Skip to content

Is Spring Water Good for You? Benefits, Risks, and Comparison

4 min read

According to the Mayo Clinic, women should aim for 11.5 cups and men for 15.5 cups of water daily. For many, the source of this water is an important health consideration, leading them to question: is spring water good for you? This question requires examining the unique characteristics of spring water, from its mineral composition to the safety of its source.

Quick Summary

An exploration of spring water's characteristics, including its natural mineral content and taste, along with a look at the benefits and potential safety risks of different sources. The piece compares spring water to other types, such as purified and tap water, to help consumers make an informed hydration choice.

Key Points

  • Rich in Natural Minerals: Spring water contains essential minerals like calcium, magnesium, and potassium, which are beneficial for bodily functions.

  • Source Matters Greatly: Bottled spring water is treated and regulated, making it safe. Untreated, wild spring sources can contain dangerous bacteria and chemicals.

  • May Encourage Hydration: Many prefer the pure, clean taste of spring water, which can lead to drinking more water throughout the day.

  • Naturally Alkaline: Some spring water has a naturally high pH level, which some believe offers health benefits, though individual results vary.

  • Verify the Source: Always check the label of bottled spring water to ensure it comes from a named, tested source and is not just treated tap water.

In This Article

What Exactly Is Spring Water?

Spring water is water sourced from an underground aquifer that flows naturally to the surface. As it travels through layers of rock and soil, it undergoes natural filtration and picks up various minerals, including calcium, magnesium, and potassium. The mineral content and composition can vary widely depending on the geological area of the spring. This natural process gives spring water its unique and often refreshing taste that many people prefer. Bottled spring water is collected at the point where it emerges or from a borehole tapping the same underground source. It is then tested and treated to ensure safety, while maintaining its characteristic mineral profile.

The Potential Health Benefits of Spring Water

For those who choose a reputable, treated source, drinking spring water offers several potential health advantages. These benefits primarily stem from its natural mineral content and lack of certain chemicals found in tap water.

Provides Essential Minerals

Unlike purified water, which strips away minerals, spring water retains its beneficial compounds. Minerals like calcium, magnesium, and potassium are crucial for various bodily functions.

  • Calcium helps build and maintain strong bones and teeth.
  • Magnesium supports muscle function, energy production, and nerve health.
  • Potassium aids in maintaining normal fluid levels within cells.

Promotes Better Hydration

Some believe the natural minerals and pure taste of spring water encourage people to drink more, leading to better overall hydration. This enhanced hydration can improve digestion, skin health, and cognitive function. The absence of chlorine and other additives often found in tap water makes the taste more palatable for many.

Potential Alkaline Properties

Some spring water sources are naturally alkaline, with a pH level higher than 7. A balanced pH is essential for health, especially considering many modern diets are acidic. While this is a selling point for many alkaline water products, natural spring water can offer this benefit organically.

Important Safety Considerations and Risks

While bottled spring water from a reputable brand is generally safe, water from untreated, wild springs can pose significant health risks. The notion that all spring water is naturally pure is a dangerous misconception.

Contamination from Untreated Sources

Water flowing from uncontrolled roadside or wild springs is not tested or regulated. These sources can be contaminated by various harmful substances.

  • Microbiological Contamination: Untreated spring water can contain bacteria (like E. coli), parasites (like Giardia), and viruses that cause gastrointestinal illnesses.
  • Chemical Runoff: Agricultural and industrial activity near a spring can cause pesticides, herbicides, and nitrates to seep into the water.
  • Heavy Metals: Natural sources can contain dangerous levels of heavy metals such as arsenic or lead, which can cause severe health issues with long-term exposure.

Quality Variation

The mineral content and overall quality of natural springs can change over time due to environmental factors, making regular testing crucial. When considering bottled spring water, it is essential to choose a brand that is transparent about its testing and purification processes.

Spring Water vs. Other Water Types

To help you decide if spring water is right for you, here is a comparison table outlining its key differences from other common water sources.

Feature Spring Water Purified Water Tap Water (Municipal)
Source Underground aquifer flows to the surface. Any source (tap, ground, surface), treated extensively. Local municipal supply; from rivers, lakes, or aquifers.
Processing Minimally processed; tested for safety but retains natural minerals. Distillation, reverse osmosis, or deionization removes impurities and minerals. Disinfected with chemicals like chlorine; treated to meet EPA standards.
Mineral Content Naturally contains essential minerals like calcium, magnesium, potassium. Lacks minerals, as they are removed during purification. Varies widely based on local geology and treatment.
Taste Often described as fresh and clean due to its mineral profile. Can taste flat or neutral due to the lack of minerals. Can have a chemical taste (e.g., chlorine) depending on the source.
Safety Bottled versions are tested and regulated. Untreated sources are risky. High purity and safety due to extensive treatment and filtration. Safe due to municipal treatment, but can vary and may contain contaminants.

How to Choose Safe Spring Water

If you prefer spring water, opt for a reliable bottled brand to ensure safety. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) recommends checking the label for specific details. A reputable brand will:

  • Disclose the water's source on the label.
  • Share independent test results from health departments or safety groups.
  • Be transparent about its treatment processes.
  • Label the product as “spring water” and not just “drinking water”.
  • Belong to reputable trade organizations like the International Bottled Water Association (IBWA).

In contrast, avoid drinking from untested roadside or wild springs. These sources are unregulated and their quality is unknown, posing serious health threats.

Conclusion

So, is spring water good for you? The answer depends entirely on its source and safety. High-quality, bottled spring water from a trusted brand can be a healthy choice, providing essential minerals and a pure taste that encourages hydration. It typically contains beneficial minerals and lacks the chemicals found in some tap water. However, the potential risks of untreated spring water cannot be overstated. Consuming water from an unverified source can expose you to harmful bacteria, parasites, and chemical contaminants. For the safest and most beneficial experience, always rely on bottled spring water from reputable companies that provide transparent testing results.

Visit the CDC's Traveler's Health page for information on safe drinking water.

Is spring water good for you: a complete analysis

The definitive guide to spring water benefits and risks

Spring water vs other types: what you need to know

Safety tips for choosing the right spring water

The surprising truth about the benefits of drinking spring water

Frequently Asked Questions

No, it is not recommended to drink water directly from an untreated natural spring. Even if the water appears clear, it can contain harmful bacteria, parasites, or chemical contaminants from environmental runoff.

Reputable bottled spring water brands are sourced from underground aquifers that feed a spring. They are collected and tested to ensure they meet safety standards while retaining their natural mineral content.

The main difference is the mineral content and processing. Spring water is minimally processed to retain its natural minerals, whereas purified water is extensively treated (e.g., via reverse osmosis) to remove nearly all dissolved solids and contaminants.

For those seeking naturally occurring minerals, spring water is generally considered better. However, municipal tap water is treated and regulated to meet safety standards. The healthfulness of tap water depends on local water quality and piping.

Yes, if consumed from an untested, unregulated source, spring water can be bad for you. It may contain harmful pathogens or high levels of heavy metals. Bottled spring water, when properly regulated, is generally safe.

Yes, due to its natural mineral content, many spring waters contain electrolytes like sodium, potassium, and magnesium, which are important for proper hydration.

Spring water can be beneficial for skin and hair health due to its mineral content and lack of harsh chemicals like chlorine. These minerals can help maintain hydration and promote a healthy pH balance for the scalp.

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.