Skip to content

Is EDTA in mayonnaise bad for you? An honest look at the additive

3 min read

Food-grade calcium disodium EDTA, a synthetic compound, has been approved by major regulatory bodies like the U.S. FDA and EFSA for decades and is generally considered safe for the majority of the population when used in regulated amounts. When it comes to the question, "Is EDTA in mayonnaise bad for you?", the answer depends on individual health factors, but for most people, the minimal quantity used poses no risk.

Quick Summary

Food-grade calcium disodium EDTA is a safe chelating agent that prevents mayonnaise spoilage and oxidation. While high doses are dangerous, small amounts in food are generally considered harmless, though people with intestinal inflammation may be sensitive.

Key Points

  • Food-Grade Safety: The FDA and other major health authorities consider calcium disodium EDTA in mayonnaise safe in small, regulated amounts for most people.

  • Not for Medical Use: The high doses of EDTA used in medical chelation therapy for heavy metal poisoning are very different from the low amounts found in food.

  • Prevents Spoilage: EDTA acts as a chelating agent in mayonnaise, binding to trace metals that would otherwise cause rancidity and discoloration of the oil.

  • Minimal Absorption: When consumed through food, the body absorbs less than 5% of calcium disodium EDTA, with the rest harmlessly excreted.

  • Risk for Vulnerable Groups: Recent animal studies suggest potential risks, such as increased intestinal permeability and inflammation, for individuals with pre-existing inflammatory bowel conditions.

  • How to Avoid It: Individuals concerned about EDTA can limit intake by choosing whole foods, making their own mayonnaise, and carefully reading ingredient labels.

In This Article

What is EDTA and its purpose in food?

Ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid, or EDTA, is a chelating agent that binds to metal ions. In processed foods like mayonnaise, calcium disodium EDTA is used to prevent trace metal contaminants from causing oxidative rancidity and color changes. By trapping these metals, it stabilizes the product, extending shelf life and preserving flavor and appearance.

How EDTA stabilizes mayonnaise

Mayonnaise, an oil and water emulsion, contains polyunsaturated fats in the oil that are susceptible to oxidation from light, heat, or trace metals, leading to rancidity and discoloration. EDTA prevents this by binding these metals, stopping them from catalyzing oxidation. This mechanism is also employed in other products like salad dressings and canned foods.

Is EDTA in mayonnaise safe?

Calcium disodium EDTA in mayonnaise is widely considered safe for most consumers. The FDA recognizes it as "Generally Recognized as Safe" (GRAS) within set limits, and other international bodies like the EFSA and JECFA also approve its use.

Low absorption and excretion

The body poorly absorbs ingested calcium disodium EDTA, with less than 5% entering the bloodstream. Most of the compound, along with bound metals, is quickly excreted. The amount in mayonnaise is also very small, well below Acceptable Daily Intake levels, making it safe for most individuals.

High-dose vs. Food-grade EDTA: A critical distinction

Concerns about food-grade EDTA often confuse it with the high-dose versions used in medical chelation therapy. Medical therapy uses much higher, intravenously administered doses to treat severe heavy metal poisoning. These high doses can cause side effects like kidney damage and mineral deficiencies, which are not relevant to the small amounts in food.

Feature Food-Grade EDTA (Calcium Disodium EDTA) Medical Chelation Therapy (High-Dose EDTA)
Purpose Stabilizes processed foods, prevents rancidity and discoloration. Removes toxic heavy metals like lead from the body.
Dosage Very small, highly regulated amounts (e.g., up to 165 ppm in some foods). Much larger doses administered under strict medical supervision.
Absorption Poorly absorbed by the body (less than 5%). Intravenously administered, ensuring high systemic absorption.
Risks Minimal risk for most people; potential for concern in those with intestinal inflammation. Serious risks possible, including kidney damage and mineral depletion.
Regulation Approved as safe by the FDA and other international bodies for food use. Administered only by medical professionals to treat specific conditions.

Emerging concerns and how to mitigate risk

While food-grade EDTA is safe for the general population, recent animal studies suggest potential concerns for individuals with pre-existing intestinal inflammation. A 2021 Nature study showed that in mouse models with intestinal inflammation, EDTA worsened the inflammation and increased the risk of colorectal cancer. This appears to be due to EDTA disrupting the intestinal barrier.

This research indicates that people with inflammatory bowel diseases (IBD) might be more sensitive to dietary EDTA, even at levels considered safe for healthy individuals. While human data is still limited, these studies highlight the importance of individual health factors.

How to reduce your EDTA intake if you are concerned

  • Read ingredient labels: Check labels for "calcium disodium EDTA" or "EDTA" in processed foods.
  • Choose whole foods: Opting for whole, unprocessed foods helps avoid all additives, including EDTA. Making mayonnaise from scratch gives control over ingredients.
  • Select organic options: Organic products typically do not use synthetic additives like EDTA, but always check labels.
  • Look for alternative preservatives: Some brands use natural preservatives like citric acid or vinegar.

Conclusion

For most healthy individuals, the small, regulated amount of calcium disodium EDTA in mayonnaise is safe. It prevents spoilage by chelating trace metals, unlike the high-dose therapy for heavy metal poisoning. However, emerging animal research suggests a potential risk for those with inflammatory intestinal conditions. To avoid synthetic additives, choose whole foods or make fresh condiments. More information on EDTA in food preservation is available from sources like the Center for Science in the Public Interest.

Frequently Asked Questions

Calcium disodium EDTA is a synthetic compound added to foods like mayonnaise to act as a preservative and chelating agent. It prevents oxidation and spoilage by binding to trace metal ions.

Mayonnaise contains oil, which is prone to becoming rancid and changing color due to oxidation catalyzed by trace metals. EDTA binds these metals, halting the oxidation process and preserving the product's quality and shelf life.

No, or very minimally. When ingested through food, calcium disodium EDTA is very poorly absorbed by the digestive system, with approximately 95% of it passing through the body and being excreted.

Food-grade EDTA is used in minute, regulated quantities to preserve food, while medical chelation therapy involves high-dose intravenous administration to treat life-threatening heavy metal poisoning. The dosage and context are vastly different.

Recent animal studies have shown that EDTA can aggravate intestinal inflammation and increase permeability in subjects with pre-existing conditions like IBD. While human data is limited, those with intestinal issues may choose to limit exposure.

Yes. Many mayonnaise brands, especially organic, natural, or small-batch options, do not use EDTA and instead rely on other preservatives like vinegar or citric acid. The ingredient label will specify if calcium disodium EDTA is included.

For healthy individuals, consuming small, regulated amounts of EDTA in food is not considered a long-term health risk, according to major regulatory bodies. The compound is not carcinogenic and is minimally absorbed.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.