Skip to content

What is the Healthy Eating Pyramid and how does it compare to the eat for health guidelines plate?

2 min read

According to Nutrition Australia, both the Healthy Eating Pyramid and the Eat for Health guidelines plate are based on the same national dietary recommendations. This comparison explores what is the Healthy Eating Pyramid and how it differs from the plate model, helping you visualize and plan your meals more effectively.

Quick Summary

The Healthy Eating Pyramid and the Eat for Health guidelines plate are visual guides representing Australian dietary recommendations. The pyramid shows food proportions through stacked layers, while the plate visualizes meal composition. Both emphasize plant-based foods, lean protein, and healthy fats, while limiting saturated fat, sugar, and salt.

Key Points

  • Visual Guides: Both the Healthy Eating Pyramid and the Eat for Health plate are visual tools based on the Australian Dietary Guidelines.

  • Pyramid's Purpose: The Healthy Eating Pyramid shows long-term dietary proportions, with wider base layers for foods to eat most, like vegetables and grains.

  • Plate's Purpose: The Eat for Health plate is designed for planning individual meals, visualizing portion sizes on a single plate.

  • Core Similarities: Both guides promote a high intake of plant-based foods (vegetables, fruits, whole grains) and moderate consumption of lean proteins and dairy.

  • Discretionary Foods: Both models recommend limiting foods high in saturated fat, added salt, and added sugar, representing them in the smallest sections or outside the main diagrams.

  • Complementary Tools: The pyramid offers a macro-level view of daily intake, while the plate provides a practical, micro-level guide for meal assembly.

  • Basis in Science: Both guides reflect up-to-date scientific research on nutrition and are not influenced by commercial interests.

In This Article

Understanding the Healthy Eating Pyramid

The Healthy Eating Pyramid, developed by Nutrition Australia, visually represents the recommended proportions of different food groups for a healthy diet, based on the Australian Dietary Guidelines. The wider base layers indicate foods to consume in larger quantities, while the narrow top layer signifies foods to eat sparingly.

The Foundation Layers

  • Vegetables and Legumes: The largest layer, emphasizing their importance as sources of vitamins, minerals, and fiber.
  • Fruits and Grains: The next layer, promoting whole grains for their nutrient and fiber content.

The Middle Layers

  • Milk, Yoghurt, Cheese, and Alternatives: Providing calcium and protein, with recommendations for reduced-fat options.
  • Lean Meats, Poultry, Fish, Eggs, Nuts, and Seeds: A source of protein and iron, encouraging a variety of choices.

The Top Layer and Beyond

  • Healthy Fats: Recommended in small amounts, such as those from olive oil and nuts.
  • Other Recommendations: Includes using herbs and spices instead of salt and drinking plenty of water.

Exploring the Australian Guide to Healthy Eating Plate

The Australian Guide to Healthy Eating is another visual guide based on the same national dietary guidelines, using a plate format to illustrate recommended food group proportions for meals. The plate is divided into five sections, each representing a core food group.

  • Largest Sections: Dedicated to grains (mostly wholegrain) and vegetables/legumes.
  • Smaller Sections: Allocated to fruits, lean meats/alternatives, and dairy/alternatives.

Beyond the Plate

The plate model also advises on elements outside the main plate, such as drinking water, using healthy fats minimally, and limiting discretionary foods high in saturated fat, sugar, or salt.

Comparison: Healthy Eating Pyramid vs. Eat for Health Guidelines Plate

Both guides convey the same healthy eating principles but differ in their visual approach and application.

Feature Healthy Eating Pyramid Eat for Health Guidelines Plate
Format Layered triangle. Divided circular plate.
Primary Use General dietary overview over time. Meal composition and portion sizes.
Emphasis Proportionality across the diet. Immediate meal balance.
Food Groups Five core groups plus fats, water, discretionary items in layers. Five core groups plus fats, discretionary items outside plate sections.
Targeted Usefulness Understanding overall dietary patterns and planning. Practical meal assembly.

Conclusion: Which Guide Should You Use?

Both the Healthy Eating Pyramid and the Eat for Health guidelines plate are valuable, complementary tools based on the same Australian Dietary Guidelines. The best choice depends on individual preference and how one visualizes eating habits. The pyramid offers a broader view of daily or weekly intake, highlighting the importance of plant-based foods. The plate provides a more direct guide for building balanced individual meals. Using both can offer a comprehensive approach to healthy eating. The core message remains consistent: prioritize diverse plant-based foods, lean proteins, whole grains, and limit processed foods, salt, and sugar.

Further Reading

For more detailed information on standard serves and the Australian Dietary Guidelines, visit the official government website:

Eat For Health - Australian Dietary Guidelines

Frequently Asked Questions

The main difference is their format and focus. The pyramid provides a general, long-term overview of food proportions across the day, while the plate offers a practical, single-meal visual guide for balancing food groups and portions.

Neither guide is specifically for weight loss, but both provide balanced dietary advice. The plate model might be more useful for portion control during individual meals, while the pyramid helps visualize overall dietary balance. Focusing on the principles of both is key.

These guides are generally applicable to healthy individuals from around 1 to 70 years of age. Those with specific dietary needs, chronic diseases, or children under two may require individualised advice from a healthcare professional.

The Pyramid doesn't exclude any food groups, but it emphasizes eating less from the smaller top layers, which include healthy fats and discretionary items, and most from the wider base layers, like fruits and vegetables.

Yes, both the Healthy Eating Pyramid (from Nutrition Australia) and the Eat for Health Plate are based on the latest available Australian Dietary Guidelines, ensuring they reflect current nutritional science.

Discretionary foods are those not included in the five core food groups, such as sweets, processed snacks, and fried foods. Both guides recommend consuming these foods sparingly, showing them outside the main visuals.

Yes, using both guides can be very effective. The pyramid can inform your overall shopping and dietary approach, while the plate can help you structure and balance specific meals throughout the day.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.