Skip to content

What is the difference between intuitive eating and mindful eating?

3 min read

Research consistently shows that adopting non-diet approaches like intuitive eating and mindful eating can lead to improved body image, better mental well-being, and a healthier relationship with food. However, what is the difference between intuitive eating and mindful eating, and how can you tell which one is right for you?

Quick Summary

Intuitive eating is a comprehensive framework for rejecting diet culture and trusting your body's wisdom, while mindful eating is the practice of being fully present with the eating experience.

Key Points

  • Scope and Focus: Mindful eating focuses on the present eating experience, while intuitive eating is a broader, anti-diet framework for your entire relationship with food and body.

  • Mindset vs. Technique: Intuitive eating is a philosophy with 10 principles to reject diet culture, while mindful eating is a technique for bringing focused awareness to meals.

  • Interconnectedness: Mindful eating is crucial for successfully implementing intuitive eating principles like honoring hunger and feeling fullness.

  • Internal Cues: Intuitive eating teaches trust in internal hunger/satiety cues; mindful eating provides the awareness to notice them.

  • Path for Dieters: Those with diet history may benefit more from intuitive eating's framework; mindful eating is a good entry point for reducing distracted eating.

In This Article

Understanding Intuitive Eating

Intuitive eating is a weight-inclusive framework developed by dietitians Evelyn Tribole and Elyse Resch. It focuses on rejecting the diet mentality and trusting your body's hunger, fullness, and satisfaction cues. This approach extends beyond mealtimes to your overall relationship with food, body image, and self-care. Intuitive eating helps heal your relationship with food, reduces eating anxiety, and promotes body respect by encouraging you to listen to internal signals instead of external diet rules.

The 10 Principles of Intuitive Eating include:

  • Reject the Diet Mentality
  • Honor Your Hunger
  • Make Peace with Food
  • Challenge the Food Police
  • Discover the Satisfaction Factor
  • Feel Your Fullness
  • Cope with Your Emotions with Kindness
  • Respect Your Body
  • Joyful Movement
  • Honor Your Health with Gentle Nutrition

Understanding Mindful Eating

Mindful eating is a practice, based on mindfulness, that involves paying non-judgmental attention to the present moment while eating. It focuses on becoming aware of the sensory qualities of food and minimizing distractions. This practice helps you connect with the physical and emotional sensations during eating, allowing you to observe thoughts and feelings about food without criticism. It aids in slowing down, savoring meals, and identifying emotional eating triggers. While it helps you recognize hunger and fullness, it's a technique applied during meals rather than a complete philosophy like intuitive eating.

Key practices of Mindful Eating include:

  • Eating without distractions (TV, phone, computer).
  • Savoring every bite (taste, texture, smell).
  • Chewing food thoroughly and pausing between bites.
  • Listening to hunger and satiety cues.
  • Acknowledging responses to food without judgment.

Comparison Table: Intuitive vs. Mindful Eating

Feature Intuitive Eating Mindful Eating
Primary Focus Overall relationship with food, body, and diet culture Eating experience and awareness during mealtimes
Scope Broad framework with 10 principles Specific technique applied during meals
Core Goal Reject diet mentality, foster positive body image, trust internal cues Bring non-judgmental awareness to the present moment of eating
Application Lifestyle mindset for all food decisions Tool used to enhance the eating process
Origin Coined by dietitians Tribole and Resch as response to diet culture Rooted in Buddhist mindfulness; adapted for eating
Outcome Improved psychological well-being, body image, reduced disordered eating Enhanced enjoyment, better digestion, identification of eating triggers

How They Intersect: Using Mindful Eating as an Intuitive Tool

Mindful eating is a key part of practicing intuitive eating. Mindful eating can be seen as the 'how-to' of eating, while intuitive eating provides the 'what-to' and 'why-to'. To be a truly intuitive eater, you need to eat mindfully to connect with your body's wisdom. Principles like 'Honor Your Hunger' and 'Feel Your Fullness' rely on the awareness developed through mindful eating. Combining both creates a powerful approach for a healthier relationship with food, moving away from external rules and trusting internal wisdom.

Which Approach is Right for You?

The best approach depends on your history and goals, and you can use both. If you've dieted extensively, intuitive eating's anti-diet framework may be a good starting point. If you eat mindlessly or rush meals, starting with mindful eating techniques can be a helpful first step, gradually integrating other intuitive eating principles. Both can lead to less stress and more enjoyment with food and your body. If you have disordered eating history, seek help from a therapist or dietitian.

How to Begin Combining Intuitive and Mindful Eating

  1. Remove distractions: Dedicate at least one meal daily to eating without screens.
  2. Use a hunger scale: Check your hunger level before eating to reconnect with cues.
  3. Savor satisfaction: Focus on the flavors, textures, and smells of your food.
  4. Pause between bites: This slows you down and helps your brain register fullness.
  5. Challenge inner critic: Acknowledge judgmental thoughts about food without judgment; remember food is morally neutral.
  6. Assess fullness: Check in during and after eating to notice if you're satisfied or overly full.

Conclusion

Intuitive eating and mindful eating are distinct yet complementary. Mindful eating focuses on the experience of eating, while intuitive eating is a framework for healing your relationship with food and rejecting diet culture. Using both approaches together helps you build a nourishing, respectful, and joyful connection with your body and food, leading to greater well-being.

For more information on the principles of intuitive eating, explore the resources available at the official Intuitive Eating website: The Original Intuitive Eating Pros.

Frequently Asked Questions

No. Mindful eating focuses on the present moment of eating, while intuitive eating is a framework with ten principles for a healthier relationship with food and your body.

Yes. Mindful eating can be practiced alone. However, being a truly intuitive eater typically requires mindful eating.

Neither is a weight loss diet. Their goals are to foster a healthier relationship with food and improve well-being.

Start by removing distractions during meals, eating slowly, savoring the sensory experience, and pausing between bites.

The 'food police' refers to the inner voice creating strict, judgmental food rules. Challenging it helps eliminate guilt around eating.

For those with a history of chronic dieting, intuitive eating's comprehensive, anti-diet framework can be more foundational and helpful.

Yes, they are highly complementary. Mindful eating provides awareness tools essential for intuitive eating principles like honoring hunger and fullness.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.