Why You Should Turn Off Exercise Calories
Many fitness and nutrition experts advise against eating back calories burned during exercise, especially if your primary goal is weight loss. The reasons for this are rooted in potential inaccuracies and the risk of overestimating your calorie burn. First, wearable fitness devices and app-based estimations are notoriously inaccurate. The number they provide is an approximation, not an exact science. Second, automatically increasing your daily calorie target after a workout can subconsciously encourage you to consume more food, potentially offsetting the very deficit you worked to create. For these reasons, many users prefer a more predictable and consistent approach to their calorie budget.
Step-by-Step Instructions: MyFitnessPal Mobile App
- Navigate to the 'More' Menu: Open the MyFitnessPal app and tap the 'More' button located in the bottom-right corner of the screen.
- Access Settings: From the 'More' menu, scroll down and tap on 'Goals'.
- Find Exercise Calories: Scroll to the very bottom of the Goals page. You will see an option for 'Exercise Calories'.
- Toggle the Setting: Tap on the 'Exercise Calories' option. On the next screen, ensure the setting is turned off. It may appear as a toggle switch or a different selection, depending on your app version.
- Confirm the Change: Close out of the settings. The change is saved automatically and your diary will no longer add calories burned from logged exercise.
How to Disconnect Step Trackers to Prevent Automatic Adjustments
For users who have connected wearable devices like Fitbit or Apple Watch, MyFitnessPal may still automatically adjust your calories based on your step count. To fully disable all exercise-related adjustments, you need to disconnect the device.
- Open the 'More' Menu: Go to the 'More' section in the app.
- Find 'Apps & Devices': Scroll down and tap on 'Apps & Devices'.
- Manage Your Connections: Locate your connected device (e.g., Apple Health, Fitbit) in the list and tap on it.
- Disconnect the Device: Look for the 'Disconnect' button or option to unlink the service completely. You can also often manage permissions directly from your phone's settings under Privacy > Motion & Fitness.
MyFitnessPal Website: Disabling Exercise Calories
If you use the web version of MyFitnessPal, the process is slightly different:
- Log In and Go to 'My Home': After logging in, hover over the 'My Home' tab at the top of the page.
- Select 'Goals': Click on the 'Goals' option from the dropdown menu.
- Adjust Exercise Settings: Scroll down to the 'Exercise' section on the Goals page. You will find options related to how exercise is tracked and its impact on your calorie goal.
- Save Changes: Make sure to save any changes you make before navigating away.
Comparison Table: Enabled vs. Disabled Exercise Calories
| Feature | Exercise Calories ENABLED | Exercise Calories DISABLED |
|---|---|---|
| Calorie Goal | Your daily target fluctuates based on recorded exercise. | Your daily target remains fixed and consistent. |
| Tracking Method | You rely on app or device estimations for calories burned. | You rely on your baseline calorie goal, which is a more consistent metric. |
| Eating Habits | Encourages eating back calories, which can be inaccurate. | Reinforces sticking to a consistent calorie budget, regardless of activity. |
| Weight Management | Can lead to slower or inconsistent weight loss due to overestimation. | Promotes more predictable and consistent weight loss outcomes. |
| Best For | Casual users or those not focused on precise calorie deficits. | Users aiming for consistent, predictable weight loss or maintenance. |
Expert Recommendations and Conclusion
Ultimately, deciding whether to turn off exercise calories on MyFitnessPal comes down to your personal goals and approach. For those serious about achieving a specific weight target, disabling this feature is often the recommended path due to the potential for overestimation and the encouragement of a more disciplined calorie tracking method. The fixed calorie target provides a clearer picture of your progress and removes the guesswork associated with exercise-based calorie fluctuations. However, for casual users or those who are extremely active and need to ensure they consume enough fuel, keeping the feature on might be appropriate, provided they understand and account for its inaccuracies. For more reliable information on nutrition, consider visiting the Dietary Guidelines for Americans website.
By following the steps for both mobile and web versions, and by disconnecting any syncing devices, you can take full control of your MyFitnessPal experience. This simple adjustment can lead to a more accurate and ultimately more successful journey toward your health and wellness goals. Always listen to your body and make adjustments as needed, but for precision, less is often more when it comes to counting exercise calories.