Understanding the Spectrum of Food Processing
Food processing exists on a spectrum. Minimally processed foods undergo minimal changes, while ultra-processed foods are heavily altered with additives. Natural cheese falls in the middle, using traditional techniques, whereas industrial processed cheese is closer to ultra-processed due to added emulsifiers.
The Creation of Natural Cheese
Natural cheese production transforms milk into a solid form through fermentation and enzymes. Key steps involve milk preparation, acidification, coagulation, cutting and cooking curds, draining whey, pressing curds, salting, and aging. Examples like Cheddar and Brie follow these steps without extensive additives.
The Industrial Process of Creating Processed Cheese
Processed cheese involves re-engineering natural cheese to achieve uniformity and meltability. This includes blending natural cheeses with other ingredients, adding emulsifying salts to prevent separation when heated, heating the mixture, and packaging. Some processed cheese products may contain as little as 51% actual cheese.
Comparison Table: Natural vs. Processed Cheese
| Feature | Natural Cheese | Processed Cheese | 
|---|---|---|
| Key Ingredients | Milk, salt, starter culture, rennet | Natural cheese, emulsifying salts, whey, milk protein concentrate, flavorings, stabilizers | 
| Manufacturing Process | Coagulation, aging (curing) | Melting, blending, adding emulsifiers and other additives | 
| Texture | Can be grainy, firm, or creamy, depending on type and aging | Homogeneous, soft, and creamy with consistent melting | 
| Flavor | Complex, diverse, and develops over time with aging | Milder, more consistent, and less complex | 
| Nutritional Profile | Generally higher protein and fat, lower sodium | Can have higher sodium and sometimes less overall nutrients due to additives | 
| Shelf Life | Shorter shelf life, requires refrigeration | Longer shelf life due to preservatives | 
Implications for Consumers
Understanding the difference helps consumers choose based on taste and health preferences. Natural cheese offers diverse flavors, while processed cheese provides consistency. Processed cheese often has more sodium and additives than natural varieties.
Conclusion: A Clear Distinction
Not all cheese is the same type of processed food. Natural cheesemaking uses fermentation and aging, distinct from industrial processed cheese production which involves combining cheese with other ingredients and emulsifiers. Reading labels can help distinguish between them. The choice depends on preferences for ingredients, taste, and production methods.