Is it better for you to drink cold water?

According to a 2012 study, drinking cold water during exercise can help your body from overheating and potentially improve workout performance. But beyond the gym, is it better for you to drink cold water for overall health? This article delves into the research to compare the benefits and drawbacks of different water temperatures for your body.

Quick Summary

The long-standing debate over cold versus warm water for hydration is explored. This article compares the benefits and drawbacks of each temperature, covering topics from digestion and calorie expenditure to potential side effects and workout performance.

Key Points

• Exercise Performance: Cold water is superior for cooling the body during and after workouts, which can improve endurance.

• Digestion: Warm or room-temperature water is often better for digestion, as cold water can cause discomfort for sensitive individuals.

• Metabolism: Drinking cold water provides a very small, temporary metabolic boost as your body expends energy to warm it.

• Hydration: The most important factor is drinking enough water consistently, regardless of the temperature.

• Health Conditions: Individuals with migraines or achalasia should be cautious, as cold water can worsen their symptoms.

• Daily Routine: A balanced approach, using different temperatures for different situations (e.g., cold for exercise, warm for digestion), is often best.

The Science of Cold Water: Benefits and Risks

There is a common misconception that drinking cold water is bad for you, primarily based on the idea that it shocks your system and hinders digestion. However, modern scientific evidence paints a more nuanced picture. While there are some potential risks, especially for certain medical conditions, cold water also offers distinct advantages, particularly in specific situations.

Benefits of Drinking Cold Water

• Enhanced Exercise Performance: When exercising, especially in hot environments, your core body temperature rises. Consuming cold water can help lower this temperature more effectively than room-temperature water, which can delay the onset of overheating and improve endurance during your workout.
• Small Metabolic Boost: Your body expends a small amount of energy to warm up any cold liquid you consume to match your internal temperature. While the effect is minimal—estimates suggest around eight calories per glass—it can contribute to your overall metabolism and might aid in weight management over time.
• Improved Alertness: The refreshing sensation of cold water can provide a quick mental pick-me-up and increase alertness, helping to fight fatigue.
• Taste Preference: Many people simply prefer the taste of cold water, which can encourage them to drink more and stay better hydrated throughout the day. This is arguably the most significant benefit, as consistent hydration is crucial regardless of temperature.

Risks and Considerations for Cold Water

• Potential for Headaches: For individuals prone to migraines, drinking ice-cold water has been linked to triggering headaches. A 2001 study found that a small percentage of women experienced a headache after consuming ice-cold water, with the effect being more pronounced in those with a history of migraines.
• May Aggravate Achalasia: This rare condition affects the esophagus and can make swallowing difficult. Studies have shown that cold water can worsen the symptoms of achalasia, while warm water may help relax the esophagus.
• Nasal Congestion: An older 1978 study found that drinking cold water made nasal mucus thicker and more difficult to pass. This suggests that if you have a cold or the flu, cold water might exacerbate your congestion.

The Advantages of Warm Water

While cold water has its place, warm or room-temperature water is not without its own set of merits. Many cultures, particularly in traditional Chinese medicine, have long advocated for warm water consumption to aid digestion and promote balance.

Benefits of Drinking Warm Water

• Supports Digestion: Warm water can stimulate the digestive system and aid in the breakdown of food, potentially preventing discomfort and constipation.
• Promotes Relaxation: A warm drink can have a soothing effect on the nervous system and is often recommended for promoting relaxation, especially before bed.
• Aids Detoxification: Some believe that warm water can promote mild perspiration, helping the body to release toxins.
• Better for Oral Health: For those with sensitive teeth, warm or room-temperature water avoids the sharp pain that very cold water can cause by irritating sensitive nerves.

Comparison Table: Cold Water vs. Warm Water

Feature	Cold Water	Warm Water
Digestive Impact	Can potentially slow digestion and cause discomfort in sensitive individuals.	Aids digestion, relaxes the esophageal muscles, and supports bowel movements.
Exercise & Rehydration	Excellent for cooling the body during or after a workout, improving endurance.	Not as effective for rapid cooling. Optimal for post-workout recovery by improving circulation.
Metabolic Effect	Creates a small, temporary metabolic boost as the body works to warm it.	May also provide a slight metabolic increase and aid in overall metabolism.
Taste & Intake	Often preferred for its refreshing taste, which can encourage greater overall water consumption.	Less appealing to some, potentially leading to lower intake. Can suppress thirst on hot days.
Risk for Migraines	May trigger headaches in individuals prone to migraines.	Does not carry the same risk for cold-induced headaches.
Optimal Use Case	Exercise, hot weather, alertness, rapid refreshment.	Digestion, relaxation, detoxification, relieving congestion.

What's the best approach for daily hydration?

For most healthy individuals, the best approach is to listen to your body and choose the temperature that makes you drink more consistently. The most critical factor is not the temperature, but simply staying adequately hydrated throughout the day, regardless of the water's temperature. Choosing the water temperature can be a matter of personal preference and circumstance.

Here is a good strategy to follow:

• Post-Workout: Reach for a glass of cold water to cool down and rehydrate effectively.
• After Meals: Consider warm or room-temperature water to assist your body with digestion.
• Morning Routine: Start your day with a glass of warm water to gently boost your metabolism and digestion.
• General Hydration: Drink room-temperature water throughout the day. It is absorbed by the body most quickly and is less likely to cause discomfort.

Conclusion: Personal Preference Reigns Supreme

There is no conclusive evidence to suggest that drinking cold water is inherently harmful for healthy individuals. Instead, the most important aspect is consistent hydration. While cold water offers advantages for cooling and alertness, especially during exercise, warm water is often better for digestion. Ultimately, the choice between cold or warm water largely comes down to personal preference, the situation, and any specific health considerations. The best approach is to balance your hydration routine, choosing the temperature that encourages you to drink enough to meet your daily needs. For more details on recommended daily water intake, visit the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine.

---

Lists of Cold and Warm Water Benefits

Benefits of Cold Water

• Cools the Body: Helps lower core temperature, especially during or after exercise.
• Boosts Alertness: Provides an invigorating sensation to increase mental focus.
• Increases Hydration Intake: Many people prefer the taste, encouraging them to drink more often.
• Small Metabolic Lift: Burns a minor number of extra calories as the body warms the water.

Benefits of Warm Water

• Aids Digestion: Stimulates the digestive tract and can help break down food.
• Relieves Congestion: Can help loosen mucus during a cold or flu.
• Supports Detoxification: Promotes mild perspiration, assisting the body in releasing toxins.
• Calms the Nervous System: Has a soothing, relaxing effect, beneficial before sleep.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

Does drinking cold water cause weight gain?

No, drinking cold water does not cause weight gain. On the contrary, your body expends a small number of calories to warm the water to your internal body temperature, which can slightly boost your metabolism and aid in weight management.

Can cold water harm your digestive system?

For most healthy individuals, drinking cold water does not cause significant harm. However, for those with sensitive digestive systems, it might cause discomfort or slow down digestion by constricting blood vessels.

Which water temperature is best for hydration?

For most effective hydration, room-temperature water is absorbed the fastest by the body. However, the key is drinking enough water regularly, and many people drink more when it's cold because they prefer the taste.

Can drinking cold water trigger headaches?

Yes, for some individuals, particularly those who are prone to migraines, drinking very cold or iced water can trigger headaches.

Is drinking warm water on an empty stomach beneficial?

Drinking warm water first thing in the morning is a common practice believed to help boost metabolism, aid digestion, and remove toxins from the body.

Should you drink cold water when you have a cold?

If you have a cold or flu, it may be better to avoid cold water. Some studies suggest cold water can thicken nasal mucus, potentially making congestion worse.

Is it safe to drink cold water during intense exercise?

Yes, drinking cold water during exercise is highly beneficial as it helps lower your core body temperature and can improve performance and endurance, especially in hot conditions.