Skip to content

What is better than reverse osmosis water? Alternatives for Health and Taste

4 min read

According to the World Health Organization, consuming demineralized water over the long term can pose potential health risks, linking it to issues like mineral deficiencies. While a reverse osmosis (RO) system produces incredibly pure water by stripping contaminants, its process also removes beneficial minerals, leaving the water with a flat taste and contributing significantly to water waste. But for those seeking the pinnacle of water purity, healthier hydration, and sustainability, several superior alternatives and enhancements exist.

Quick Summary

This guide evaluates purification methods that surpass standard reverse osmosis, focusing on options that retain or add back beneficial minerals, reduce water waste, and offer improved taste and efficiency. Key alternatives include ultrafiltration, distillation, and advanced RO systems with remineralization features for healthier and more satisfying hydration.

Key Points

  • Remineralization is key: Standard RO removes essential minerals; adding a remineralization stage restores them for better taste and health.

  • Ultrafiltration (UF) is a viable alternative: It purifies water by removing bacteria and viruses while retaining beneficial minerals and creating zero wastewater.

  • Distillation offers ultimate purity with tradeoffs: The process removes virtually all impurities but is energy-intensive, slow, and produces water with a flat taste.

  • Advanced RO systems reduce waste: Modern RO systems have significantly improved water efficiency, with some reaching an efficient 1:1 purified-to-waste ratio.

  • Consider combination systems: Pairing activated carbon for taste and UV for microbial disinfection with UF or RO offers a comprehensive purification approach.

  • Superior taste and hydration: Remineralized water is less acidic and has a more natural, refreshing taste, encouraging better hydration compared to pure RO water.

In This Article

What is Missing in Standard Reverse Osmosis Water?

While standard reverse osmosis is highly effective at removing up to 99% of contaminants, including heavy metals, chemicals, and bacteria, its aggressive filtration process leaves the water nearly devoid of all total dissolved solids (TDS). This includes essential minerals like calcium, magnesium, and potassium, which are naturally present in water sources. The resulting pure but demineralized water is often slightly acidic and can taste flat or bland, a significant drawback for many people. Additionally, traditional RO systems are notorious for their inefficiency, often wasting several gallons of water for every gallon purified. For those concerned about both the health implications of mineral-stripped water and the environmental impact of water waste, considering alternatives is a prudent step.

The Superior Alternative: Remineralized Reverse Osmosis

Perhaps the most practical and popular enhancement to standard reverse osmosis is adding a remineralization stage. This add-on filter, typically the final stage of an RO system, automatically introduces a balanced amount of essential minerals back into the purified water.

Health and Taste Benefits

  • Restored Nutrients: Remineralizing filters restore vital minerals like calcium and magnesium, which are crucial for bone health, nerve function, and overall wellness.
  • Balanced pH: Pure RO water can be slightly acidic, but remineralization balances the pH to a more neutral or alkaline state, making it more aligned with the body's needs.
  • Improved Taste: The added minerals provide a crisper, more natural flavor, eliminating the flat taste associated with demineralized RO water.
  • Consistent Hydration: The balanced pH and mineral content create a more palatable drinking water, which can encourage better daily hydration habits.

The Eco-Friendly Upgrade

Many modern remineralized RO systems are also designed for higher efficiency, with improved drain ratios (some as low as 1:1) compared to older, wasteful models. This makes them a more environmentally conscious choice while still delivering the highest quality water.

Ultrafiltration (UF): An Alternative That Retains Minerals

For those who prefer to retain the naturally occurring minerals in their water from the start, ultrafiltration (UF) is an excellent alternative.

How Ultrafiltration Works

Ultrafiltration uses a membrane with slightly larger pores (0.01 to 0.1 micron) than an RO system (0.0001 micron). While it effectively removes bacteria, viruses, and microplastics, it allows beneficial minerals and salts to pass through. This provides a great balance of purification without stripping everything away.

Key Advantages of Ultrafiltration

  • Zero Water Waste: UF systems do not require a drain connection, producing zero wastewater during the filtration process.
  • No Electricity Needed: They operate on standard water pressure, requiring no electricity for operation.
  • Fast Flow Rate: Without the need for a storage tank, UF systems provide purified water on demand with a faster flow rate than typical RO systems.
  • Retained Minerals: The natural mineral content of your water is preserved, offering better taste and health benefits without additional steps.

Distillation: For Near-Absolute Purity

If the goal is to achieve near-absolute purity, such as for specific medical, laboratory, or industrial applications, distillation is a powerful method.

The Distillation Process

This process involves boiling water and collecting the condensed steam, leaving most contaminants—including heavy metals, salts, and microorganisms—behind.

The Trade-offs of Distillation

  • High Energy Consumption: Boiling water is an energy-intensive process, making distillation less cost-effective and environmentally friendly than other methods for daily drinking water.
  • Flat Taste: Like standard RO, distilled water is devoid of minerals, resulting in a notably flat or neutral taste that many find unpleasant.
  • Slow Production: The process of boiling and condensing water is slow, making it impractical for high-volume needs.

Comparison Table: RO vs. Advanced Alternatives

Feature Standard RO Remineralized RO Ultrafiltration (UF) Distillation
Purity Level Excellent Excellent Very High Near-Absolute
Removes Minerals? Yes No (Adds back) No Yes
Waste Water High Low (Modern Systems) Zero Minimal (Residue)
Electricity Needed? Yes (Typically) Yes (Typically) No Yes (High Energy)
Taste Flat / Slightly Acidic Crisp / Natural Retains Natural Flat / Bland
Contaminants Removed Broad Range (0.0001µ) Broad Range (0.0001µ) Bacteria, Viruses, Microplastics (0.01µ) Broad Range (Boiling Point)

Other Filtration Combinations

Many other water purification technologies are often used in combination with or as alternatives to RO, depending on the specific water source and needs.

Activated Carbon Filters

These filters use adsorption to remove chlorine, volatile organic compounds (VOCs), and other contaminants that affect taste and odor. They can be used as a standalone filter for improved taste or as a pre-filter in a multi-stage system.

Ultraviolet (UV) Purification

UV systems use UV light to inactivate microorganisms like bacteria and viruses by damaging their DNA, preventing them from reproducing. While effective against microbes, UV does not remove chemical contaminants or heavy metals. It is often used as a post-filter for added peace of mind, especially for well water.

Conclusion

For most homes, the quest for what is better than reverse osmosis water often leads to a system that improves upon it rather than replacing it entirely. A modern, high-efficiency RO system with a remineralization stage offers the best of both worlds: superior contaminant removal and the health and taste benefits of essential minerals. Ultrafiltration is a compelling alternative for those prioritizing water conservation and mineral retention without the need for absolute purity. The best method for you ultimately depends on your specific water source, budget, and priorities for health and taste. By evaluating the pros and cons of these advanced options, you can move beyond standard RO to find a water purification system that is truly better for you, your family, and the environment.

For more in-depth information on drinking water quality guidelines and safety, consider consulting resources from the World Health Organization, which provides comprehensive research on the impact of demineralized water on health.(https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4921383/)

Frequently Asked Questions

Standard RO water tastes flat because the intense filtration process removes nearly all total dissolved solids, including minerals like calcium and magnesium, which contribute to water's natural flavor.

While not inherently harmful in the short term, the World Health Organization has warned that long-term consumption of demineralized water may be linked to mineral deficiencies because it lacks essential minerals. The body's mineral intake can also be negatively affected.

Remineralizing filters are typically added as a final stage to an RO system. They use a special cartridge containing mineral media (like calcium and magnesium) that automatically adds these beneficial minerals back into the purified water.

Yes, ultrafiltration (UF) membranes have pores small enough to effectively remove bacteria, viruses, and other microorganisms, providing a high level of purification.

Distillation produces nearly 100% pure water by boiling and condensing steam, making it more thorough than RO for removing most contaminants. However, it is also much slower, more energy-intensive, and removes all beneficial minerals.

An RO membrane can be an effective physical barrier to microorganisms, but UV purification provides an extra layer of defense by killing any potential surviving bacteria and viruses, especially for those with well water concerns.

The primary drawbacks of standard RO systems are the removal of beneficial minerals, which can affect water taste and health, and the significant amount of water waste generated during filtration.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.