What is the Mediterranean Diet Score (MDS)?
The Mediterranean Diet Score (MDS) is a research tool developed to measure how closely a person's diet matches the traditional eating patterns of the Mediterranean region, particularly in the 1960s. It assesses the overall dietary pattern, not just single nutrients, to study its potential health effects. Researchers use it to quantify diet adherence and link it to various health outcomes, such as cardiovascular disease and cognitive function. Multiple versions of the MDS have been developed to suit different populations and research goals.
The Origins of the Mediterranean Diet Score
A foundational version of the MDS was proposed by Trichopoulou et al. in 1995, based on nine key Mediterranean diet components. This initial score measured adherence against sex-specific median consumption levels in a study population, giving points for high intake of beneficial foods and low intake of detrimental ones. This median-based approach had limitations as it depended heavily on the study population. To address this, other versions using absolute, predefined cut-off points were developed for more consistent measurement across studies.
How Different MDS Versions are Calculated
MDS calculation varies by version but involves summing points based on the frequency of consuming specific food groups. Common MDS variations include:
- Trichopoulou et al. 9-Item Score: Uses a binary (0 or 1 point) system relative to the sample's median consumption for nine food categories. Beneficial items include vegetables, legumes, fruits and nuts, cereals, and fish, while detrimental ones are meat, poultry, and dairy. Moderate alcohol also gets a point.
- The MedDiet Score (Panagiotakos et al.): An 11-item score with a graded system (0 to 5 points) based on monthly consumption frequency. The maximum score is 55, with higher scores indicating better adherence. Developed in Greece, it's used in studies on diet and cardiovascular risk.
- The Mediterranean Diet Adherence Screener (MEDAS): A 14-item questionnaire used in the PREDIMED trial, scoring 0 or 1 per item. It's a simplified clinical tool, with high adherence typically defined as a score of 10 or more.
Key Components of the Mediterranean Diet Score
Most MDS calculations focus on a consistent set of food groups. High scores are linked to high consumption of:
- Fruits, vegetables, legumes, and nuts: Providing fiber, vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants.
- Olive oil: A primary fat source rich in monounsaturated fats.
- Whole grains and cereals: Prioritized over refined options.
- Fish and seafood: Consumed moderately for omega-3 fatty acids.
A high score also means lower consumption of:
- Red meat and processed meats: Typically consumed in very small amounts.
- Sweets and baked goods: Limited intake.
- Full-fat dairy products: Consumed in low to moderate amounts.
Interpreting the Mediterranean Diet Score
MDS interpretation depends on the version used and its score range. Scores are often categorized into low, moderate, or high adherence using quartiles or cut-offs. A high score indicates a healthful diet and is consistently linked to reduced risks of chronic diseases and increased longevity. The extent of risk reduction varies based on factors and specific health outcomes. For example, one study found a higher MDS was inversely associated with total and cardiovascular disease (CVD) deaths.
Comparison of Different Mediterranean Diet Scores
Here's a comparison of three common MDS versions:
| Feature | Trichopoulou et al. MDS | MedDiet Score (Panagiotakos et al.) | Mediterranean Diet Adherence Screener (MEDAS) | 
|---|---|---|---|
| Number of Items | 9 | 11 | 14 | 
| Scoring Range | 0-9 | 0-55 | 0-14 | 
| Scoring Method | Binary (0 or 1 point) based on sex-specific medians | Graded (0-5 points) based on monthly servings | Binary (0 or 1 point) based on specific frequencies | 
| Primary Use Case | Epidemiological research; cohort studies | Clinical and epidemiological research in Mediterranean regions | Clinical practice, PREDIMED trial | 
| Key Food Components | Vegetables, legumes, fruit+nuts, cereals, fish, meat, dairy, fat ratio, alcohol | Non-refined cereals, potatoes, fruits, vegetables, legumes, fish, red meat, poultry, full-fat dairy, olive oil, alcohol | Olive oil, vegetables, fruits, red meat, butter, sugary drinks, legumes, fish, sweets, nuts, sofrito | 
| Pros | Simple, widely-used for comparative research | Graded scale offers higher sensitivity to consumption differences | Quick, easy to administer in clinical settings | 
| Cons | Score is relative to the study population's diet | Monthly frequency can be challenging for users to recall accurately | Simplified scoring may miss nuances of adherence | 
The Significance and Limitations of MDS
The MDS is a valuable tool for understanding the broader health impacts of dietary patterns. Research using MDS has confirmed the health benefits of the Mediterranean diet and influenced public health recommendations. A high MDS is linked to positive health markers like lower BMI, blood pressure, and inflammation. However, limitations exist, including reliance on potentially biased self-reported data from FFQs. Some scores also don't fully account for regional variations or overconsumption of certain foods. Modified versions have been created to be more culturally sensitive and address methodological issues.
Conclusion
The Mediterranean Diet Score (MDS) quantifies adherence to the healthful Mediterranean dietary pattern, allowing researchers to link this eating style to significant health benefits. Various versions exist, such as the 9-item score and the 14-item MEDAS, all measuring intake of key food groups. Knowing which score is used is vital for interpreting research. The MDS highlights the importance of focusing on broad dietary patterns for optimal health. Aiming for a high MDS is a proven strategy for promoting longevity and reducing chronic disease risk.
Outbound link recommendation: Definitions and potential health benefits of the Mediterranean diet: a forum article