What Defines Ileal Digestibility?
Ileal digestibility refers to the proportion of ingested protein and amino acids that are digested and absorbed by the body before reaching the end of the small intestine (the ileum). It is the most accurate measure of protein and amino acid availability for metabolic use. This is in stark contrast to older, less precise methods that relied on fecal analysis, which incorrectly accounts for protein and amino acids modified or produced by gut bacteria in the large intestine.
The significance of ileal digestibility is recognized in modern nutritional science, including the adoption of the Digestible Indispensable Amino Acid Score (DIAAS) by the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO). Unlike the older Protein Digestibility-Corrected Amino Acid Score (PDCAAS), DIAAS is based on true ileal digestibility and individual amino acid values, providing a more reliable indicator of protein quality.
Apparent vs. True Ileal Digestibility
When discussing ileal digestibility, it's important to distinguish between apparent and true measurements.
- Apparent Ileal Digestibility (AID): This is calculated by subtracting the amino acids recovered in the ileal digesta from the amount consumed. It does not account for amino acids from endogenous sources (like digestive enzymes and shed intestinal cells) that are present in the digesta.
- True Ileal Digestibility (TID): This is the most accurate measure, as it corrects for the endogenous amino acid losses present in the ileal digesta. By subtracting these endogenous losses, TID provides a value that truly reflects the digestibility of the dietary protein.
Factors Influencing Ileal Protein Digestibility
Several variables affect how well the body can digest and absorb protein at the ileal level.
Protein Source
Animal-based proteins typically have higher ileal digestibility than plant-based proteins. This is largely due to the presence of anti-nutritional factors (ANFs) and the less accessible protein structures found in many plant sources.
- Animal Proteins: High-quality sources like whey, egg, and meat often have very high ileal digestibility values, as evidenced by numerous studies.
- Plant Proteins: Legumes and cereals, for example, often have lower digestibility due to a denser protein matrix and the presence of ANFs. However, processing can significantly improve their digestibility.
Anti-Nutritional Factors (ANFs)
ANFs are compounds in food, particularly plants, that can interfere with protein digestion and nutrient absorption.
- Protease Inhibitors: These compounds, such as trypsin and chymotrypsin inhibitors found in soybeans, can block digestive enzymes from breaking down proteins.
- Phytates and Tannins: These can bind with proteins, making them less accessible to digestive enzymes.
- Fiber: High fiber content can reduce the time food spends in the small intestine and physically hinder enzyme access to protein.
Food Processing
Cooking and other processing methods can drastically impact ileal digestibility by altering protein structure and reducing ANF content.
- Heat Treatment: Techniques like cooking, autoclaving, and extrusion can denature proteins, unfolding their structure and making them more accessible to digestive enzymes. However, excessive heat can sometimes cause protein aggregation, which reduces digestibility.
- Enzymatic Hydrolysis: Breaking proteins down into smaller peptides and amino acids improves digestibility and absorption efficiency.
- Fermentation: This process uses microbes to break down complex proteins and reduce ANFs, enhancing digestibility.
Animal vs. Plant Protein Digestibility
| Factor | Animal Protein | Plant Protein | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Protein Matrix | Generally less complex; higher digestibility. | Often a dense, complex structure; lower digestibility. | Processing can alter this significantly. |
| Anti-Nutritional Factors (ANFs) | Generally negligible amounts. | Can contain inhibitors (e.g., trypsin inhibitors, phytates) that hinder digestion. | Proper processing (cooking, soaking) can mitigate ANF effects. |
| Typical Digestibility | Higher, with values for egg and meat often exceeding 90%. | Lower on average, but varies widely by source and processing. | High-quality isolates (e.g., soy protein isolate) can rival animal proteins. |
| Bioavailability | Faster absorption kinetics for some proteins like whey due to high content of certain amino acids. | Absorption rate is generally slower. | Slower digestion can be beneficial for satiety. |
| Processing Impact | Cooking typically increases digestibility by denaturing proteins. | Processing methods like fermentation and hydrolysis are crucial to improving digestibility. | Excessively high heat can sometimes decrease digestibility. |
How Is Ileal Digestibility Measured?
Accurately measuring ileal digestibility, especially the true value, requires specialized techniques that differentiate dietary protein from endogenous losses.
In Vivo Methods
In human studies, naso-ileal intubation or the use of ileostomates (individuals with a stoma) are the most direct methods.
- Naso-ileal intubation: A tube is inserted to collect digesta directly from the terminal ileum of healthy volunteers.
- Ileostomy Model: Digesta is collected from individuals with a stoma, which allows for robust and repeated testing. In animal nutrition, surgically implanted cannulas in pigs or other livestock models are used to collect ileal digesta.
In Vitro Methods
Due to the cost and invasive nature of in vivo studies, in vitro (laboratory-based) methods are often used as alternatives, though they have limitations.
- Static In Vitro Models: These mimic the human gastrointestinal tract using fixed conditions (e.g., pH, enzymes, temperature) through oral, gastric, and intestinal phases.
- Dynamic In Vitro Models: More complex and advanced systems like TIM-1 simulate the dynamic physiological processes of digestion, including peristalsis and gastric emptying, for more accurate predictions.
Standardized Ileal Digestibility (SID)
In animal feed formulation, standardized ileal digestibility (SID) has become the preferred metric. It corrects for the predictable, baseline (basal) endogenous losses, offering a more consistent and comparable metric for different feed ingredients. Unlike apparent digestibility, SID values are additive in mixed diets, making it invaluable for precise diet formulation.
Conclusion
Understanding what the ileal digestibility of protein is is crucial for accurate nutritional assessment. By measuring protein and amino acid absorption at the end of the small intestine, ileal digestibility provides a far more precise picture of a protein's nutritional value than outdated fecal methods. This metric is influenced by the protein source, the presence of anti-nutritional factors, and how food is processed. As a key component of modern protein quality scoring systems like DIAAS, ileal digestibility is a cornerstone of advanced nutritional science, enabling more effective diet planning for both humans and livestock. The pursuit of maximizing ileal digestibility through better food processing and informed dietary choices ultimately leads to improved protein utilization and better overall health.
For Further Reading
For a detailed overview of plant protein digestibility methods, including both in vivo and in vitro approaches, refer to the comprehensive review by MDPI.