The Spectrum of Antibiotic Policies: NAE vs. NAIHM
Not all "no antibiotic" claims are created equal, and it is crucial to understand the different standards restaurants adopt. The highest and most stringent claim is “No Antibiotics Ever” (NAE), which means the animal was never given antibiotics at any point in its life. A less restrictive standard is “No Antibiotics Important to Human Medicine” (NAIHM), which restricts medically important antibiotics but allows animal-specific ones. Recent shifts show some chains previously using NAE have downgraded to NAIHM.
Fast Food Chains Committed to No Antibiotics Ever (NAE) Chicken
These chains prioritize a “No Antibiotics Ever” policy for their chicken.
- Chipotle Mexican Grill: Known for responsible sourcing, Chipotle uses NAE for all its meats, removing sick animals from the supply.
- Shake Shack: This chain commits to no antibiotics in its U.S. chicken, beef, pork, or dairy.
- Starbird Chicken: This "super-premium fast-food" chain serves chicken never raised with antibiotics or hormones.
Recent Policy Shifts: Chick-fil-A and Panera Bread
Two former NAE leaders have changed their policies.
- Chick-fil-A: Citing supply challenges, Chick-fil-A switched from NAE to NAIHM in 2024, allowing some antibiotic use for sick animals.
- Panera Bread: Panera also loosened its antibiotic standards in 2024, reportedly for cost savings and flexibility.
Other Notable Chains and Considerations
Other restaurants have varying policies.
- KFC: By 2019, KFC committed to sourcing chicken without medically important antibiotics (NAIHM).
- McDonald's: U.S. McDonald's chicken is raised without medically important antibiotics.
- Subway: While previously pledging NAE chicken, recent reports suggest their current policy is less clear.
Comparison of Fast Food Antibiotic Chicken Policies
| Restaurant | Current Chicken Antibiotic Policy | Notes | 
|---|---|---|
| Chipotle | No Antibiotics Ever (NAE) | Longstanding commitment for all meat. | 
| Shake Shack | No Antibiotics Ever (NAE) | All chicken, beef, and pork are NAE. | 
| Starbird Chicken | No Antibiotics Ever (NAE) | Hand-breaded and never-frozen chicken. | 
| Chick-fil-A | No Antibiotics Important to Human Medicine (NAIHM) | Shifted from NAE to NAIHM in 2024 due to supply chain issues. | 
| Panera Bread | Loosened Policy | Retreated from NAE in 2024, now allows some antibiotics. | 
| KFC | No Antibiotics Important to Human Medicine (NAIHM) | Implemented policy by 2019. | 
| McDonald's | No Antibiotics Important to Human Medicine (NAIHM) | Applies to US chicken supply. | 
Making Informed Choices at the Drive-Thru
Understanding NAE and NAIHM helps navigate fast-food antibiotic claims. While some chains have relaxed policies, others like Chipotle and Shake Shack maintain high standards. For assurance, check company websites or third-party certifications. Consumer demand drives transparency in antibiotic use.
Supporting brands with responsible sourcing and high animal welfare sends a positive message. For updates, consult reputable sources like Consumer Reports.
What Does It Mean for Your Health?
Overuse of antibiotics in livestock contributes to antibiotic resistance, a significant health threat. Choosing meat from animals raised without antibiotics helps reduce this practice and preserves the effectiveness of these drugs for human use.
Conclusion
The fast-food antibiotic policy landscape is evolving, but options for chicken raised without antibiotics exist. Chipotle and Shake Shack maintain strict NAE standards. The policy shifts at Chick-fil-A and Panera highlight the need to stay informed. By understanding claims and supporting transparent brands, consumers can make choices aligned with their values and health. Checking restaurant websites for the latest updates is recommended.