Federal Regulations on Interstate Raw Milk Shipping
U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) regulation (21 CFR § 1240.61) prohibits the interstate commercial sale of raw milk for direct human consumption, requiring milk and milk products sold across state lines to be pasteurized to protect public health by killing harmful bacteria like E. coli, Salmonella, and Listeria.
FDA’s Enforcement Stance
The FDA has clarified that it does not intend to pursue enforcement against individuals transporting raw milk across state lines for their own personal consumption, but this does not override state laws. Commercial interstate shipment remains prohibited.
Legislative Efforts to Alter Federal Law
Legislation like the "Interstate Milk Freedom Act" has been introduced in Congress to allow interstate raw milk traffic under state-compliant conditions, supported by farm-to-consumer groups, but these efforts have not yet changed federal law.
State-by-State Raw Milk Laws and Shipping Implications
States regulate raw milk sales within their borders (intrastate), leading to varied laws on its availability, from retail sales to bans.
Common State-Level Methods for Acquiring Raw Milk:
- On-Farm Sales
- Herd-Share Programs
- Retail Store Sales
- Delivery Services
The Interstate Transport Challenge
The federal commercial interstate shipping ban still applies even when raw milk is legal in both the origin and destination states. This prevents commercial shipping between states, making personal transport for non-commercial use the only method, subject to both states' laws.
Comparison Table: Federal vs. State Raw Milk Regulations
| Feature | Federal Regulation (FDA) | State-Level Regulations | Implications for Shipping |
|---|---|---|---|
| Commercial Sale | Prohibited in final package form for human consumption across state lines. | Varies significantly by state, from retail sales to complete bans. | Commercial interstate shipping is illegal, regardless of state laws. |
| Personal Transport | Does not actively enforce against individuals transporting for personal use. | Governs legality of initial purchase and possession within state borders. | Transport for personal consumption is a legal grey area, subject to the laws of both states. |
| Regulatory Framework | Enforced by the FDA based on food safety concerns. | Determined by state health departments and agriculture agencies. | A producer must comply with both the destination and origin states' laws and avoid triggering federal interstate commerce prohibitions. |
| Enforcement Targets | Historically focuses on commercial enterprises and large-scale distribution. | Varies, can target producers, sellers, or distributors violating state laws. | Farmers and distributors involved in any interstate sales risk federal enforcement action. |
The Role of Herd Shares in Navigating Regulations
Herd shares allow members, as part-owners of dairy animals, to receive raw milk, primarily within state borders, effectively bypassing some state sales regulations. However, shipping herd-share milk across state lines commercially is still prohibited by the federal ban.
The Risks of Raw Milk Consumption
Federal health agencies like the FDA and CDC warn that raw milk can cause foodborne illnesses from bacteria such as Listeria, E. coli, and Salmonella, which pasteurization eliminates. They state that raw milk's claimed health benefits lack scientific proof and that its risks are significant, especially for vulnerable groups.
Conclusion
The federal ban on the interstate commercial shipment of raw milk for human consumption (21 CFR § 1240.61) remains a major obstacle. While the FDA allows individuals to transport raw milk for personal use across state lines, this doesn't apply to businesses. The legality of raw milk is a complex mix of federal interstate law and varied state intrastate regulations. The conflict between consumer choice and public health concerns makes shipping raw milk across state lines a legally challenging issue.
Navigating the Legal Landscape
- Individual consumers can usually transport raw milk across state lines for personal consumption if it's legal in both states.
- Commercial entities cannot use interstate shipping for raw milk due to the federal ban.
- Herd shares are primarily for intrastate access and don't allow interstate commercial shipping.
- Always check state laws for specific regulations on sales and delivery.
The Path Forward
Advocates seek to change federal law through lobbying and supporting legislation like the Interstate Milk Freedom Act. Understanding the distinct federal and state rules is crucial for raw milk consumers and producers.