Skip to content

Which Form of Zinc Is Better Absorbed? A Guide to Bioavailability

3 min read

An estimated 17 to 20% of the global population is at risk for zinc deficiency, making zinc supplements a common solution. However, the effectiveness of supplementation hinges on one critical factor: which form of zinc is better absorbed by the body. This guide explores the different types of zinc and their bioavailability.

Quick Summary

This article examines the comparative bioavailability of different zinc supplements, including chelated forms like bisglycinate and picolinate, against common salts such as gluconate and oxide. It details which forms offer superior absorption for maximizing health benefits.

Key Points

  • Chelated Forms Are Superior: Zinc bisglycinate and zinc picolinate, which are chelated (bound to amino acids), offer the highest bioavailability and are gentler on the digestive system.

  • Gluconate and Citrate Are Good: Common, affordable forms like zinc gluconate and zinc citrate are well-absorbed, better than zinc oxide, and suitable for general supplementation.

  • Avoid Zinc Oxide for Oral Use: Zinc oxide has the lowest bioavailability and is poorly absorbed when taken orally, making it a poor choice for internal supplements.

  • Watch for Dietary Inhibitors: Dietary factors like phytates (in grains and legumes) and high doses of other minerals such as iron and calcium can inhibit zinc absorption.

  • Consider Your Goal: Choose based on your objective; chelated forms are best for targeted supplementation or deficiency, while gluconate or citrate may be sufficient for general immune support.

In This Article

Understanding Zinc Absorption

Zinc is a vital mineral involved in over 300 enzymatic reactions, immune function, DNA synthesis, and wound healing. The body absorbs zinc in the small intestine, but this process is not uniform across all forms of zinc. Factors like the compound to which zinc is bound, dietary inhibitors (like phytates), and individual health status can all influence how well zinc is absorbed. Supplemental zinc is available in many forms, each with varying degrees of bioavailability.

Bioavailability of Common Zinc Forms

Zinc Bisglycinate

Zinc bisglycinate is a chelated form, meaning zinc is bound to two glycine molecules, an amino acid. Research suggests this form offers superior absorption and excellent tolerability, making it gentler on the stomach than other types. One study found that zinc bisglycinate was absorbed 43.4% better than zinc gluconate. Its chelated structure helps it bypass some dietary inhibitors, leading to more efficient uptake.

Zinc Picolinate

In this chelated form, zinc is bound to picolinic acid, which is naturally produced by the body. A double-blind, four-week crossover trial found that zinc picolinate significantly increased zinc levels in hair, urine, and red blood cells, whereas zinc citrate and gluconate did not produce a significant change. This indicates picolinate has high bioavailability, though some short-term studies suggest others may have a faster initial uptake.

Zinc Citrate and Gluconate

Often found in popular over-the-counter supplements, zinc citrate and zinc gluconate are generally considered well-absorbed, especially when compared to zinc oxide. For instance, a study comparing fractional zinc absorption in healthy adults found that zinc citrate and zinc gluconate had similar absorption rates, both significantly higher than zinc oxide. Zinc gluconate is widely used in cold remedies like lozenges.

Zinc Sulfate

Zinc sulfate is a water-soluble zinc salt that is less bioavailable and more likely to cause stomach irritation than chelated forms. While effective as a supplement, it has a bitter taste and is often the cheapest form available. Some studies on fortified foods have found little difference in absorption between zinc sulfate and zinc oxide, suggesting a potentially lower absorption rate than chelated varieties.

Zinc Oxide

Zinc oxide is the least bioavailable and most poorly absorbed of the common supplemental forms. Studies show it is absorbed significantly less than zinc gluconate and zinc citrate. Its poor solubility makes it less efficient for internal supplementation, though it is widely used topically in sunscreens and ointments.

Comparison of Common Zinc Supplements

Form of Zinc Bioavailability Tolerability Common Uses Notes
Zinc Bisglycinate Highest Excellent Daily supplementation, immune support Chelated, well-absorbed, and gentle on the stomach.
Zinc Picolinate High Good Addressing deficiency, general health Chelated, historically shown superior absorption in some long-term studies.
Zinc Gluconate Moderate-High Good Cold lozenges, general supplementation Widely available, well-absorbed but less so than chelated forms.
Zinc Citrate Moderate-High Good Daily supplements, cold remedies Comparable absorption to gluconate, less bitter taste.
Zinc Sulfate Low-Moderate Poor (can cause irritation) Cheapest supplements, acne treatment Can cause stomach upset, less bioavailable than chelated options.
Zinc Oxide Lowest Poor (for oral use) Topical applications (creams, sunscreen) Least suitable for internal supplementation due to poor absorption.

Factors Affecting Overall Zinc Absorption

Besides the form of the supplement, several other factors influence how effectively your body absorbs zinc. Dietary components are a major influence. Phytates, found in grains, legumes, nuts, and seeds, can inhibit zinc absorption by binding to it in the digestive tract. The presence of other minerals, especially high doses of iron or calcium, can also interfere with zinc uptake. Taking zinc with food can mitigate stomach upset but might reduce overall absorption, so some experts recommend taking it on an empty stomach unless it causes nausea. However, the most critical factor remains the inherent bioavailability of the specific zinc compound you choose.

Conclusion: Choosing the Right Zinc Supplement

For those seeking the most effective way to increase their zinc levels through supplementation, the choice of form is paramount. Chelated forms, particularly zinc bisglycinate and zinc picolinate, consistently demonstrate higher bioavailability and better tolerability than inorganic salts like zinc oxide and zinc sulfate. Zinc gluconate and citrate offer a good balance of effectiveness and affordability for general maintenance. Ultimately, if maximizing absorption is the priority, opting for a high-quality chelated zinc is the best strategy. As with any supplement, consulting a healthcare provider is recommended to determine the optimal dosage and form for your individual health needs. Information on the role of chelation in mineral absorption can be found at the National Institutes of Health.

Frequently Asked Questions

Both are excellent, chelated forms of zinc with high bioavailability. Some studies suggest zinc bisglycinate may be absorbed slightly better acutely and is often better tolerated by the stomach, while zinc picolinate has demonstrated strong long-term absorption.

Chelated zinc, such as bisglycinate or picolinate, is bound to organic molecules like amino acids. This process makes it easier for the body to absorb the mineral, as it is protected from dietary inhibitors and can be transported more efficiently across the intestinal wall.

Yes, taking zinc with food can help mitigate gastrointestinal side effects like nausea. However, note that some foods, particularly those high in phytates (grains, legumes), may interfere with absorption. If taken with food, it is generally recommended to avoid foods high in phytates or wait a couple of hours.

For cold lozenges, zinc acetate is often recommended, with some studies suggesting it may be more effective at reducing cold duration than zinc gluconate. Zinc gluconate is also a very common and effective form used in cold remedies.

Orally, zinc oxide is the least bioavailable and is poorly absorbed, making it an ineffective choice for supplementation. It is best used for topical applications like sunscreens and skin treatments.

High-dose supplements containing iron or calcium can interfere with zinc absorption. It is best to take zinc at a different time of day, at least two hours apart from these minerals, to maximize absorption.

Elemental zinc is the actual amount of pure zinc in a supplement. Bioavailability determines how much of this elemental zinc your body can use. Always check the label for the elemental zinc content to ensure you are getting the dose you need.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.