The Role of Rennet in Cheesemaking
Rennet is a complex set of enzymes used to coagulate milk, separating it into solid curds and liquid whey. Traditionally, rennet was sourced from the stomachs of young ruminant animals, primarily calves. For vegetarians, this traditional process makes many cheeses unsuitable for consumption. Fortunately, modern cheesemaking has developed several non-animal alternatives for curdling milk.
Non-Animal Rennet Alternatives
- Microbial Rennet: This type of rennet is produced by specific microorganisms, such as fungi or molds (e.g., Rhizomucor miehei). It is now the most common type used in commercial cheese production and is suitable for most vegetarians. It provides a consistent curdling process without imparting the animal-derived qualities.
- Fermentation-Produced Chymosin (FPC): A type of microbial rennet, FPC is created through genetic engineering, where genes from a calf's stomach are inserted into microorganisms to produce chymosin. While technically a form of microbial rennet, its genetic modification is a consideration for some consumers. FPC is widely used and is considered vegetarian.
- Vegetable Rennet: Derived from plants, such as the cardoon thistle, artichoke, or figs, vegetable rennet offers another plant-based alternative. Cheeses made with vegetable rennet may sometimes develop a slightly bitter taste over time, especially with longer aging.
How to Identify Vegetarian-Friendly Cheeses
Since cheesemakers are not always required to specify the type of rennet on the label, identifying a vegetarian cheese requires careful inspection.
Reading the Label
- Look for specific wording: Phrases like "microbial enzymes," "vegetarian rennet," "plant-based rennet," or "vegetable rennet" are clear indicators.
- Beware of generic terms: If the label only lists "enzymes" without specifying the source, there's a strong chance it contains animal rennet.
- Look for Kosher Certification: Kosher laws prohibit mixing meat and milk, so a certified Kosher cheese (often marked with a 'K' or 'OU' symbol) will never contain animal rennet.
Common Rennet-Free Cheeses Some cheeses are naturally rennet-free because they are made using an acid, like lemon juice or vinegar, to curdle the milk instead of an enzyme. These are always vegetarian.
- Ricotta: A soft, fresh cheese often used in lasagna and other Italian dishes.
- Paneer: A non-melting Indian cheese used in curries and other dishes.
- Cottage Cheese: The curds are formed by acid coagulation rather than rennet.
- Cream Cheese: The soft texture does not require the use of rennet.
- Mascarpone: A soft Italian cream cheese.
Cheeses Commonly Made Without Animal Rennet
Many mass-produced cheese varieties have switched from animal rennet to microbial rennet to appeal to a wider audience. However, label reading is still essential.
- Mozzarella: While traditional European versions may use animal rennet, most modern, mass-market mozzarella uses microbial enzymes.
- Cheddar: Many large brands now offer cheddar varieties made with microbial or vegetable rennet. Artisanal cheddars are more likely to use animal rennet.
- Swiss: Both processed and natural Swiss cheeses from major brands often use non-animal enzymes.
- Provolone: Similar to other Italian varieties, modern provolone often has a vegetarian option, but check labels, especially for blends.
- Monterey Jack and Colby: Widely available from brands using microbial enzymes.
- Feta: The use of rennet in feta is inconsistent; some producers use animal rennet, while others use microbial. Always check the label.
Cheeses Traditionally Made With Animal Rennet
For these cheeses, finding a vegetarian version is more challenging, and labels must be scrutinized.
- Parmigiano-Reggiano: Authentic Parmigiano-Reggiano is required by law to be made with animal rennet. A vegetarian substitute will be labeled as "Parmesan" and must be checked for microbial enzymes.
- Pecorino Romano: Similarly, this traditional Italian cheese uses animal rennet, though non-traditional vegetarian versions exist.
- Gruyère: This is another traditional European cheese that requires animal rennet.
- Some Blue Cheeses: While some blue cheeses, like Stilton, are vegetarian, others such as traditional Gorgonzola or Roquefort are not.
Navigating the Cheese Aisle: A Comparison
| Cheese Type | Traditional Rennet Source | Common Vegetarian Status | How to Identify a Vegetarian Option | 
|---|---|---|---|
| Ricotta | None (Acid-coagulated) | Always Vegetarian | Check for acid-based coagulation on the label if desired. | 
| Paneer | None (Acid-coagulated) | Always Vegetarian | Primarily curdled with acid. | 
| Parmigiano-Reggiano | Animal | Never (by law) | Look for "Parmesan" with specified "microbial enzymes" or Kosher certification. | 
| Mozzarella | Can be animal or non-animal | Often Vegetarian | Many mass-market versions use microbial enzymes; always check the label. | 
| Cheddar | Can be animal or non-animal | Often Vegetarian | Many larger brands use non-animal rennet; check the label or brand website. | 
| Swiss | Can be animal or non-animal | Often Vegetarian | Many mass-market versions use microbial enzymes; check the label. | 
| Feta | Can be animal or non-animal | Inconsistent | Varies significantly between brands; label check is essential. | 
| Blue Cheese | Varies (Some are, some aren't) | Inconsistent | Brands like Stilton are vegetarian, but check labels for others. | 
Brands Offering Vegetarian-Friendly Options
Many popular brands make it a priority to offer vegetarian-friendly cheese options. Some examples include:
- Organic Valley: Uses vegetarian, microbial enzymes in most cheeses (except blue cheese) and is known for its high-quality organic products.
- Sargento: Most natural cheeses from Sargento are made with non-animal rennets, though some Italian styles may contain animal enzymes.
- BelGioioso: Provides many vegetarian cheese options, including a dedicated vegetarian parmesan made without animal rennet.
- Tillamook: This brand specifies that many of its cheddars, Colby, and blends use microbial or vegetable-based enzymes.
- Kirkland Signature (Costco): Many Kirkland cheeses are made with microbial rennet and are suitable for vegetarians.
Conclusion: Making Informed Choices for Your Vegetarian Diet
Understanding the source of rennet is a key consideration for anyone following a vegetarian diet. While traditionally derived from animals, the widespread adoption of microbial and vegetable rennet in modern cheesemaking has made it easier than ever to find a variety of delicious vegetarian-friendly cheeses. The most reliable method is to diligently check product labels for terms like "microbial enzymes" or a Kosher certification symbol. By doing so, you can confidently enjoy a wide range of flavorful cheeses that align with your dietary choices. For more in-depth information on cheesemaking processes, consult resources like Cultures for Health, which explains the different types of rennet.