Skip to content

Is SodaStream better than soft drinks? A complete comparison

4 min read

Reports indicate that SodaStream users drink over 60% more water compared to average, suggesting home carbonation boosts hydration. Is SodaStream better than soft drinks for your health, wallet, and the planet? Let's analyze the key factors to find out.

Quick Summary

An analysis comparing SodaStream to traditional soft drinks across key metrics, including health benefits, cost-effectiveness, environmental impact, and user convenience.

Key Points

  • Healthier Ingredients: SodaStream offers customizable drinks with less sugar and fewer artificial ingredients compared to most commercial soft drinks.

  • Cost-Effective Long-Term: After the initial purchase, homemade soda from a SodaStream is significantly cheaper per liter than buying pre-packaged soft drinks.

  • Eco-Friendly Choice: Using a reusable SodaStream bottle helps dramatically reduce single-use plastic waste and lowers your carbon footprint.

  • Endless Customization: Unlike store-bought options, SodaStream allows you to control the level of carbonation and personalize flavors to your exact preference.

  • On-Demand Convenience: No more lugging heavy bottles from the store; fresh, sparkling water is available at the push of a button at home.

  • Improved Hydration: The enjoyable fizz encourages many users to drink more water throughout the day, supporting overall hydration and digestion.

  • Avoids High-Fructose Corn Syrup: SodaStream products do not contain high-fructose corn syrup, a key ingredient in many traditional soft drinks.

In This Article

Health and Nutrition: Taking Control of What You Drink

Traditional soft drinks, such as cola or lemon-lime soda, are widely known for their high sugar content. A single 12-ounce can of cola can contain nearly 10 teaspoons of sugar, contributing to weight gain and increasing the risk of developing conditions like type 2 diabetes. These beverages also contain artificial flavorings, colorings, and phosphoric acid, which can erode tooth enamel. Many commercial soft drinks are sweetened with high-fructose corn syrup, an ingredient completely absent from SodaStream products.

With a SodaStream, you gain significant control over the nutritional content of your beverage. The core function is to carbonate plain water. You can enjoy this sparkling water unsweetened, add natural fruit essences with zero calories and zero sugar, or use a flavored syrup. SodaStream's branded syrups, which combine natural sugar and artificial sweeteners, have roughly 50% less sugar than most commercial soft drinks. The flexibility to control syrup quantity or opt for healthier alternatives like fresh fruit juices allows for a personalized, healthier drink experience.

Benefits of Drinking Carbonated Water

Beyond the ability to control sugar, carbonated water itself offers several health benefits:

  • Promotes Hydration: For many, the appealing fizz of sparkling water makes it easier to stay adequately hydrated throughout the day compared to still water.
  • Aids Digestion: The carbonation can help improve digestion, alleviate constipation, and reduce symptoms like indigestion and stomach pain.
  • Supports Weight Management: Studies suggest that the bubbles in sparkling water can help you feel fuller for longer, potentially reducing appetite.
  • Better for Bones: Unlike the phosphorus in many soft drinks which can impact bone health, carbonated water has no negative effect on bone density.

Cost Comparison: Long-Term Savings vs. Upfront Costs

Evaluating the cost of SodaStream versus soft drinks requires looking beyond the immediate price tag. A SodaStream machine can cost between $80 and $200 initially, but this is a one-time purchase. The ongoing expenses include CO₂ cylinder refills, which cost $15–$30 and can produce up to 60 liters of sparkling water. Flavored syrups cost $5–$7 and make about 12 liters. This brings the long-term cost of a homemade liter to approximately $0.20–$0.50.

Commercial soft drinks, meanwhile, carry a high per-liter cost, often exceeding $1, with prices varying significantly for different brands. The savings with a SodaStream are particularly pronounced for heavy consumers. For example, a family drinking two liters of sparkling water daily could save hundreds of dollars annually by switching. While traditional soft drinks offer the convenience of a lower immediate cost, the SodaStream proves to be the more economically sound choice in the long run for regular users.

Environmental Impact: A Significant Reduction in Plastic Waste

One of the most compelling arguments for SodaStream is its positive environmental impact. The soft drink industry is a major source of single-use plastic waste, with millions of plastic bottles and cans contributing to pollution in landfills and oceans. The manufacturing and transportation of these heavy, pre-packaged beverages also result in a substantial carbon footprint.

By contrast, SodaStream offers a sustainable alternative. A single reusable carbonating bottle can replace thousands of single-use plastic bottles over its lifespan. The CO₂ cylinders are part of an exchange program, where empty cylinders are returned, sterilized, and refilled, minimizing waste. By producing beverages at home, you eliminate the carbon emissions associated with the long-distance transportation of bottled drinks.

Convenience: Instant Gratification vs. Effortless Supply

For immediate convenience, nothing beats grabbing a pre-chilled soft drink from a store shelf. However, this comes with the hassles of frequent store trips, carrying heavy packages, and storing bottles at home. You also run the risk of having a flat drink if it's left open for too long.

A SodaStream provides a different kind of convenience: an endless, on-demand supply of fresh sparkling water at home. With the simple push of a button, you can create a bubbly beverage in seconds. While there is a minor amount of preparation required (filling the bottle, carbonating, adding flavor), it's far less effort than managing a constant supply of store-bought drinks. You never have to worry about running out, and the customization is instant.

SodaStream vs. Soft Drinks: A Comparison Table

Feature Traditional Soft Drinks SodaStream
Health High sugar, calories, and artificial additives. No ingredient control. Potential dental and metabolic risks. Low to zero sugar and calories (depending on syrup). Full control over ingredients and sweetness. Supports hydration and digestion.
Cost High per-liter cost, especially for brand names. No long-term savings. Higher initial machine cost. Significantly lower long-term cost per liter. Substantial savings over time.
Environment Major contributor to single-use plastic waste and transportation-related emissions. Drastically reduces single-use plastic bottles and cans. Reusable bottles and CO₂ cylinder exchange program.
Convenience Instant access. Requires trips to the store and storage space. Bottles can go flat. On-demand, fresh soda at home. Effortless supply without leaving the house. Total freshness with each serving.
Customization Limited to pre-set market options and fixed flavor profiles. Full control over carbonation levels, flavor, and sweetness. Endless possibilities for personalized drinks and recipes.

The Verdict: Is SodaStream Truly Better Than Soft Drinks?

For most consumers, SodaStream is the clear winner when compared to traditional soft drinks across the most important categories. Its most significant advantage is the ability to take control of your beverage's nutritional content, making it a healthier choice for daily consumption. Environmentally, the reduction in single-use plastic waste is undeniable, offering a more sustainable way to enjoy carbonated drinks. Financially, the initial investment is quickly recouped by the long-term savings on beverage costs.

However, the best choice depends on individual priorities. If your main concern is absolute zero-effort, immediate consumption, then store-bought soft drinks still have an edge. But for anyone willing to put in a few seconds of preparation to gain control over their health, budget, and environmental impact, SodaStream is a powerful and practical alternative. It turns hydration into a customizable, eco-friendly, and cost-effective daily habit. You can learn more about the hydration benefits of sparkling water on SodaStream's wellness blog.

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes, SodaStream is healthier because it provides control over ingredients. You can opt for plain sparkling water, use natural fruit drops with zero sugar, or add syrups that contain significantly less sugar than commercial soft drinks.

Yes, in the long run. While there is an initial investment for the machine, the per-liter cost of homemade sparkling water and soda is much lower than store-bought drinks, leading to significant savings over time.

Using a SodaStream is far more eco-friendly. One reusable bottle replaces thousands of single-use plastic bottles and cans, and the CO₂ cylinders are returned for exchange and reuse, reducing waste and transportation emissions.

The taste is often different because SodaStream syrups contain less sugar and different sweeteners. However, many users prefer the cleaner flavor and enjoy the ability to customize the sweetness and carbonation to their liking.

This depends on your habits. Store-bought sodas offer immediate convenience, but SodaStream provides an endless, on-demand supply at home, eliminating heavy lifting and frequent store trips.

SodaStream officially recommends only carbonating plain water. Carbonating other liquids like juice or wine can create a mess or damage the machine and is not advised.

A standard CO₂ cylinder can make up to 60 liters of sparkling water. The actual duration depends on your preferred level of carbonation and how often you use the machine.

Carbonated water is significantly less damaging to tooth enamel than sugary soft drinks. The acidity comes from carbonation, but the high sugar content in traditional sodas is the primary cause of decay and erosion.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.