Understanding the Levels of Food Processing
To determine if Jack and Annie's products are ultra-processed, it's essential to understand the term's meaning. The NOVA classification system, created by Brazilian scientists, is the most accepted framework. This system categorizes foods by processing extent.
The NOVA Food Classification System
- Group 1: Unprocessed and Minimally Processed Foods. These are whole foods in their natural state or with minimal alterations that don't add or change ingredients. Examples include fruits, vegetables, eggs, and raw meats.
- Group 2: Processed Culinary Ingredients. These are substances derived from Group 1 foods that are used for cooking, like oils, sugar, and salt.
- Group 3: Processed Foods. Simple products made by combining Group 1 and 2 ingredients. Canned vegetables, plain bread made from flour, water, salt, and yeast, and cheeses fall into this category.
- Group 4: Ultra-Processed Foods (UPFs). Industrial formulations that combine ingredients from the other groups with industrial additives not typically used in home cooking. These include preservatives, emulsifiers, flavorings, and stabilizers. Examples are fizzy drinks, breakfast cereals with additives, and packaged snacks.
Jack and Annie's: An Ingredient Review
Jack and Annie's focuses on jackfruit, a whole food valued for its natural meaty texture and nutritional benefits. However, turning raw jackfruit into convenient products like nuggets, patties, and sausages means they move beyond 'minimally processed'.
Industrial Ingredients in Jack & Annie's Products
Many Jack and Annie's items have ingredients indicating a higher processing level, aligning with NOVA Group 4 criteria. These include:
- Methylcellulose: A plant fiber derivative used as a thickener and binder. It is not found in home kitchens and is a strong industrial processing indicator.
- Natural Flavor(s): In processed foods, this term signifies complex ingredient mixtures made in a lab to enhance taste.
- Yeast Extract: An additive providing a savory, umami flavor. Its isolated use in food formulations is an industrial practice.
- Soy Flour: A concentrated source of soy protein used for texture and protein content, a refinement of a whole food.
- Added Sugars: Ingredients like brown sugar and raw sugar are found in some products, such as the Plant Based Sausage Sandwich, further contributing to its ultra-processed status.
EWG Ratings and Product Variety
The Environmental Working Group (EWG) scores foods based on nutritional content, ingredient concerns, and processing, offering further insight. Ratings for Jack and Annie's products differ, highlighting the importance of label checks.
- Moderate Processing Concerns: Products like the Crispy Jackfruit Nuggets and Maple Breakfast Jackfruit Sausage Links receive this rating, showing a notable industrial processing level beyond minimal modification.
- High Processing Concerns: The Plant Based Sausage With Real Cheese, Egg & Spinach Vegetarian Sandwich is rated high by EWG due to a long ingredients list, including added sugars and emulsifiers like monoglycerides. This demonstrates varying processing levels within the same brand.
The Health Implications of Ultra-Processed Foods
Research links high ultra-processed food consumption to health issues, including weight gain, type 2 diabetes, heart disease, and cancers. While research continues regarding whether processing itself or the high fat, sugar, and salt levels are the cause, the association is evident. Many UPFs are formulated to encourage overconsumption and often replace nutrient-dense whole foods.
NIH study on ultra-processed foods
What are the implications for Jack & Annie's?
With industrial additives like methylcellulose and natural flavors in many products, most Jack and Annie's products are ultra-processed, according to the NOVA system. However, the use of a nutritious base ingredient like jackfruit provides some fiber and protein, unlike many UPFs. The degree of ultra-processing varies by product, so checking the label is best.
Comparison: Unprocessed vs. Processed vs. Ultra-Processed
| Feature | Unprocessed / Minimally Processed | Processed (NOVA Group 3) | Ultra-Processed (NOVA Group 4) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ingredients | Whole, natural foods (e.g., jackfruit) | Whole foods plus simple culinary ingredients (e.g., jackfruit, salt) | Whole foods plus industrial additives (e.g., jackfruit, methylcellulose, natural flavors, soy flour) |
| Purpose of Processing | Ready-to-eat convenience, preservation | Preservation, simple transformation | Textural, flavor, and sensory engineering for palatability |
| Health Impact | Naturally high in nutrients, associated with better health outcomes | Can be part of a healthy diet, provides simple convenience | Linked to various chronic diseases when consumed in excess |
| Example | Plain, cooked jackfruit | Jackfruit with salt and spices | Jack & Annie's Crispy Jack Nuggets |
Conclusion
While using a plant-based food like jackfruit is positive, the final classification of a Jack and Annie's product as ultra-processed is nuanced. Many products fit the NOVA criteria due to industrial additives like methylcellulose and natural flavors to achieve desired textures and tastes. While not all ultra-processed foods have the same nutritional impact, health-conscious consumers should note that convenient plant-based items, including many from Jack and Annie's, undergo significant industrial alteration. Reading the ingredient list of each product remains the most reliable strategy for the processing level.