Skip to content

Is 10-19% Daily Value an Excellent or High Source? The Truth About Food Labels

5 min read

Less than 20% of Americans correctly understand how to use the Nutrition Facts label to make informed dietary choices. This widespread confusion often extends to interpreting the percent Daily Value (%DV), particularly when distinguishing between a 'good' source and an 'excellent' or 'high' source of a nutrient.

Quick Summary

A 10-19% daily value for a nutrient signifies a "good source" of that nutrient, not an excellent or high source. High or excellent sources contain 20% or more of the nutrient's daily value per serving, according to FDA guidelines.

Key Points

  • False Statement: The premise that a 10-19% DV is an excellent or high source of a nutrient is false; it is officially considered a 'good source'.

  • Excellent/High Source Threshold: A food must contain 20% or more of the Daily Value for a nutrient to be considered a high or excellent source.

  • Low Source Threshold: A food with 5% or less of the Daily Value is considered a low source of a nutrient.

  • Serving Size Matters: The %DV is calculated per serving, so you must factor in how many servings you consume.

  • Use %DV as a Guide: Look for foods with a high %DV for beneficial nutrients like fiber and a low %DV for nutrients to limit, such as sodium and saturated fat.

  • FDA Regulation: The FDA regulates all nutrient content claims, ensuring that terms like 'good source' and 'high in' correspond to specific %DV ranges.

In This Article

Deciphering the %Daily Value on Nutrition Labels

The percent Daily Value (%DV) is a crucial tool on the Nutrition Facts label, designed to help consumers understand how a single serving of food contributes to their total daily dietary needs. It's based on a standard 2,000-calorie daily diet, though individual needs may vary. The %DV provides a simple, at-a-glance way to assess the nutrient content of a food without needing to calculate percentages yourself. However, the specific terminology used by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) to describe nutrient levels can be a point of confusion. For example, the difference between a "good source" and an "excellent source" is based on distinct percentage ranges, and misunderstanding these can lead to incorrect assumptions about a food's nutritional value.

The Definitive Answer: Good vs. Excellent Sources

The statement that a 10-19% DV indicates a food is an excellent or high source is false. Based on FDA guidelines, a food's nutrient content is categorized into specific ranges:

  • Low Source: A food with 5% DV or less per serving is considered a low source of that nutrient. This is a number to look for when trying to limit nutrients like saturated fat, sodium, and added sugars.
  • Good Source: A food with a %DV ranging from 10% to 19% per serving is considered a "good source" of that nutrient. This means it provides a meaningful amount, but is not the highest level available. Look for this range on foods you want to increase, like fiber or potassium.
  • High/Excellent Source: To be considered a "high," "rich in," or "excellent source" of a nutrient, a food must contain 20% or more of the DV per serving. This is the threshold for maximizing your intake of specific beneficial vitamins and minerals.

Comparing Nutrient Descriptors

Nutrient Descriptor % Daily Value (DV) Range Significance
Low Source 5% or less Provides a small amount of the nutrient per serving.
Good Source 10% to 19% Provides a meaningful amount of the nutrient per serving.
High / Excellent Source 20% or more Provides a significant amount of the nutrient per serving.
Reduced At least 25% less than the original Contains a lower amount of the nutrient compared to a standard version.
Free Less than 0.5g per serving Contains a negligible amount of the nutrient (e.g., fat-free, sugar-free).

Using the %DV to Make Smarter Choices

Understanding the distinct %DV categories empowers you to make more informed food choices that align with your health goals. For example, if you are looking to increase your fiber intake, you should actively seek out foods with a %DV of 10% or more for dietary fiber. Conversely, if you are trying to reduce your sodium consumption, you should choose products that have a %DV of 5% or less for sodium. The key is to think of the %DV as a guide to balance your diet throughout the day.

How to effectively use the Nutrition Facts label:

  • Always check the serving size first: All %DV values are based on a single serving. Many packages contain multiple servings, so adjust your calculations accordingly.
  • Look for lower %DV for "bad" nutrients: Limit your intake of foods that are high in saturated fat, sodium, and added sugars.
  • Look for higher %DV for "good" nutrients: Aim for more foods rich in dietary fiber, vitamins (like Vitamin D), and minerals (like calcium, iron, and potassium).
  • Compare products easily: Use the %DV to compare different brands or similar products to see which one is the healthier option for your needs.

The Importance of Label Lingo

Beyond the %DV numbers, many food packages also feature nutrient content claims like "good source of" or "high in." These claims are regulated by the FDA and directly correspond to the %DV ranges. A food can't simply say it's a "high source" of iron unless its %DV for iron is 20% or more. Being aware of these official definitions prevents you from being misled by marketing language and allows you to look past the front of the package to the facts panel. The updated Nutrition Facts label, which started appearing in 2020, also features an "Added Sugars" line, making it even easier to track and limit these specific types of sugar. For a more detailed guide, you can refer to the official FDA instructions on how to interpret the label.

Conclusion

In summary, the statement that a 10-19% DV of a nutrient makes a food an excellent or high source is incorrect. That range designates a food as a "good source," while a true excellent or high source must meet or exceed 20% DV per serving, according to official FDA regulations. By using the simple 5%/20% rule—low if 5% or less, high if 20% or more—you can quickly and confidently evaluate a food's nutrient profile. Armed with this knowledge, you can navigate the grocery store aisles with a clearer understanding of what you are putting into your body, ultimately leading to better health outcomes.

Understanding the Nutrition Facts Label

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Is a food with 10% Daily Value considered high in a nutrient? A: No, a food with a 10% Daily Value is considered a "good source" of that nutrient, not a high source.

Q: What %DV is required for a food to be an excellent source? A: A food must contain 20% or more of the Daily Value per serving to be labeled an excellent or high source of a nutrient.

Q: What is the 5/20 rule for interpreting food labels? A: The 5/20 rule is a quick guide: 5% DV or less is considered low in a nutrient, while 20% DV or more is considered high.

Q: How does the Daily Value percentage help me compare different foods? A: The %DV allows you to compare the nutrient content of different products on a standardized scale. Just make sure you are comparing similar serving sizes.

Q: Are all nutrient claims, like "low-fat" or "high-fiber," standardized? A: Yes, nutrient content claims like "low-fat," "good source," and "high in" are regulated by the FDA and have specific, standardized criteria that must be met.

Q: Why is it important to check the serving size on the label? A: The %DV is calculated for a single serving. If you eat more than one serving, you will consume more calories and nutrients, and the %DV will be higher.

Q: Can I use the %DV if my diet is not 2,000 calories a day? A: Yes, the %DV is still a useful reference point even if your calorie needs are different. You can use it as a general target to aim for.

Frequently Asked Questions

A 'good source' provides 10-19% of the Daily Value per serving, while an 'excellent source' or 'high source' provides 20% or more.

No, a 15% Daily Value indicates that the food is a 'good source' of that nutrient. The threshold for a 'high' source is 20% or more.

You should look for foods that have a 20% or higher %DV for that vitamin, as these are considered excellent or high sources.

Yes, according to FDA guidelines, any food with 5% DV or less of a nutrient per serving is considered low.

A %DV of 25% for calcium means that one serving of the food is an excellent or high source of calcium and provides a significant contribution to your daily needs.

The 2,000-calorie diet is used as a standard for general nutrition advice to make food labels consistent and comparable, though individual calorie needs may differ.

By paying attention to the %DV for different nutrients, you can make dietary trade-offs. For example, if you eat a high-sodium food for one meal, you can balance it by choosing low-sodium foods for the rest of the day.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.