The introduction of the National Bioengineered Food Disclosure Standard (NBFDS) in the United States requires food manufacturers, importers, and retailers to disclose if a food product is bioengineered (BE) or contains BE ingredients. The government uses the term 'bioengineered' for a subset of genetically modified organisms (GMOs). This standard applies to most foods under FDA and, sometimes, USDA jurisdiction. However, meat, poultry, and egg products from animals fed BE feed are not required to be labeled.
Identifying Bioengineered Food Labels
Manufacturers have several options for disclosing BE ingredients on packaging:
- Text: Look for phrases like “Bioengineered food” or “Contains a bioengineered food ingredient”.
- Symbol: A green and white circular symbol with “BIOENGINEERED” may be used.
- Digital Link: A QR code that links to a page with BE information can be included, often with text like “Scan here for more food information”. This link should be free of marketing.
- Text Message: A phone number may be provided for texting a command word to get BE information.
- Website/Phone: Small manufacturers can use a website address or phone number.
Key Exemptions to the Rule
Not all foods derived from bioengineering require a BE label due to several exemptions:
- Highly Refined Ingredients: Ingredients processed to the point where modified DNA is undetectable, like some corn oils or sugar from sugar beets, do not need a mandatory disclosure. A voluntary 'Derived from Bioengineering' label might be used instead.
- Animal Products: As noted, meat, milk, or eggs from animals fed BE feed are exempt.
- Restaurants: Food served in restaurants and similar food-service establishments is not covered by the standard.
- Organic Foods: USDA certified organic foods are exempt because organic standards prohibit genetic engineering.
Voluntary Non-GMO Labeling
Some consumers may also look for the Non-GMO Project seal. This is a voluntary third-party verification indicating a product meets their standard for avoiding genetically modified ingredients. Their criteria can be more rigorous than the USDA's mandatory BE rules. The butterfly seal signifies this verification.
Comparing Labels: USDA Bioengineered vs. Non-GMO Project
Here’s a comparison of the key differences:
| Feature | USDA Bioengineered Disclosure | Non-GMO Project Verification |
|---|---|---|
| Standard | Mandatory federal regulation | Voluntary third-party verification |
| Detection | Required for detectable modified genetic material | Aims for a lower threshold for ingredients |
| Refined Ingredients | Exempt if modified DNA is not detectable | Verifies absence in all ingredients |
| Exemptions | Significant exemptions exist | Fewer exemptions |
| Symbol | Standardized circular symbol | Distinctive butterfly seal |
| Purpose | Inform about BE ingredient presence | Market products as non-GMO |
Tips for Shopping Smart
To identify or avoid BE foods:
- Look for the USDA BE text, symbol, QR code, or phone number on packaging.
- Choose USDA Certified Organic for a guarantee against bioengineered ingredients.
- Seek the Non-GMO Project seal for stricter non-GMO verification.
- Be mindful that highly processed foods and restaurant meals may not be labeled, even if derived from BE sources. Opt for organic in these cases if avoiding BE is a priority.
Conclusion
Understanding food labels is essential for identifying bioengineered foods. The USDA's mandatory BE disclosure provides key information, but it's important to be aware of the exemptions. For those wishing to avoid bioengineered ingredients entirely, the USDA Organic certification offers the most comprehensive assurance. The voluntary Non-GMO Project verification provides an additional layer of scrutiny. By using these tools and understanding the rules, consumers can make more informed decisions about the food they buy.
Visit the USDA Agricultural Marketing Service website for the official List of Bioengineered Foods