Skip to content

How unhealthy is Jersey Mike's? An in-depth nutritional guide

4 min read

According to reports, some regular-sized Jersey Mike's sandwiches contain over 1,000 milligrams of sodium, a significant portion of the daily recommended limit. This guide addresses the pressing question: how unhealthy is Jersey Mike's and how can you make smarter choices?

Quick Summary

Analyzing Jersey Mike's menu reveals potential health concerns like high sodium and saturated fat in many subs. This guide explores the nutritional profile and provides expert tips for healthier meal choices and customization.

Key Points

  • High Sodium & Fat: Many Jersey Mike's subs are loaded with excessive sodium and saturated fat from cured meats, cheeses, and the oil blend.

  • Sub in a Tub: Ordering a sub in a bowl is the simplest way to drastically cut carbs and calories from bread.

  • Smart Protein Choices: Opt for lean proteins like turkey breast or roast beef over processed Italian meats to reduce sodium and saturated fat.

  • Customize Your Order: Skipping cheese, mayo, and oil can remove significant calories and unhealthy fats from your meal.

  • Veggies for Volume: Adding extra vegetables like lettuce, tomatoes, and onions boosts fiber and nutrients without adding many calories.

  • Smaller Portions: Choosing a mini or regular sub instead of a giant can make a substantial difference in overall calorie intake.

In This Article

Deciphering the Nutritional Realities at Jersey Mike's

While Jersey Mike's prides itself on fresh ingredients, a closer look at the nutritional information reveals several common pitfalls, primarily high sodium, excessive saturated fat, and surprising calorie counts. Many popular subs can contain a full day's worth of sodium in a single meal, and even seemingly light options can be loaded with hidden fats. Understanding these factors is key to navigating the menu successfully and aligning your choices with your health goals.

The Sodium and Saturated Fat Problem

Many of Jersey Mike's most popular subs derive their rich flavor from cured meats, cheeses, and the signature "Mike's Way" oil and vinegar blend. The cumulative effect of these ingredients often results in very high levels of sodium and saturated fat. For example, a regular-sized #13 Original Italian can deliver a staggering amount of sodium, largely due to the salami, prosciutto, and provolone. Similarly, hot subs like the Bacon Ranch Chicken Cheese Steak or the Philly steaks pack high saturated fat, much of it from the cheese.

Hidden Calorie Bombs

Even vegetarian options or simple additions can inflate the calorie count significantly. The #14 The Veggie, for instance, contains a substantial amount of saturated fat and calories from the provolone, Swiss cheese, and oil blend. Furthermore, a side of chips can add another 200-500 milligrams of sodium, depending on the flavor. To make healthier choices, it's crucial to evaluate every ingredient.

Healthier Menu Choices and Smart Customizations

Ordering smartly at Jersey Mike's means leveraging customization options to your advantage. By focusing on lean proteins and vegetable-heavy options, you can create a satisfying and nutritious meal.

Healthier Ordering Strategies:

  • Choose a "Sub in a Tub": This is the most effective way to reduce calories and carbs by removing the bread entirely. A Turkey and Provolone Bowl can come in at around 510 calories, versus over 700 for the sub.
  • Opt for Lean Protein: Lean turkey and roast beef are better choices than cured or fried meats. For example, ordering a mini #7 Turkey Breast & Provolone on wheat bread without mayo or oil is a solid option.
  • Limit or Remove Cheese: Cheese is a major contributor of saturated fat and sodium. Eliminating it, especially in hot subs, can significantly improve the nutritional profile.
  • Hold the Oil: The olive oil blend adds a high number of calories. Skipping it or requesting just a touch can save hundreds of calories.
  • Pile on the Veggies: Load up on lettuce, tomatoes, onions, pickles, and banana peppers. These add flavor, fiber, and nutrients without heavy calories.

How to Build a Healthier Sub:

  1. Protein: Turkey breast, roast beef, or grilled portabella mushrooms.
  2. Size: Choose a mini or regular size over the giant.
  3. Veggies: Add fresh lettuce, onions, tomatoes, and bell peppers.
  4. Condiments: Use a small amount of red wine vinegar instead of the oil blend. Opt for mustard instead of mayo.
  5. Cheese: Skip it or ask for a light amount of provolone or Swiss.

Comparison Table: Jersey Mike's vs. Subway

To understand the nutritional landscape better, comparing Jersey Mike's to another major chain like Subway can be helpful. While nutritional information varies by sandwich, here's a general comparison based on typical deli meat options.

Feature Jersey Mike's (Regular) Subway (Footlong)
Portion Size Regular sub is smaller than Subway's footlong. However, Jersey Mike's portions of meat are typically more generous. Standard footlong is a larger portion overall, but with less meat per inch.
Calories Can range from 500-1100+ calories depending on the sub and toppings. Generally lower calorie options available, though heavy additions increase count.
Sodium Often very high, with many regular subs exceeding the daily recommended limit. Typically lower on comparable sandwiches, though still relatively high for fast food.
Saturated Fat High saturated fat from cheese and cured meats is common, sometimes meeting the full daily value. Lower on average, especially with lean proteins.
Customization Offers the "Sub in a Tub" and easy customization. Offers robust customization options and salad formats.

Conclusion: Eating Responsibly at Jersey Mike's

Jersey Mike's can be an unhealthy choice if you don't pay attention to your order. The combination of cured meats, generous cheese portions, and the oil blend can create subs that are excessively high in calories, sodium, and saturated fat. However, the restaurant offers enough customization to allow for healthier choices. By opting for a low-carb "Sub in a Tub" with lean protein, skipping the cheese, and limiting the high-fat dressings, you can enjoy a satisfying meal that better fits your dietary goals. The key takeaway is to be mindful and deliberate with your ordering, viewing Jersey Mike's as a flexible fast-food option rather than a consistently healthy one.

For more detailed nutritional information, consult the official Jersey Mike's nutrition calculator on their website.

The Takeaway

Making healthy choices at Jersey Mike's is possible with a few modifications to your order. The difference between a nutritional pitfall and a balanced meal is in the details, so be strategic about your ingredients.

Frequently Asked Questions

Many of Jersey Mike's standard subs are high in sodium, saturated fat, and calories due to cured meats, cheese, and oil, making them a less healthy choice if not customized.

A mini #7 Turkey Breast & Provolone or a "Sub in a Tub" with lean protein and plenty of vegetables is often considered one of the healthiest options, especially when skipping high-fat condiments like mayo and oil.

To reduce sodium, avoid cured meats (salami, capicola, pepperoni) and cheese, as these are major contributors. Leaner meats like turkey or roast beef are better, and you can also request less seasoning salt.

A "Sub in a Tub" is the contents of a sub—meat, cheese, and toppings—served in a bowl, with the bread removed. This is a significantly healthier option, especially for those watching carbs or calories.

Yes, Jersey Mike's cheese steaks, including the Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak and the Mike's Famous Philly, are generally high in calories, sodium, and saturated fat due to the beef/chicken, cheese, and bread.

The olive oil blend, particularly when applied "Mike's Way," adds a significant amount of calories and fat. Skipping it can save over 200 calories on some subs.

The standard veggie sub is surprisingly high in saturated fat and calories from the provolone and Swiss cheeses and the oil blend. To make it healthier, it is best to remove the cheese.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.