Skip to content
Ntro

Is Smartwater Alkaline Worth It? The Truth Behind the Premium Price

•
4 min read

According to a 2018 anti-award from Foodwatch Germany, Smartwater is "nothing but ordinary water" being sold at a premium price for an unnecessary production process. This raises a key question: is smartwater alkaline worth it, or is the added pH just a marketing gimmick?

Quick Summary

This guide examines the value of Smartwater Alkaline by comparing its features and price to regular water and other options. We explore the science behind its health claims, potential drawbacks, and help consumers decide if this premium bottled water is justified.

Key Points

  • Limited Scientific Evidence: Many of the robust health claims for alkaline water, including Smartwater Alkaline, lack conclusive scientific backing and are often contradicted by the body's natural pH regulatory systems.

  • Premium Price, Dubious Value: Smartwater Alkaline commands a significantly higher price than regular filtered water, with some critics suggesting the extra cost is unjustified given the minimal proven health benefits for the average consumer.

  • Taste vs. Necessity: The added electrolytes in Smartwater improve its taste, which is a key factor for many consumers. However, this is a preference, not a health necessity, as regular water provides sufficient hydration.

  • Potential Risks of Excess: While moderate consumption is generally safe, excessive intake of high-pH water can potentially disrupt natural stomach acidity, impair digestion, and interfere with mineral absorption.

  • Sustainable Alternatives Exist: For clean, good-tasting water, more eco-friendly and cost-effective solutions like home water filters and reusable bottles offer a smarter, more sustainable choice than consistently buying bottled water.

  • Marketing vs. Reality: The marketing around products like Smartwater often uses scientific-sounding terms to suggest superior hydration or health benefits, but for daily needs, the benefits are often negligible compared to regular, filtered water.

In This Article

What is Smartwater Alkaline?

Smartwater Alkaline, a product from Coca-Cola, is positioned as a premium bottled water with enhanced properties. Like its standard counterpart, it starts with vapor-distilled water, a process that removes impurities by turning water into vapor and then condensing it back into a liquid. What sets the alkaline version apart is the addition of electrolytes—specifically calcium chloride, magnesium chloride, and potassium bicarbonate—for a crisp taste and a boosted pH level of 9.5 or higher. The alkaline variant also includes the antioxidant selenium. While the process adds minerals lost during distillation, some argue that the trace amounts offer negligible nutritional value compared to a balanced diet.

The Science Behind Alkaline Water Claims

Advocates of alkaline water point to several health benefits, including neutralizing body acid, enhanced hydration, and antioxidant properties. However, medical experts and scientific research offer a more skeptical perspective on many of these widespread claims.

The pH Balance Myth

One of the most common claims is that alkaline water can regulate the body's pH. In reality, the body is naturally equipped with robust mechanisms, including the lungs and kidneys, to maintain blood pH within a very narrow and healthy range of 7.35 to 7.45. Drinking alkaline water has a minimal, temporary effect on stomach pH, but the body quickly compensates, producing more hydrochloric acid to restore the acidic environment needed for digestion and to kill harmful bacteria.

Limited Evidence for Health Benefits

While proponents cite enhanced hydration and other benefits, the evidence is limited or inconclusive. Some small studies have explored potential links to better hydration markers after intense exercise or improvements in conditions like acid reflux, but for most people and everyday hydration, regular water is just as effective. Critics often point out that the body's digestive system can be disrupted by consistently altering its pH, potentially impacting nutrient absorption and immune function.

Potential Risks and Side Effects

Though generally considered safe in moderation, excessive consumption of alkaline water can have drawbacks. Over time, it may lead to:

  • Digestive Disruption: A consistently less acidic stomach environment can hinder digestion and leave the body more vulnerable to pathogens.
  • Mineral Imbalance: High levels of certain minerals can interfere with the absorption of others, such as iron and zinc, leading to potential deficiencies.
  • Alkalosis: In rare, extreme cases of overconsumption, a person can develop metabolic alkalosis, causing symptoms like nausea, muscle twitching, or confusion.

Smartwater Alkaline vs. Alternatives: A Comparison

To understand if smartwater alkaline is worth the price, it helps to compare it to alternatives. The value for money is questionable, especially since effective hydration is possible with less expensive and more sustainable options.

Feature Smartwater Alkaline Regular Tap Water Other Alkaline Brands (e.g., Fiji)
Source Municipal water, vapor-distilled Public tap water supply Natural springs or ionized water
Purification Vapor-distilled, filtered Municipal water treatment Varies; may include natural filtration or ionization
pH Level 9.5+ ~7 (neutral) Varies; often 8.8+ for natural spring varieties
Added Ingredients Electrolytes (potassium, calcium, magnesium), selenium Fluoride, chlorine (for sanitation) Naturally occurring minerals
Cost High (premium price) Very Low High (premium price)
Environmental Impact High (plastic bottles) Low (using reusable bottle) High (plastic bottles)
Purported Benefits Marketing claims for hydration, antioxidants Basic hydration Similar marketing claims, depends on mineral content

Making the Smart Choice for Your Hydration

Ultimately, the decision to purchase Smartwater Alkaline comes down to personal priorities. If you prefer the taste and are willing to pay a premium for it, that is a valid choice. However, it is crucial to temper marketing hype with scientific facts. For general health and hydration, regular filtered water is perfectly sufficient and far more economical and environmentally friendly.

Instead of relying on an expensive bottled product with dubious health claims, consider these smarter alternatives:

  • A home water filter: A high-quality filter pitcher or tap filter can remove unpleasant flavors and contaminants from tap water, providing a constant supply of clean, balanced water for a fraction of the cost.
  • Reusable bottles: Investing in a durable, reusable water bottle dramatically cuts down on plastic waste and is the most environmentally conscious choice.
  • Natural mineral water: For those seeking naturally occurring minerals, some spring waters can be a good option, though they still come in plastic bottles.

Conclusion: Is Smartwater Alkaline Worth It?

For the average consumer, Smartwater Alkaline is likely not worth the premium price. While it offers a crisp taste due to added electrolytes, the significant health benefits often advertised lack conclusive scientific backing. The body is highly efficient at regulating its own pH, and consistent consumption of bottled alkaline water introduces unnecessary costs and environmental waste without providing a proportional health advantage over regular filtered water. Making a truly smart choice means prioritizing simple, clean hydration from more sustainable and affordable sources, saving both your wallet and the planet.

References

Frequently Asked Questions

While alkaline water is generally safe to drink, many health claims associated with it, such as neutralizing body acid or providing superior hydration, are not supported by robust scientific evidence. The body is highly efficient at regulating its own pH balance.

Smartwater Alkaline is ionized to a pH level of 9.5 or higher.

Yes, Smartwater Alkaline contains added electrolytes, including calcium chloride, magnesium chloride, and potassium bicarbonate, for a crisp taste.

No, the amount of electrolytes added to Smartwater is in trace amounts and is not nutritionally significant. You can get more beneficial minerals from a balanced diet.

There is no conclusive scientific evidence to support claims that alkaline water can prevent or cure chronic diseases like cancer or stroke. Your body's own regulatory systems handle pH balance.

Excessive consumption could potentially disrupt your stomach's natural acidity, leading to digestive issues. It may also cause mineral imbalances in rare cases.

Yes, for most people, regular filtered tap water is an excellent and sufficient source of hydration. It is also more cost-effective and environmentally friendly than bottled water.

Some small studies suggest alkaline water might temporarily help relieve acid reflux by neutralizing pepsin, but the evidence is not conclusive, and it does not permanently alter stomach pH.

References

  1. 1
    Alkaline water: Better than plain water? - Mayo Clinic
  2. 2
    Alkaline Water: Benefits, Side Effects, and Dangers - Healthline
  3. 3
    What is Smart Water and is it good for you? - Fountain Filters
  4. 4
    Dangers of Drinking Alkaline Water | High Water Standard
  5. 5
    What Is Alkaline Water? Benefits and Risks Explained - Waterdrop Filter

Related Topics:

#hydration #electrolytes #Alkaline Water #Bottled Water #Water Quality #Health Trends #Consumer Guide #Smartwater

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.