Skip to content

Is Reverse Osmosis Water Bad For You? Separating Fact From Fiction

4 min read

Recent studies in some populations have linked demineralized water consumption to negative health effects, leading many to question if reverse osmosis water is bad for you. This concern stems from the fact that while RO systems are highly effective at removing contaminants, they also strip away beneficial minerals like calcium and magnesium, sparking a global debate over its long-term health implications.

Quick Summary

This article examines the health implications of reverse osmosis water, balancing its powerful ability to remove harmful contaminants against the debate surrounding demineralization and potential mineral deficiencies.

Key Points

  • RO removes contaminants and minerals: Reverse osmosis is highly effective at removing up to 99% of harmful contaminants but also strips the water of beneficial minerals like calcium and magnesium.

  • Demineralization is the main concern: The primary health risk associated with RO water is the lack of essential minerals, which some studies link to health issues like bone demineralization and cardiovascular problems.

  • Remineralization is a solution: Adding a remineralization filter or mineral drops is a simple and effective way to restore healthy mineral levels to RO water, mitigating the primary concern.

  • Diet provides most minerals: For individuals with a balanced diet, the mineral contribution from water is minimal, so a healthy diet can compensate for what is lost in the RO process.

  • Safety depends on context: The decision to use RO water depends on your local water quality and personal health needs. It is safer than contaminated water but requires careful consideration if drinking for the long term.

  • RO water can be acidic and corrosive: The demineralized nature of RO water can result in a slightly acidic pH, which may be corrosive to plumbing and potentially leach toxic metals.

In This Article

What is Reverse Osmosis and How Does It Work?

Reverse osmosis (RO) is a water purification process that uses a semi-permeable membrane to remove ions, unwanted molecules, and larger particles from drinking water. Pressure is applied to push water through the membrane, which blocks contaminants such as heavy metals, bacteria, viruses, and chemicals. While effective at removing harmful substances, this process also removes beneficial minerals.

The Health Debate: Demineralization and Its Potential Effects

A major point of contention regarding reverse osmosis water is its lack of minerals. Concerns about long-term consumption of demineralized water focus on the removal of essential minerals like calcium and magnesium. Research suggests that consistently drinking water low in minerals may be linked to decreased bone mineral density and other health issues. Reports citing the World Health Organization (WHO) have indicated that demineralized water can have a negative impact on the body by affecting homeostasis and mineral metabolism.

  • Mineral Leaching: Demineralized water is sometimes described as a "hungry" liquid that can draw minerals out of the body. This, combined with the lack of minerals in the water itself, can contribute to mineral deficiencies. Some studies suggest that consuming water low in calcium and magnesium may lead to symptoms like cardiovascular disorders, tiredness, and muscle cramps.
  • Acidic pH: RO water, without its natural mineral buffering, can be slightly acidic. While the body's pH is primarily regulated by diet, acidic water could potentially cause corrosion and leach metals like lead from plumbing.
  • Impact on Cooking: Cooking with demineralized water can also reduce the mineral content of food, further decreasing dietary mineral intake.

The Case For Reverse Osmosis: Benefits and Safety

Despite the concerns, reverse osmosis offers significant advantages, particularly in areas with contaminated water. It effectively removes harmful substances, making water safer to drink. Studies suggest that for individuals with balanced diets, the benefit of reduced exposure to heavy metals from RO water can outweigh the minimal mineral loss.

  • Comprehensive Contaminant Removal: RO systems are highly effective at removing a wide range of pollutants, including nitrates, pesticides, fluoride, arsenic, and chlorine. This provides a safer water source, especially for vulnerable populations.
  • Improved Taste and Odor: Removing impurities results in cleaner-tasting and odor-free water, potentially encouraging better hydration.
  • Reduced Sodium Intake: RO systems also reduce sodium levels, which is beneficial for those on low-sodium diets.

Addressing the Demineralization Concern: Remineralization

The mineral loss issue in RO water can be addressed through remineralization, which involves adding essential minerals back into the water after purification.

Methods for remineralizing RO water include:

  • Inline Remineralization Filters: Many RO systems offer an added filter that restores minerals like calcium and magnesium.
  • Mineral Drops: Concentrated drops can be manually added to water, offering a simple way to adjust mineral levels.
  • Alkaline Pitchers: These pitchers often filter water to increase pH and add minerals.

Comparison: Reverse Osmosis vs. Tap Water vs. Distilled Water

Feature Reverse Osmosis Water Tap Water (Municipal) Distilled Water
Purity High; removes up to 99% of contaminants. Varies by location; may contain contaminants. Highest; removes virtually everything.
Mineral Content Very low to non-existent; can be restored. Varies; contains natural minerals. None; completely demineralized.
Taste Often flat or neutral. Varies based on content. Flat or bland.
Cost High initial and ongoing cost. Generally lowest cost. Higher energy cost.
Health Consideration Safe with contaminant removal, but demineralization is a concern if not remineralized. Quality depends on source and plumbing. Not recommended for long-term drinking due to complete demineralization.
Environmental Impact Creates wastewater. Lower, but uses municipal resources. Requires significant energy.

Conclusion: A Balanced Perspective

Determining if reverse osmosis water is bad for you requires a balanced view. While RO water effectively removes harmful contaminants, its demineralized state is a valid concern, particularly for those with diets low in minerals. Remineralization is a practical solution to ensure mineral intake for those who rely heavily on RO water.

The decision to use RO water should consider individual health needs, diet, and local water quality. When properly maintained and potentially equipped with a remineralization stage, an RO system can provide safe, purified water while addressing mineral concerns.

Making an Informed Decision

Evaluate your local water quality and dietary habits. If contamination is an issue, RO's ability to remove harmful substances may be a priority. To counter demineralization, incorporate mineral-rich foods or use a remineralization filter. An informed choice allows you to benefit from purified water while protecting your health.

Resources

For additional information on demineralized water and health, refer to studies like those cited by the National Institutes of Health.

Reverse Osmosis System Maintenance

Regularly replace filters and membranes in RO systems to maintain water quality and prevent bacterial growth. Testing the water output ensures the system and any remineralization are functioning correctly.

Note: Individuals with specific health conditions should consult a healthcare professional before deciding on RO water.

The Future of Water Filtration

Water filtration technology continues to advance, leading to more efficient RO systems with less water waste and integrated remineralization. Hybrid systems combining RO with other filtration methods offer comprehensive solutions addressing both contamination and demineralization.

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes, but with a caveat. While RO water is safe because it removes harmful contaminants, it also removes beneficial minerals. For long-term use, especially as a primary water source, it is highly recommended to remineralize the water or ensure your diet is rich in minerals to prevent potential deficiencies.

Long-term exclusive consumption of RO water, without a balanced diet or remineralization, could contribute to a mineral deficiency. However, for most people with a varied diet, the minerals obtained from food are the primary source, and the small amount lost from water is less impactful.

Because RO water has had its mineral content removed, it can be slightly acidic (a pH below 7.0). This is not typically a concern for internal body health, as your body regulates pH, but it can make the water more corrosive to plumbing systems over time, potentially leaching metals.

Some studies suggest that demineralized water, being hypotonic, can cause a small amount of mineral leaching from the body, contributing to mineral loss. The effect is not as dramatic as some myths suggest, but it adds to the overall concern of consuming water without beneficial minerals.

Potential side effects are related to mineral deficiency if the water is not remineralized or a person has a poor diet. These can include tiredness, weakness, muscle cramps, and cardiovascular issues. These effects are more pronounced in populations with overall low mineral intake.

Alternatives include using a standard carbon filter, which removes chemicals but retains minerals; ultrafiltration, which removes bacteria and viruses while keeping minerals; or a system that incorporates remineralization after the RO stage. The best option depends on your specific water quality concerns.

It depends on your tap water quality. If your tap water contains significant contaminants like heavy metals or bacteria, RO water is a safer option. If your tap water is already high quality and you have a balanced diet, the difference in health benefits might be negligible, and you retain the beneficial minerals.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.