Why the confusion over the number of food groups?
The perception of whether there are 5 or 6 food groups largely depends on which dietary guide you are following. The USDA's MyPlate system, for instance, uses five core groups. Other guidelines, or historical models, might include a sixth group or categorize foods differently. This variation reflects different ways of communicating nutritional advice, such as separating fruits and vegetables or including healthy fats as a distinct group.
The 5 food groups according to USDA's MyPlate
The most current U.S. guideline, MyPlate, includes these five core groups:
- Fruits: This group covers all fruits and 100% fruit juices, whether fresh, canned, frozen, or dried.
- Vegetables: A diverse group including dark green, red and orange, starchy, and legume varieties.
- Grains: Encompasses both whole grains (like brown rice) and refined grains (like white bread).
- Protein Foods: A broad category including various meats, poultry, seafood, beans, eggs, nuts, and seeds.
- Dairy: Includes milk, yogurt, cheese, and fortified soy milk, as well as other calcium-rich alternatives.
MyPlate also acknowledges the importance of oils, which contain essential fatty acids, but classifies them separately from the main groups.
The 6 food groups model
Some dietary models, such as certain international guides or older classifications, use a six-group structure. A common six-group breakdown explicitly includes 'Healthy Fats and Oils' as a separate category. Other variations might split protein or combine fruits and vegetables. Explicitly including oils highlights their role in nutrient absorption and energy, which is mentioned separately in the five-group model.
A comparison of dietary models: MyPlate vs. a 6-group model
| Feature | MyPlate (5-group model) | 6-group model (varied examples) | 
|---|---|---|
| Number of Core Groups | 5 (Fruits, Vegetables, Grains, Protein, Dairy) | 6 (Often adds 'Healthy Fats and Oils') | 
| Oil/Fat Classification | Emphasized separately, not a core group. | Explicitly included as its own core group. | 
| Plate Visualization | Uses a plate graphic showing proportional servings. | Does not have a single standard graphic; often described via list or pyramid. | 
| Fruits & Vegetables | Separate groups, with vegetables slightly larger on the plate. | Often combined into a single 'Fruits and Vegetables' group or kept separate. | 
| Legumes/Beans | Classified within the vegetable group and also the protein group. | Clearly included within the protein or vegetable/legume group. | 
| Focus | Simplified visual guide for easy meal planning and portion control. | May focus more on specific nutritional components and their importance. | 
Which model should you follow?
The specific number of food groups is less crucial than adhering to the principles of a balanced diet. Most modern nutrition guidance, regardless of the number of groups, emphasizes variety. Both the MyPlate and common six-group models stress including a diverse range of fruits, vegetables, whole grains, lean proteins, and dairy or alternatives to ensure adequate intake of vitamins, minerals, and macronutrients.
The Harvard Healthy Eating Plate provides another valuable visual guide, recommending half a plate of fruits and vegetables, a quarter whole grains, and a quarter healthy protein, along with healthy oils and water. This offers a similar approach to MyPlate with some different emphases.
The importance of context in food group models
Nutritional guidance has evolved, simplifying from older models like the 'Basic Four' or 'Basic Seven' to reflect current scientific understanding. A five-group model often prioritizes simplicity, while a six-group model might offer more detail by separating healthy fats. Understanding that the number varies by classification system helps clarify the confusion. The primary goal is always to encourage a balanced, nutrient-dense diet.
Conclusion
There is no single, universal answer to whether there are 5 or 6 food groups; it depends on the specific dietary model used. The U.S. primarily uses the five-group MyPlate system, while others may use six groups, often by including oils as a separate category or combining fruits and vegetables. The key is not the exact number of groups but rather ensuring a varied intake of nutrient-rich foods from the core categories to support health.