The Origins and Motivations for Placentophagy
The practice of consuming the placenta, known as placentophagy, is a modern trend in Western societies that has gained traction largely through celebrity endorsements and social media advocacy. Proponents often cite observing this behavior in other mammals, hypothesizing that humans lost this natural instinct over time. The primary motivations, according to surveys, revolve around anecdotal reports of health benefits for new mothers.
Anecdotal Claims and Perceived Benefits
Those who advocate for placentophagy report a variety of positive outcomes, which proponents believe stem from the hormones and nutrients within the placenta. These purported benefits include:
- Improved Mood and Reduced Risk of Postpartum Depression: Some women believe that reintroducing hormones like progesterone and estrogen helps to stabilize mood and prevent the 'baby blues'.
- Increased Energy and Reduced Fatigue: The placenta contains iron and other nutrients, which advocates suggest can replenish iron stores depleted during childbirth and boost energy levels.
- Enhanced Milk Production: It is claimed that placental hormones like human placental lactogen (hPL) can stimulate lactation.
- Faster Postpartum Recovery: Proponents believe the placenta can aid in reducing postpartum bleeding and speeding up uterine recovery.
However, it is crucial to note that clinical studies have not substantiated these claims. A randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled pilot study found no significant differences in maternal mood, bonding, or fatigue between women who took placenta capsules and those who took a placebo. Many experts believe the positive effects women experience are a result of the placebo effect.
The Risks and Dangers of Eating Raw Placenta
Consuming raw placenta is particularly hazardous due to the significant risk of bacterial contamination. The placenta is not a sterile organ and can contain bacteria, viruses, and toxins.
Contamination and Infection Risks
- Bacterial Pathogens: The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) has issued warnings against placenta consumption, especially encapsulation, following a documented case where an infant contracted a life-threatening group B Streptococcus (GBS) infection linked to the mother's contaminated placenta pills. Raw consumption carries an even greater risk as the tissue is not heated at all to reduce pathogens.
- Toxic Accumulation: The placenta functions as a filter during pregnancy, accumulating heavy metals like mercury and lead. When ingested, these toxins are reintroduced into the mother's body.
Lack of Regulation
Unlike food, the preparation of placenta for consumption is unregulated by agencies like the FDA. This means there are no standardized safety protocols for handling and processing, leaving mothers vulnerable to improper and unhygienic practices.
Raw vs. Encapsulated: A Comparison of Preparation Methods
While raw consumption (often in smoothies) is one method, most people who practice placentophagy opt for encapsulation. The following table highlights the key differences and risks.
| Feature | Raw Placenta | Encapsulated Placenta | 
|---|---|---|
| Preparation | Consumed immediately after birth, blended into smoothies, or cooked. No heat processing. | Steamed (TCM method) or raw, dehydrated, and ground into powder for capsules. | 
| Alleged Hormones/Nutrients | May theoretically retain more hormones and nutrients due to no heat exposure. | Retains some hormones and minerals, but concentrations are significantly reduced by processing. | 
| Bacterial Risk | Highest risk of bacterial and viral contamination due to lack of heating. | Still carries a significant risk of contamination, as heating may not be sufficient to kill all pathogens. | 
| Palatability | Many find the idea of consuming raw tissue unpleasant or difficult. | Consumed like a supplement, making it more palatable and discreet. | 
| Consistency | Inconsistent in terms of hormonal and nutrient content per serving. | Standardized dose per capsule, though the content itself varies from placenta to placenta. | 
Exploring Safer Nutritional Alternatives Postpartum
Instead of turning to an unproven and potentially dangerous practice, new mothers can rely on evidence-based nutritional strategies for a healthier recovery. These methods offer proven benefits without the risks associated with placentophagy.
- Balanced Diet: Focus on consuming a diet rich in protein, fruits, vegetables, and whole grains to provide essential vitamins and minerals.
- Iron Supplements: Postpartum anemia is a real concern. Supplementing with an oral iron tablet, especially if blood counts are low, is a safe and effective way to replenish iron stores.
- Stay Hydrated: Drinking plenty of fluids is essential for overall health and for supporting milk production.
- Lactation Support: For concerns about milk supply, consult a lactation consultant or healthcare provider for proven, personalized strategies.
- Rest and Support: Prioritize rest and seek emotional support from family, friends, or a professional if experiencing symptoms of postpartum depression.
Conclusion: Weighing the Risks and Anecdotes
Ultimately, the reasons why do people eat raw placenta are rooted in anecdotal beliefs and unproven claims, not scientific evidence. The practice carries significant health risks, particularly concerning bacterial contamination and potential exposure to toxins, and a lack of standardized safety protocols exacerbates these dangers. For new mothers seeking a nutritional boost or recovery support, safer, evidence-based methods such as a balanced diet, iron supplements, and professional care are recommended. Consulting a healthcare provider is the best way to develop a safe and effective postpartum nutrition and wellness plan.
For more information on evidence-based postpartum care, you can visit the Mayo Clinic's expert answers on eating the placenta.