Skip to content

Why Don't Muslims Drink Water During Fasting?

5 min read

Millions of Muslims worldwide observe the holy month of Ramadan by fasting from dawn until dusk, a practice that includes a strict abstention from all food and drink, including water. For those unfamiliar with Islamic traditions, the question of why Muslims don't drink water during fasting is often raised, highlighting a profound aspect of this act of worship.

Quick Summary

Muslims abstain from water while fasting from dawn to sunset during Ramadan as a core act of devotion and self-discipline mandated by Islamic principles. This practice fosters empathy for the less fortunate, strengthens one's connection with Allah, and allows for spiritual purification.

Key Points

  • Spiritual Devotion: Abstaining from water is a core act of submission to Allah, demonstrating complete obedience and willpower.

  • Empathy and Compassion: The experience of thirst fosters empathy for the poor and reminds fasters of their blessings, encouraging charitable deeds.

  • Self-Discipline: Resisting the basic need for water trains the soul to control desires, a form of spiritual discipline known as jihad an-nafs.

  • Validating the Fast: Drinking water intentionally invalidates the fast, while doing so out of forgetfulness does not, a rule that highlights the importance of intention.

  • Exemptions for Hardship: Islam provides compassionate exemptions from fasting for the sick, elderly, travelers, and women who are pregnant or menstruating, reflecting the principle of avoiding undue difficulty.

  • Holistic Purification: The fast is a means of purifying both the body and the soul, with the physical deprivation leading to enhanced spiritual clarity and taqwa (God-consciousness).

In This Article

The Foundational Principle of Fasting (Sawm)

Fasting, known as Sawm in Arabic, is one of the five pillars of Islam, a fundamental act of worship for every able-bodied Muslim. The practice is clearly defined in the Quran, specifically in Surah Al-Baqarah (2:183), which states, “O you who have believed, decreed upon you is fasting as it was decreed upon those before you that you may become righteous”. This verse establishes the divine command for fasting and clarifies that its purpose is to develop taqwa, or God-consciousness. The act of fasting involves consciously abstaining from all things that are otherwise permissible—food, drink, and sexual activity—from the break of dawn until sunset.

The Spiritual Significance of Abstaining from Water

The prohibition of water during fasting hours is not a mere side effect of abstaining from food, but a deliberate and significant part of the spiritual journey. It emphasizes a complete submission to the will of Allah, where believers willingly give up their most basic needs for His sake. The feeling of thirst serves as a powerful reminder of one’s dependence on Allah and a profound empathy for those who live in conditions of scarcity. By experiencing hunger and thirst, Muslims gain a deeper appreciation for the blessings they often take for granted.

  • Empathy for the Needy: The act of experiencing thirst allows for a tangible sense of what the poor and less fortunate endure daily. This cultivates compassion and encourages charitable acts, which are also highly rewarded during Ramadan.
  • Enhancing Self-Control: The discipline required to resist even a single sip of water strengthens a believer’s willpower and trains them to control their desires and passions. This spiritual training extends beyond the fasting hours, helping individuals avoid all other sinful behavior, such as lying or arguing.
  • Purification of the Soul: Just as the body is cleansed of toxins, the soul is cleansed of spiritual impurities through sincere fasting. The fast is a way to recalibrate one’s moral compass and focus on righteous deeds, prayer, and remembrance of Allah.
  • Focus on Spiritual Growth: Fasting shifts a person's focus from physical needs to spiritual reflection. By starving the body's physical needs, one feeds the soul, leading to enhanced spiritual clarity and mindfulness of Allah's presence.

Rules for Breaking and Exemptions from Fasting

Islamic jurisprudence (Fiqh) provides clear guidelines on what invalidates the fast and who is exempt. While intentionally consuming food or water during daylight hours nullifies the fast, consuming it forgetfully does not. There are also compassionate exemptions for those unable to fast due to legitimate reasons.

Comparison: Intentional vs. Forgetful Consumption

Feature Intentional Eating/Drinking Forgetful Eating/Drinking
Effect on Fast Invalidates the fast Fast remains valid
Required Action Must repent and make up the missed day later No action required; continue fasting
Spiritual Impact Considered a major sin if done without valid reason No negative spiritual impact; viewed as a mercy from Allah

Exemptions and Considerations

For those who are unable to fast, Islam provides flexibility and alternative arrangements to ensure no undue hardship is placed upon believers. These include:

  • The Sick: Individuals with temporary or chronic illnesses that would be worsened by fasting can break their fast. They must make up the missed days later if they recover, or pay fidyah (feeding a needy person for each missed day) if they have a permanent condition.
  • Travelers: Those traveling a significant distance are permitted to break their fast and make up the days later.
  • Women: Pregnant and breastfeeding women, or those experiencing menstruation or postnatal bleeding, are excused from fasting. They must make up the missed days after Ramadan.
  • The Elderly: The frail or elderly who are medically unfit to fast are exempted and may pay fidyah instead.

Conclusion: Beyond Simple Deprivation

The prohibition of drinking water during the fast is a cornerstone of the spiritual discipline of Ramadan. It is not an arbitrary rule but a powerful tool for cultivating deeper spiritual qualities, such as empathy, self-control, and gratitude. The practice, while physically challenging, aims to cleanse the soul and draw believers closer to Allah. The feeling of thirst becomes a tangible connection to the struggles of others and a reminder of the immense blessings that are often overlooked. By abstaining from even the most basic necessity like water, Muslims affirm their submission and devotion, ensuring their fast is not merely an act of starvation but a profound journey of spiritual transformation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Is it permissible to drink water accidentally during fasting? A: No, if someone unintentionally eats or drinks while fasting, the fast is not broken. They should stop as soon as they remember and continue their fast.

Q: How do Muslims stay hydrated during non-fasting hours? A: Muslims are advised to drink plenty of water between the evening meal (Iftar) and the pre-dawn meal (Suhoor) to prevent dehydration.

Q: What happens if a person feels very weak while fasting? A: While minor discomfort is part of the fast, if a person feels severely weak and fears for their health, they are permitted to break their fast. The missed day must be made up later.

Q: Can one brush their teeth or shower while fasting? A: Yes, it is permissible to brush your teeth and take a bath while fasting. Care should be taken not to swallow any water while rinsing the mouth.

Q: Why do many Muslims break their fast with dates and water? A: Following the tradition of the Prophet Muhammad, it is customary and considered a blessed act (Sunnah) to break the fast with dates and water.

Q: Does taking a nutritional IV drip break the fast? A: Yes, a nutritional IV drip provides sustenance and therefore invalidates the fast. However, non-nutritive injections, such as vaccines, do not.

Q: Is one required to fast if they are in a polar region with no sunset? A: No, Islamic law provides a concession for Muslims in such regions. They may follow the fasting times of the nearest country with regular days and nights, or use the fasting duration of Mecca.

Frequently Asked Questions

The same rules for fasting apply to any voluntary or obligatory fast in Islam. This includes abstaining from all food and drink, including water, from dawn until sunset.

The pre-dawn meal is called Suhoor. It is a recommended practice to have this meal, and drinking plenty of water during this time is encouraged to prepare for the day's fast.

Fasting is a test of endurance, but if the heat poses a genuine health risk, such as severe dehydration, it may become permissible to break the fast. A medical assessment and consideration of alternative fasts later is advised.

The wisdom lies in promoting total self-control and submission to Allah. Abstaining from even a basic necessity like water proves one's sincerity and dependence on God alone.

Gargling with water is permitted during fasting, for instance during the ritual ablution (wudu), as long as no water is swallowed. Care must be taken to ensure this.

Some limited studies suggest potential anti-inflammatory and other health effects from intermittent dry fasting, but many health experts warn of the dangers of dehydration, especially with prolonged or repeated dry fasting. The primary purpose of Ramadan fasting is spiritual, not medical.

Yes, it is traditional and recommended to break the fast immediately after sunset. It is a Sunnah to do so with dates and water before performing the evening prayer (Maghrib).

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.