What Causes the White Spots? The Phenomenon of Chocolate Bloom
That dusty or streaky white film that sometimes appears on chocolate is known as 'chocolate bloom'. This is not a sign of contamination or spoilage, but rather a cosmetic change resulting from improper storage conditions. There are two distinct types of bloom, both of which are completely harmless to consume. The appearance and texture will differ slightly depending on whether the issue is with the fat or the sugar in the chocolate.
Fat Bloom: When Cocoa Butter Migrates
Fat bloom is the more common of the two types of chocolate bloom and is primarily caused by temperature fluctuations. Chocolate contains cocoa butter, which consists of fats with different melting points. When chocolate is exposed to warm temperatures, the cocoa butter softens and separates from the other ingredients. It then rises to the surface through tiny cracks and pores. When the chocolate re-cools, the fat re-solidifies and re-crystallizes in an unstable form, appearing as a dull, gray or whitish film. This can happen from leaving a chocolate bar in a warm car or storing it in a cabinet that gets too hot. While the texture may become soft or crumbly, it remains safe to eat.
Sugar Bloom: The Effects of Moisture
Sugar bloom is caused by moisture coming into contact with the chocolate. This can happen in a humid environment or, more commonly, when chocolate is stored in the refrigerator. As the cold chocolate is brought to warmer room temperature, condensation forms on the surface. This moisture dissolves the sugar in the chocolate. When the water evaporates, the sugar re-crystallizes into larger, rougher crystals on the surface, creating a grainy, dusty-white coating. Milk and white chocolates are more susceptible to sugar bloom due to their higher sugar content.
Chocolate Bloom vs. Mold: How to Tell the Difference
At first glance, some may mistake bloom for mold, but they are very different. Chocolate is an extremely inhospitable environment for mold growth due to its low moisture content. Mold on chocolate is rare and would only occur under very specific, prolonged, and humid conditions. A few key indicators can help you differentiate between the two.
Bloom vs. Mold Comparison Table
| Characteristic | Chocolate Bloom | Mold on Chocolate | 
|---|---|---|
| Appearance | Dull, grayish-white film or streaks; can be powdery or waxy. | Irregular, fuzzy or slimy patches; may be green, gray, or black. | 
| Texture | Dry, powdery, or waxy to the touch; can feel grainy if sugar bloomed. | Fuzzy or slimy to the touch; not powdery. | 
| Smell | Retains its normal chocolate aroma. | Often has a musty or unpleasant, off-putting odor. | 
| Safety | Completely safe to eat. | Unsafe; food poisoning risk. | 
| Cause | Temperature fluctuations (fat bloom) or moisture exposure (sugar bloom). | Fungal growth due to moisture, air, and heat. | 
What to Do with Bloomed Chocolate
So, you've confirmed that your chocolate's white spots are just bloom. Now what? You have a few options, depending on your preferences and the final use for the chocolate. Since the flavor is largely unaffected, many people choose to simply enjoy it as is, despite the textural difference.
If you're not a fan of the texture, here are some ways to repurpose bloomed chocolate:
- Melt it for baking: Heat will remelt and reincorporate the fat and sugar crystals, restoring its smooth consistency. This is a great solution for chocolate chips or blocks used in brownies, cookies, or cakes.
- Make hot cocoa or ganache: Melting the chocolate into a liquid form is an easy way to hide the cosmetic imperfections and enjoy the flavor.
- Re-temper it: For the ambitious home cook, you can melt down and re-temper the chocolate to stabilize the crystal structure and restore its original glossy finish and snap. This works best with high-quality chocolate with a higher cocoa butter content.
Tips for Preventing Chocolate Bloom
Proper storage is the key to preventing chocolate bloom. Keeping your chocolate in a stable environment will maintain its aesthetic appeal and ideal texture for longer.
- Store in a cool, dry place: The ideal storage temperature for chocolate is between 15°C and 20°C (59°F and 64°F). A pantry or cupboard is often the best location, as it is dark, cool, and dry.
- Avoid the refrigerator (if possible): Refrigerators have high humidity and can cause condensation when the chocolate is removed, leading to sugar bloom. If refrigeration is necessary in a hot climate, place the chocolate in an airtight container to protect it from moisture and odor absorption. Allow it to come to room temperature while still in the container before opening to prevent condensation.
- Maintain consistent temperatures: Avoid sudden temperature changes or storing chocolate near heat sources like ovens or direct sunlight. Constant temperature is more important than a slightly colder one, within reason.
- Use airtight packaging: Keep chocolate tightly wrapped in its original packaging or in an airtight container to protect it from moisture and strong odors, which cocoa butter can easily absorb.
Conclusion
For anyone asking, is chocolate with white spots ok to eat?, rest assured that in most cases, the answer is yes. The harmless white film is a natural and common phenomenon called 'chocolate bloom' and not a sign of spoilage. By understanding the difference between fat bloom (caused by temperature) and sugar bloom (caused by moisture), you can confidently know that your treat is safe to consume. While the texture may be slightly compromised, the flavor remains intact, and the chocolate can be repurposed for baking or sauces. With a few simple storage precautions—keeping it in a cool, dry, and stable environment—you can prevent bloom and enjoy your chocolate in its most pristine form. For more information on food safety standards, you can consult reliable sources like the Canadian Food Inspection Agency (CFIA).