What is Bonemeal and How is it Used?
Bonemeal is a dry, inert powder created from dried and defatted animal bones, typically from cattle. The processing involves heating and grinding the bones into a fine powder or granules. This product is primarily used for two purposes:
- Fertilizer: Bonemeal serves as a slow-release, organic fertilizer rich in phosphorus and calcium for plants. It helps promote strong root growth and flowering, especially in plants growing in acidic soil.
- Animal Feed Supplement: It is used as a mineral supplement for livestock, including cattle, swine, and poultry, to provide a source of calcium and phosphorus. This practice is, however, subject to strict regulations in many regions to prevent disease transmission.
Historically, bonemeal was also used as a human dietary supplement, particularly for its high calcium content. However, this practice is now strongly discouraged due to modern safety concerns.
The Significant Health Dangers of Consuming Bonemeal
While it might seem like a natural way to get calcium, consuming bonemeal is fraught with health risks that make it an unsafe choice for human nutrition. The major concerns revolve around contamination with heavy metals and the potential for disease transmission.
Heavy Metal Contamination
- Lead and Mercury: One of the most significant risks is the presence of toxic heavy metals, particularly lead and mercury, which can accumulate in animal bones. Studies have analyzed commercial bonemeal samples and found significant amounts of these potentially toxic metals. Consuming these can lead to heavy metal poisoning, affecting the neurological, gastrointestinal, and hematologic systems. A notable historical case involves actress Allison Hayes, who suffered from lead poisoning in the 1970s from a bonemeal calcium supplement.
- Accumulation: The body can accumulate lead over time, and because calcium and lead have similar atomic structures, lead can be stored in the bones, leading to long-term health issues.
Risk of Infectious Agents
- Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy (BSE): Commonly known as "mad cow disease," BSE can be transmitted through animal by-products used in feed and supplements, including bonemeal. While strict regulations and processing protocols aim to reduce this risk for animal feed, the infectious prion proteins are extremely difficult to destroy completely. Given the severe, fatal nature of the disease in humans (Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease), the risk is simply too high for direct human consumption.
- Other Pathogens: Inadequately processed bonemeal can also carry bacterial contaminants like Salmonella, which can cause foodborne illnesses.
The Difference Between Bonemeal and Bone Broth
It's crucial to differentiate bonemeal from bone broth, a popular culinary item often praised for its health benefits. The two are entirely different products with distinct safety profiles.
- Bone Broth: This is a liquid stock made by simmering animal bones, meat, and connective tissue for an extended period. The process extracts minerals and collagen into the liquid. As a food product, bone broth is safe for human consumption and is a good source of protein, minerals, and collagen.
- Bonemeal: This is the ground-up, solid bone material itself. It is not meant to be eaten directly by humans and carries the significant contamination risks detailed above. Consuming bonemeal is not the same as consuming bone broth.
Safer Alternatives to Bonemeal for Calcium Intake
Given the serious risks, bonemeal should never be considered a source of human nutrition. Fortunately, there are many safe and readily available alternatives to meet your calcium needs.
- Refined Calcium Supplements: Look for supplements containing calcium carbonate, calcium citrate, or calcium phosphate. These are produced in controlled laboratory settings to minimize heavy metal contamination and are widely available.
- Dairy Products: Milk, yogurt, and cheese are excellent sources of highly bioavailable calcium.
- Fortified Foods: Many cereals, plant-based milks (almond, soy), and juices are fortified with calcium.
- Green Leafy Vegetables: Collard greens, kale, and broccoli are good non-dairy sources of calcium.
- Fish with Edible Bones: Canned sardines and salmon with bones are rich in calcium.
Bonemeal vs. Bone Broth: A Comparison
| Feature | Bonemeal | Bone Broth |
|---|---|---|
| Composition | Ground, defatted, and dried animal bones. | Liquid stock from simmering bones, meat, and connective tissue. |
| Primary Use | Organic fertilizer for plants; mineral supplement for livestock. | Culinary ingredient for soups, stews, and beverages. |
| Safety for Humans | Unsafe due to heavy metal and prion contamination risks. | Generally Safe as a food item when prepared properly. |
| Associated Risks | Lead/mercury poisoning, BSE transmission, pathogenic bacteria. | Minor risks limited to improper preparation; generally considered safe. |
| Nutrient Form | Concentrated calcium and phosphorus in a raw, solid form. | Bioavailable minerals, collagen, and amino acids in liquid form. |
Conclusion
In conclusion, the answer to the question "Can humans eat bonemeal?" is a definitive no. Despite being a source of calcium and phosphorus, the significant risks of heavy metal contamination and disease transmission make it unsafe for human consumption. There are far safer, more effective, and better-regulated alternatives available, ranging from refined supplements to a wide variety of dietary sources. Always prioritize well-established, safe nutritional options over dangerous and outdated practices. For those seeking joint or gut health benefits from bones, bone broth is a safe and beneficial alternative to bonemeal. For more information on dietary safety and healthy alternatives, consult authoritative sources like the Food and Drug Administration or the World Health Organization.
Recommended Outbound Link
For more information on the risks of heavy metal contamination, refer to the following study on bone meal toxicity: Potential toxicity due to dolomite and bonemeal
