Understanding the Landscape of Protein Claims
Making a "high in protein" claim on a food product's packaging is a powerful marketing tool, but it's not a decision to be made lightly. The rules governing nutrient content claims are strict and enforced by regional regulatory bodies like the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and the European Commission. Mislabeling can lead to legal issues and consumer distrust. The key to making a legitimate claim lies in understanding the precise calculation required by the specific market your product is sold in. While the core concept is straightforward—a certain amount of protein must be present—the method of measurement (per serving, per 100g, or based on energy value) differs significantly.
The U.S. FDA Method: Daily Value Percentage
In the United States, the criteria for a "high protein" claim is tied to the recommended Daily Value (DV). For adults and children over four years old, the DV for protein is 50 grams.
For a food to be labeled as "High in Protein," it must meet the following condition:
- Criteria: The food must contain 20% or more of the recommended Daily Value (DV) for protein per Reference Amount Customarily Consumed (RACC).
Calculation for a high protein claim (U.S.):
- $Grams\ of\ protein\ per\ serving\ \ge\ 0.20\ \times\ 50g$
- $Grams\ of\ protein\ per\ serving\ \ge\ 10g$
If a food product bears a %DV for protein on its nutrition panel, the protein quality must also be considered. This involves using the Protein Digestibility Corrected Amino Acid Score (PDCAAS), which assesses how well the human body can absorb and utilize the protein.
The EU and UK Approach: Energy Percentage
In contrast to the U.S. system, the European Union and the United Kingdom base their "high protein" claim on the food's energy value.
- Criteria: At least 20% of the energy (calorie) value of the food must be provided by protein.
To perform this calculation, you must know the energy values for protein (4 kcal/gram) and the total calories of your product per 100g. The formula is as follows:
- $Percentage\ of\ energy\ from\ protein\ =\ (Grams\ of\ protein\ per\ 100g\ \times\ 4)\ /\ Total\ kcal\ per\ 100g$
- The resulting value must be $\ge\ 0.20$
Comparison of Global Protein Claim Standards
To illustrate the different requirements, the following table provides a clear comparison of the standards for a high protein claim in key regions:
| Region | Calculation Basis | Threshold for "High Protein" Claim | Additional Considerations |
|---|---|---|---|
| United States | Grams per serving | $\ge$ 10g per serving (20% of 50g DV) | Protein quality (PDCAAS) must be considered if %DV is on the label. |
| European Union / UK | Percentage of energy | $\ge$ 20% of food's energy value is from protein | Based on a calculation per 100g or 100ml. |
| Canada | Protein Rating (PDCAAS) | "Excellent Source" requires $\ge$ 20% DV (10g) corrected protein per RACC | System uses Protein Rating and PDCAAS, similar to the US. |
| Australia / New Zealand | Grams per serving | "Good Source" is $\ge$ 10g protein per serving. | General claim is $\ge$ 5g/serving. Specific thresholds for liquids differ. |
Step-by-Step Guide for Calculation
Navigating these different requirements can be complex, but following a structured process simplifies the task. Here is a practical guide to calculating your product's protein claim eligibility for different markets:
- Gather Nutritional Data: Obtain the grams of protein, total grams, and total calories per serving and per 100g/100ml from your nutritional information. For U.S. labels, determine the Reference Amount Customarily Consumed (RACC) for your product category.
- Determine Target Market: Decide which region(s) you are labeling for. This is the most crucial step, as the calculation method will vary based on your target market.
- Perform the Calculation: Use the specific formula for your target market:
- For U.S. (Daily Value): Check if the protein content per serving is 10g or more. If you also wish to declare a %DV, you will need to determine the corrected protein using PDCAAS, although this is not required for just a quantitative protein claim.
- For EU/UK (Energy Basis): Calculate the percentage of total energy derived from protein. Ensure this figure is 20% or higher. For example, if a product has 200 kcal per 100g and 11g of protein per 100g, the calculation is $(11 \times 4)/200 = 44/200 = 22%$. Since 22% is over 20%, it qualifies as "high in protein."
- Confirm Quality Metrics (if necessary): If the protein claim in your target market (like the U.S. or Canada) requires consideration of protein quality, you will need laboratory analysis to determine the amino acid profile and digestibility, often resulting in a PDCAAS value.
- Review the Label: Ensure all parts of your packaging and labeling comply with the required terminology for that region. Some regions mandate additional statements if a nutrient claim is made.
The Importance of Protein Quality
While calculating the quantity of protein is a central part of the claim, some regulations also consider protein quality. The Protein Digestibility Corrected Amino Acid Score (PDCAAS) is a widely used method for this.
- What it is: PDCAAS measures how digestible a protein is and how its amino acid profile matches human needs. It is calculated by multiplying a protein's amino acid score by its true fecal protein digestibility.
- How it works: For example, many plant proteins have lower digestibility scores than animal proteins due to factors like fiber content. This can impact the corrected protein value used for labeling and for calculating a product's %DV in markets like the U.S. and Canada.
Food companies often need to perform laboratory analysis to substantiate claims based on protein quality. This scientific rigor ensures that the label provides accurate and verifiable information to the consumer.
Conclusion: Navigating Complex Regulations
Calculating a "high in protein" claim is not a one-size-fits-all process. The legal definition and required calculation are specific to each region, so a product labeled for the U.S. will use a different standard than one for the EU. For manufacturers, it is essential to identify the target market and consult the relevant regulations to ensure compliance and avoid mislabeling. For consumers, understanding the basis of these claims helps in making more informed dietary choices. By following the correct steps and paying attention to both protein quantity and quality, manufacturers can confidently make accurate and honest protein claims on their products.