The Science of Lime: Fruit vs. Chemical
When people ask if adding lime to water makes it alkaline, they are often unaware that there are two very different substances referred to as "lime".
Fruit Lime (Citrus aurantiifolia)
The lime fruit contains citric acid, a weak organic acid. When you squeeze fresh lime juice into a glass of water, you are adding an acidic substance. A simple litmus test would immediately show a lower, more acidic pH. However, the misconception arises from how the body metabolizes citrus fruits. After digestion, the minerals left behind produce an alkaline byproduct. This process, known as potential renal acid load (PRAL), is what makes lime water 'alkalizing' inside the body, despite being acidic on the outside.
Hydrated Lime (Calcium Hydroxide)
In contrast, hydrated lime is calcium hydroxide, a strong base that has no relation to the citrus fruit. It is used in industrial processes and has a saturated solution pH of around 12.4, making it highly alkaline. This is not a food product and is not what people are referring to when they make 'lime water' for health reasons. Using the wrong type of lime could be extremely dangerous, emphasizing the need for clarity.
The Body's pH Regulation: A Highly Controlled System
Your body has a complex and efficient system to maintain a stable blood pH within a very narrow, slightly alkaline range (7.35 to 7.45). This tight regulation is essential for all physiological functions, and your body's lungs and kidneys work constantly to keep it balanced, regardless of your diet.
- The Lungs: The respiratory system adjusts blood pH by regulating the amount of carbon dioxide exhaled.
- The Kidneys: The renal system excretes excess acids or bases to maintain balance.
Claims that you can significantly and lastingly alter your body's blood pH with food are not supported by scientific evidence. Drinking alkaline water or consuming alkalizing foods primarily affects the pH of your urine, not your blood.
Comparison of DIY Alkaline Water Methods
| Method | How it Works | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lime/Lemon Juice | Metabolic byproduct is alkaline. | Adds flavor and Vitamin C; aids digestion. | Does not make water alkaline outside the body; acidic nature can erode tooth enamel. |
| Baking Soda | Sodium bicarbonate is a natural alkali. | Quick and easy; immediately raises water pH. | High sodium content; can cause stomach pain or diarrhea in large amounts. |
| pH Drops | Concentrated minerals and electrolytes are added. | Consistent and reliable pH increase; easy to use. | Can be expensive; quality and ingredients vary by brand. |
| Water Ionizer | Electrolysis separates water into alkaline and acidic streams. | Consistent alkaline water; often includes a filtration system. | High initial cost; requires maintenance; some devices lack FDA approval for health claims. |
| Natural Mineral Water | Water naturally picks up alkaline minerals from rocks. | Naturally contains minerals like calcium and magnesium. | pH can vary; can be expensive depending on the brand. |
The Real Benefits of Adding Citrus to Water
While the primary claim of altering your body's pH is unproven, adding lime or lemon to your water is still a healthy habit. The benefits stem from the nutrients in the fruit, not from changing your body's acid-base balance.
- Excellent Source of Vitamin C: Limes, like other citrus fruits, are packed with vitamin C, an antioxidant that supports the immune system and strengthens collagen.
- Improved Hydration: The pleasant flavor encourages you to drink more water, which is essential for flushing toxins and keeping your body energized.
- Enhanced Digestion: Citric acid stimulates the production of digestive enzymes, which can help your body break down food more effectively.
- Potential for Kidney Stone Prevention: The citric acid in lime water may help prevent the formation of certain kidney stones.
Conclusion
In summary, adding fresh lime juice to water does not make the water itself alkaline, as the citric acid immediately lowers its pH. The idea of it being 'alkalizing' refers to the alkaline-producing effect of the fruit's minerals after metabolism. However, your body's blood pH is rigidly controlled and cannot be significantly altered by diet. The actual health benefits of drinking lime water, such as increased hydration and vitamin C intake, are well-established and independent of any effect on the body's pH.
For those interested in exploring the scientific literature on the alkaline diet, the National Institutes of Health (NIH) provides valuable resources. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3195546/
The Alkaline Diet and Your Body
An important fact about the alkaline diet is that your body maintains a remarkably stable blood pH, regardless of what you eat, through complex systems involving your lungs and kidneys. The 'alkalizing' effects of certain foods are largely reflected in the pH of your urine, not your blood. While increasing your intake of fruits and vegetables is beneficial, it's for the vitamins and minerals, not for manipulating your internal pH.
How to Make Alkaline Water (If Desired)
For those still keen on consuming alkaline water, alternative methods exist that actually raise the water's pH before consumption:
- Add Baking Soda: Stir half a teaspoon of baking soda into a glass of water.
- Use pH Drops: Add a few drops of concentrated mineral solution to a glass of water.
- Invest in an Ionizer: Use a water ionizer to produce alkaline water via electrolysis.
- Use an Alkaline Filter Pitcher: A portable filter pitcher can infuse alkaline minerals.
Is Alkaline Water Better?
While alkaline water is generally considered safe, there is limited scientific research to support many of the health claims made by proponents, such as slowing aging or preventing chronic diseases. Some studies suggest potential benefits for certain conditions like acid reflux and bone resorption, but more extensive human research is needed. Ultimately, staying hydrated with plain water is most important for overall health.
A Final Word on Tooth Enamel
Regardless of its metabolic effect, lime juice is acidic before consumption. Regular and frequent consumption of lime water can lead to dental enamel erosion over time. To minimize this risk, dentists recommend drinking through a straw, rinsing your mouth with plain water afterward, and waiting at least 30 minutes before brushing your teeth.