Understanding the Legitimate vs. Faddish Human Milk Diet
The term "human milk diet" refers to two distinct practices. Medically, it denotes the Exclusive Human Milk Diet (EHMD), a feeding approach for preterm infants using breast milk and human milk-derived fortifiers. Conversely, a non-medical and unsupported trend involves adults consuming human milk, often believing it offers unique nutritional or performance advantages. This article will differentiate between these two applications and detail the significant dangers of the adult fad.
The Exclusive Human Milk Diet (EHMD) for Infants
The EHMD is a well-established medical intervention for premature newborns. Because their digestive and immune systems are still developing, human milk provides essential nutrients and immune support. Donor milk used in hospitals and milk banks undergoes screening and pasteurization for safety. Key benefits for infants on an EHMD include optimal nutrition, enhanced immune function, improved digestive health, reduced risk of necrotizing enterocolitis (NEC), and support for neurodevelopment.
The Adult Fad: Misconceptions and Lack of Evidence
Misinformation has led some adults to consume human breast milk, seeking benefits such as improved immunity, muscle growth, or illness treatment. However, experts confirm these claims lack scientific backing. The idea of breast milk as a superior muscle builder is false; it has less protein than cow's milk and is not suited for adult nutritional needs. Beneficial components for infants are largely degraded by adult digestion. Any perceived benefits are likely placebo effects.
Why the adult human milk diet is a dangerous gamble
Consuming unregulated human milk poses significant health risks with no proven benefits.
- Risk of Infectious Diseases: Unscreened human milk can transmit diseases like HIV, Hepatitis B and C, and Syphilis.
- Bacterial Contamination: Studies frequently find high levels of bacteria in human milk bought online due to improper handling, potentially causing serious illness.
- Adulteration and Contaminants: Unregulated milk may contain other substances, drugs, alcohol, or contaminants.
- Nutritional Imbalance: Human milk is not formulated for adult nutritional requirements and would be deficient in a balanced adult diet.
Comparison: Infant Therapy vs. Adult Fad
| Feature | Exclusive Human Milk Diet (Infants) | Adult Human Milk Diet (Fad) |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Lifesaving medical nutrition for premature infants. | Unproven wellness or muscle-building trend. |
| Source | Regulated milk banks with strict donor screening and pasteurization. | Unregulated online sellers, friends, or partners with no screening. |
| Processing | Tested, pasteurized, and stored in sterile conditions. | Sold raw, untested, and often contaminated with bacteria. |
| Scientific Evidence | Extensive clinical evidence and research support its benefits for infants. | Anecdotal claims, zero robust scientific evidence for adults. |
| Safety | High safety standards in a controlled medical environment. | Extremely high risk of infectious disease and bacterial contamination. |
| Nutritional Value | Optimal for infant growth and development. | Nutritionally insufficient for adults, lower protein than cow's milk. |
Conclusion: A Dangerous Trend Based on Misinformation
What is the human milk diet? For infants, it is a medically vital, safe intervention. For adults, it is a risky, unproven fad that exposes individuals to infectious diseases and contamination without scientific benefit. Health organizations warn against consuming unscreened breast milk. Healthy adults should rely on balanced diets and safe, conventional nutritional sources for health and performance. The FDA advises against using donor milk from unscreened sources due to severe health risks.