Skip to content

Are SodaStream drinks healthy? A Comprehensive Guide

4 min read

According to research, substituting homemade soda for store-bought can save up to 100,000 calories per year, making many wonder: are SodaStream drinks healthy? The simple answer lies in what you add to your sparkling water, giving you complete control over your beverage's nutritional content.

Quick Summary

The healthiness of SodaStream beverages is determined by the syrups and flavors added. Plain sparkling water is a zero-calorie, hydrating choice. Flavored options range from low-sugar to zero-calorie, offering a healthier alternative to commercial sodas with customizable sweetness.

Key Points

  • Plain is Best: The base of any SodaStream drink—carbonated water—is zero-calorie and just as hydrating as still water, making it the healthiest option.

  • Flavors Vary: The healthiness of a SodaStream drink is determined by the flavorings you add. Options range from sugar-laden classic mixes to zero-calorie, all-natural fruit essences.

  • DIY Control: For maximum health benefits, you can flavor your sparkling water with fresh fruit, herbs, or natural sweeteners, bypassing all artificial ingredients.

  • Better Than Bottled: Even classic SodaStream syrups contain significantly less sugar than store-bought sodas, making them a healthier transitional option for cutting sugar intake.

  • Myths Debunked: Plain sparkling water does not significantly damage tooth enamel or affect bone density, contrary to common misconceptions often associated with sugary carbonated drinks.

In This Article

The Healthiness of SodaStream: A Balancing Act

The fundamental component of any SodaStream drink is simply carbonated water. On its own, sparkling water is just as hydrating as still water, calorie-free, and contains no sugar. The 'healthy' or 'unhealthy' aspect is entirely dependent on the flavorings you choose to add. Unlike pre-packaged sodas with fixed, often high, sugar content, SodaStream offers a spectrum of flavor options, empowering you to control the nutritional impact of your drink. This customization is the key differentiator for health-conscious consumers.

Decoding SodaStream's Flavor Options

SodaStream offers a wide array of flavor syrups to suit different tastes and dietary needs. Understanding the ingredients in each type is crucial for making informed choices.

Classic Drink Mixes

These syrups are formulated to replicate the taste of traditional sodas. While they contain sugar, SodaStream states they typically have at least 50% less sugar than major store-bought brands. They often use a combination of natural sugar and artificial sweeteners like sucralose to achieve a lower calorie count.

Zero-Sugar and Diet Flavors

For those watching their calorie and sugar intake, the Zero-Sugar and Diet lines are the healthiest flavored options. These mixes use non-nutritive sweeteners such as stevia leaf extract and erythritol to provide sweetness without the added calories.

Unsweetened Flavor Essences (Bubly drops)

These are perhaps the healthiest pre-made option available. Bubly drops contain no sugar, no calories, and are made from natural fruit essences, providing a subtle hint of flavor without any sweeteners or artificial ingredients.

Organic and Natural Flavor Concentrates

SodaStream's Soda Press Co. line offers organic, all-natural options sweetened with sugar but with a much lower sugar content than conventional sodas. This provides a middle ground for those who prefer natural ingredients over artificial sweeteners but still want some sweetness.

DIY: Crafting Your Own Healthy Sodas

For ultimate control, you can bypass SodaStream's syrups entirely and create your own healthier flavorings. This is the surest way to guarantee a truly healthy homemade soda.

  • Fresh Fruit Juice: Use a splash of fresh-squeezed orange, lime, or grapefruit juice.
  • Herbs and Spices: Infuse your sparkling water with fresh mint, ginger, or cucumber slices.
  • Natural Sweeteners: If you need a touch of sweetness, use a small amount of raw honey or maple syrup with your fruit infusions.
  • Water Enhancers: Third-party sugar-free water enhancers with natural ingredients can also be an option.

Potential Health Concerns: Debunking Myths

Some myths surround the health effects of sparkling water, primarily related to dental and bone health. Scientific evidence has largely debunked these concerns.

  • Dental Health: The mild acidity of plain sparkling water is not a significant threat to tooth enamel, especially when compared to sugary sodas. The key issue with commercial sodas is not the carbonation but the combination of sugar and acid.
  • Bone Health: There is no evidence that carbonated water negatively affects bone density or causes osteoporosis. This myth stems from studies on cola-type sodas, which contain phosphoric acid and are not the same as plain sparkling water.
  • Artificial Ingredients: Some classic syrups do contain artificial colors and sweeteners, which some people may want to avoid. It is always wise to read the ingredient label to make an informed choice.

SodaStream vs. Store-Bought Soda: A Nutritional Comparison

Feature Plain SodaStream Water SodaStream Flavored Soda (Classic) Commercial Brand Soda DIY SodaStream (Juice + Stevia)
Calories (per 8 oz) 0 ~35-70 ~100 ~5-25 (depending on ingredients)
Sugar 0 Less than 50% vs commercial Up to 15 teaspoons per serving Very low or zero
Sweeteners None Sugar, sucralose High-fructose corn syrup Stevia, honey, maple syrup (optional)
Artificial Ingredients None Potential food dyes, caramel color Common (HFCS, phosphoric acid, artificial colors) None (user dependent)
Health Impact Excellent hydration, calorie-free A better alternative, but still a treat Linked to weight gain, diabetes, etc. Highly beneficial, customizable nutrition

Conclusion: Your Choices Define the Outcome

So, are SodaStream drinks healthy? The answer is a resounding 'yes,' but with a crucial asterisk: the user is in control. The machine itself produces nothing but water and bubbles, a perfectly healthy beverage. By choosing zero-calorie drops or making your own flavorings from fresh ingredients, you can enjoy a delicious, bubbly drink that is vastly healthier than anything from a can or bottle.

SodaStream serves as a tool to promote healthier hydration habits, particularly for those who find plain water unappealing. It's an excellent way to reduce your intake of sugary sodas, which carry significant health risks. For ingredient information on specific flavors, always refer to the official SodaStream website Check here for detailed flavor information on the SodaStream website.

Ultimately, whether a SodaStream drink is healthy depends on your choices. It enables a personalized approach to hydration, allowing you to gradually reduce your reliance on sugar and embrace a healthier, more customizable fizzy drink experience.

Frequently Asked Questions

Plain SodaStream sparkling water is not bad for your teeth. Its mild acidity is far less harmful than sugary sodas. The combination of sugar and acid in commercial soft drinks is what causes significant tooth decay.

No, plain sparkling water does not cause bone density loss. This myth is based on studies of sugary colas containing phosphoric acid, which are different from plain carbonated water.

SodaStream's zero-sugar and diet flavors are a healthier alternative to full-sugar sodas, containing no calories. However, they are sweetened with artificial or natural non-nutritive sweeteners, so plain sparkling water remains the healthiest choice.

Yes, you can use your own homemade syrups. For the healthiest option, create your own flavorings using fresh fruit, herbs, and a natural sweetener like honey or stevia. Only carbonate plain water, and then add your flavorings afterwards.

Most SodaStream flavored drinks are nutritionally superior to commercial sodas. Classic syrups have at least 50% less sugar, while zero-sugar options contain no sugar or calories at all, offering significantly better health outcomes.

No, the carbonation itself is not harmful. It is created by infusing water with carbon dioxide (CO2). While excessive consumption might cause temporary bloating or indigestion for some, it is generally safe.

The healthiest flavor options are the unsweetened bubly drops, which contain natural fruit essences with zero calories and zero sugar. The next best are DIY options using fresh fruits and herbs.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.