Fumarate is an organic compound that serves a vital function in cellular metabolism, particularly in the Krebs cycle, which is central to energy production. While our bodies produce fumarate naturally, it is also present in certain foods. The terms 'fumarate' and 'fumaric acid' are often used interchangeably in a food context, with fumaric acid (E297) being the version used as a food additive due to its effectiveness as an acidulant and preservative. Understanding where it is found can shed light on both natural dietary components and industrial food processes.
Natural Sources of Fumarate
While fumarate is not a major nutrient people actively seek, it is found in trace amounts in a variety of natural products. For example, some fungi and plants naturally produce it as part of their metabolic processes.
Fungi and Lichen
Certain species of fungi and lichen are among the most notable natural sources of fumarate.
- Bolete Mushrooms: This category of fungi is a known natural source.
- Lichen and Iceland Moss: These slow-growing organisms also contain natural fumaric acid.
- Yeast: Some yeasts, including those in yogurt fermentation, produce fumaric acid, and other bacteria use it as a metabolite.
Fruits and Vegetables
Fumarate is present in a limited range of fruits and vegetables, though typically in very small concentrations.
- Fruits: Papayas, pears, and plums contain limited amounts. Some sources also cite apples and grapes as containing trace amounts.
- Vegetables: Onions, chives, celery, cauliflower, cabbage, carrots, and potatoes have also been noted to contain fumaric acid.
The Widespread Use of Fumarate as a Food Additive (E297)
Fumaric acid's most common presence in the modern diet is as a food additive, known by its E number E297 in Europe. Its low water solubility and strong tartness make it ideal for several applications, particularly in dry food mixes where it prevents caking and extends shelf life.
Baked Goods and Dry Mixes
- Tortillas: Added as a preservative to inhibit mold growth and extend shelf life.
- Baking Powder and Cake Mixes: Acts as a leavening acid and anti-caking agent, especially in dry mixes.
- Rye and Sourdough Breads: Enhances the tangy flavor.
Beverages and Confectionery
- Dry Drink Mixes: Because of its non-hygroscopic nature, it maintains free-flowing powder and stable flavor.
- Sour Candies and Chewing Gum: Provides a sharp, long-lasting sour taste.
- Wines and Fruit Juices: Used to regulate acidity, stabilize color and flavor, and extend shelf life.
Dairy Products and Desserts
- Cheese Products: Used in processed cheeses and cheese substitutes to regulate pH and enhance flavor.
- Dairy Drinks: Found in flavored milk, cocoa, and yogurt, where it acts as an acidulant.
- Gelatin Desserts and Pie Fillings: An economical acidulant that aids in gelling.
Processed Meats and Seafood
- Cured and Processed Meats: Fumaric acid can be used in bacon, sausages, and other processed meats to help stabilize and preserve the product.
- Frozen and Smoked Seafood: May contain added fumaric acid for preservation.
Fumaric Acid vs. Other Common Acidulants
Fumaric acid is often used as a substitute for other acidulants like citric and malic acid due to its specific properties. The table below compares the key characteristics of these three food acids.
| Feature | Fumaric Acid | Citric Acid | Malic Acid | 
|---|---|---|---|
| Sourness | Strong, lingering, persistent tartness | Sharp, quick-onset, and clean sour taste | Smooth, mellow, and fruity sourness | 
| Solubility in Water | Low solubility in cold water | Very high solubility | Very high solubility | 
| Hygroscopicity | Non-hygroscopic (resists moisture absorption) | Very hygroscopic (absorbs moisture readily) | Moderately hygroscopic | 
| Best for | Dry mixes, powders, chewing gum, products needing long-lasting tartness | Beverages, candies, jams, jellies, where quick dissolution is needed | Beverages and candies, especially for apple flavor profiles | 
| Cost-Effectiveness | Highly cost-effective due to its strength | Standard cost | Higher cost than citric acid | 
Fumarate in Human Metabolism
Beyond its role in food, fumarate is a naturally occurring dicarboxylic acid that plays an essential part in our cellular processes. It is an intermediate in the Krebs cycle, where it is formed from succinate and then converted into malate to continue the cycle. In this process, it helps to generate energy (ATP) from the breakdown of carbohydrates, fats, and proteins. Human skin also produces fumaric acid when exposed to sunlight. Research has also focused on fumarate and its role in disease states, including its link to certain cancers and autoimmune conditions, though this is separate from its dietary intake from food.
Conclusion
While a few natural foods, including bolete mushrooms, lichen, and certain fruits and vegetables, contain trace amounts of fumarate, the vast majority of our dietary intake comes from its use as a food additive, E297. It is a versatile and cost-effective acidulant, appreciated for its strong, lingering tartness and non-hygroscopic properties that are especially beneficial for preserving dry food mixes. The next time you enjoy a sour candy, a slice of sourdough, or a powdered drink, there's a good chance you are consuming intentionally added fumarate.
For more detailed technical information on fumaric acid and its properties, you can review its profile on the Creative Proteomics website.