive into the mandatory nutrition facts panel, these scores offer an at-a-glance snapshot of a food's healthiness. Various systems exist, each with its own methodology, but they all share the fundamental goal of translating complex nutritional data into an easy-to-understand format. By focusing on a balance of beneficial and less-desirable nutrients, these scores can guide healthier choices and even motivate manufacturers to reformulate their products.
The Nutri-Score System
The Nutri-Score is a voluntary, five-color front-of-package labeling system first adopted in France in 2017 and used across several European countries. It assigns a color and a letter—from dark green 'A' (most healthy) to dark orange 'E' (least healthy)—to products based on a calculation per 100 grams or 100 milliliters. The final score is determined by balancing "negative" points, given for ingredients to limit, against "positive" points, for ingredients to favor.
Step-by-Step Nutri-Score Calculation
To calculate the Nutri-Score for a product, you must first gather the nutritional information from the label. The process involves four main steps:
- Allocate Negative Points (N): A product receives points for its content of calories (energy), saturated fat, total sugars, and sodium per 100g/ml. A scoring table assigns 0 to 10 points for each of these four components based on their amount. The total N points are the sum of these values.
- Allocate Positive Points (P): Points are then awarded for favorable nutritional elements: protein, dietary fiber, and the percentage of fruits, vegetables, legumes, and nuts (FVLN). A separate scoring table assigns up to 5 points for fiber, up to 7 for protein, and up to 5 or 6 points for FVLN depending on the amount.
- Calculate the Final Score: The total positive points (P) are subtracted from the total negative points (N). The formula is:
Nutri-Score = Total N points - Total P points. There are specific algorithmic variations for certain food types, such as beverages, fats, and cheeses. - Determine the Final Grade: The final numerical score is converted to a letter grade (A-E) using a set range. For instance, a score of 0 or less typically receives an 'A', while a score of 19 or higher gets an 'E'.
The Nutrivore Score
Another approach is the Nutrivore Score, which measures nutrient density—the total nutrition a food delivers per calorie. Instead of just considering a few negative and positive factors, it evaluates over 30 essential and important nutrients relative to their daily values. The score is calculated by summing the percentage of daily values for these nutrients per 100 grams and then dividing by the food's energy density (calories). This method provides a comprehensive picture of how nourishing a food truly is, rather than just highlighting a few components. A higher Nutrivore Score indicates more nutrients packed into every calorie.
EWG's Food Scores
EWG's Food Scores offer a different, multi-faceted approach, providing an overall rating from 1 (best) to 10 (worst). The overall score is calculated by combining three separate scores:
- Nutrition: This is the most heavily weighted component and is based on a modified version of the UK's Food Standards Agency profiling system. It considers factors like calories, saturated fat, sugar, sodium, protein, and fiber.
- Ingredient Concerns: This score flags potential health or environmental concerns related to additives, contaminants, pesticides, hormones, and antibiotics.
- Processing: This score rates the extent to which a food product has been processed, based on factors like ingredient modification and the number of artificial ingredients.
By including these three elements, EWG's system aims to provide a more holistic view of a food product's quality beyond just its basic nutritional values.
Comparing Popular Nutrition Scoring Systems
| Feature | Nutri-Score | Nutrivore Score | EWG's Food Scores |
|---|---|---|---|
| Primary Goal | Simplify comparison within food categories. | Measure nutrient density (nutrients per calorie). | Assess nutritional value, processing level, and ingredient safety. |
| Key Factors | Energy, saturated fat, sugars, sodium, protein, fiber, FVLN. | 30+ essential and important nutrients. | Nutrition, ingredient concerns, processing. |
| Calculation Basis | Balance of negative and positive points per 100g/ml. | Sum of % daily values divided by calorie density. | Weighted combination of three separate scoring factors. |
| Focus | Front-of-pack label for quick comparison. | Comprehensive nutrient density evaluation. | Overall product quality, including non-nutritional aspects. |
| Output | Color-coded letter grade (A-E). | Numerical score. | Numerical score (1-10) with three sub-scores. |
Limitations and Considerations
While nutritional scores are valuable tools, it is crucial to understand their limitations. A single score can sometimes oversimplify the complexity of nutrition. For example, a healthy food like olive oil might receive a lower Nutri-Score (like a D) due to its high calorie and saturated fat content, even though it is beneficial in moderation. Some systems also do not account for the level of food processing, which is a key factor in overall health. Furthermore, personal dietary needs and health conditions are not reflected in a universal score. Therefore, using these scores as a quick guide for comparison between similar products is most effective, but they should not override common sense and broader dietary knowledge. For example, comparing two types of breakfast cereals using a Nutri-Score is a valid application, but comparing a cereal to a cheese is not.
Conclusion
Knowing how to calculate a nutrition score reveals the intricate algorithms that simplify complex food choices. Whether it's the A-E grade of Nutri-Score, the nutrient density ratio of Nutrivore, or the multi-factor evaluation of EWG, each system provides a different lens through which to view a food product's health profile. By understanding the methodology behind these scores, consumers can make more informed decisions at the grocery store. These tools are valuable aids in a health-conscious lifestyle, encouraging smarter swaps and a more balanced diet.
foodwatch.org - Nutri-Score: how to use a label to improve health and diet
Glossary of Terms
- Nutrient Profiling System (NPS): A method used to evaluate and rank foods based on their nutritional composition.
- Nutrient Density: The concentration of beneficial nutrients in a food relative to its calorie content.
- Daily Value (DV): The recommended intake levels for a nutrient, often used as a benchmark in nutrition calculations.
- Front-of-Package Labeling (FOPL): Simplified, interpretive symbols or scores placed on the front of food packaging to provide nutritional information.