Skip to content

Is a Jersey Mike's Sandwich Unhealthy? A Deep Dive into Nutritional Facts

4 min read

With some regular-sized sandwiches containing over 1,000 mg of sodium, Jersey Mike's subs can be a high-sodium meal depending on your order. It is important to look at the whole nutritional picture to determine if a Jersey Mike's sandwich is unhealthy for your specific dietary needs.

Quick Summary

An analysis of Jersey Mike's nutrition reveals that while some subs are high in calories and sodium, others offer leaner protein and lower calorie counts. Customizing your sandwich or opting for a 'sub in a tub' are effective strategies to make a healthier choice.

Key Points

  • High Sodium Warning: Many regular-sized Jersey Mike's subs exceed daily sodium recommendations, particularly hot and Italian varieties.

  • Smart Customization: Modifying orders by choosing leaner meats, skipping or reducing oil, and adding extra vegetables can significantly improve the nutritional value.

  • Lean Protein Options: Leaner protein choices like turkey and roast beef are better for reducing saturated fat and calorie content compared to processed Italian meats.

  • Sub in a Tub: Ordering a "sub in a tub" is a low-carb, lower-calorie option that replaces the bread with a bed of lettuce.

  • Portion Control Matters: Opting for a mini or regular sub instead of a giant is an easy way to manage calorie intake.

  • Be Aware of Serving Sizes: The nutritional info on Jersey Mike's website is based on a half-regular sub, so be mindful of your actual portion.

In This Article

Analyzing the Nutritional Landscape of Jersey Mike's

For many, a sandwich from Jersey Mike's is a satisfying and convenient meal. However, the nutritional profile of these popular subs can vary dramatically depending on your order. While Jersey Mike's prides itself on fresh ingredients, the high levels of sodium, calories, and saturated fat in certain menu items are worth examining. This guide breaks down the nutritional content, highlighting which options to be cautious of and how to make smarter choices.

The Unhealthy Culprits: High-Sodium, High-Calorie Options

Some of the most popular and flavorful subs on the Jersey Mike's menu are also the most nutritionally dense. Hot subs, especially those with cheese, tend to be the biggest offenders. For example, a regular-sized Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak can pack over 3,500 mg of sodium and nearly 1,000 calories when loaded with dressings. For reference, the American Heart Association recommends no more than 2,300 mg of sodium per day, with an ideal limit of 1,500 mg for most adults. This means a single sandwich could contain more than a day's worth of sodium. Similarly, Italian subs, often made with processed meats like salami and pepperoni, contribute significantly to total fat and saturated fat intake.

It's also important to note how nutritional information is sometimes presented. Jersey Mike's nutritional guide considers half of a regular sub to be a single serving, which doesn't reflect how most people actually eat the sandwich. This can make calorie and sodium counts appear lower than they are for a full meal.

Customization is Your Best Tool for Healthy Eating

Fortunately, Jersey Mike's offers plenty of customization options that empower you to take control of your meal's nutritional content. By being mindful of your choices, you can create a delicious and satisfying sub that aligns with your dietary goals. Here are some simple adjustments to make your meal healthier:

  • Choose Leaner Proteins: Opt for less processed meats like turkey, ham, or roast beef instead of Italian meats or fatty steak options.
  • Modify 'Mike's Way': The standard "Mike's Way" includes an olive oil blend and red wine vinegar. While the olive oil contains heart-healthy fats, you can ask for it to be used sparingly or omitted to reduce calories. The extra salt can also be skipped.
  • Go for the 'Sub in a Tub': If you want to significantly reduce carbs and calories, you can order any sub as a salad bowl, or "sub in a tub." This option replaces the bread with a bed of lettuce. The Mini Turkey and Provolone Sub in a tub, for instance, offers a great balance of protein and lower carbs.
  • Add Extra Vegetables: Loading up on extra lettuce, tomatoes, and onions adds fiber and volume without many calories, helping you feel full and satisfied.

Comparison Table: Unhealthy vs. Healthy Choices

To illustrate the impact of your choices, consider this comparison between two Jersey Mike's options based on regular-sized portions:

Feature Unhealthy Choice (Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak) Healthy Choice (Turkey and Provolone Sub in a Tub)
Calories ~930 kcal ~509 kcal
Total Fat ~48 g ~38 g
Saturated Fat ~15 g Not specified, but significantly lower
Sodium ~3,635 mg ~1,283 mg
Carbohydrates ~76 g ~8 g
Protein ~48 g ~35 g
Key Difference High fat, very high sodium, high carbs Significantly lower sodium and carbs

Beyond the Sandwich: Healthier Sides and Portion Control

It's not just the sub itself that matters. The accompanying sides and portion sizes play a crucial role in overall nutrition. Choosing the mini or regular size over the giant sub is an easy way to control calories. For sides, opt for baked chips like Sun Chips instead of traditional potato or chili cheese options, which are higher in fat and sodium. And remember, drinking water instead of sugary sodas is always a healthier choice.

The Final Verdict

Is a Jersey Mike's sandwich unhealthy? The answer is: it depends entirely on your specific order. For those seeking a delicious meal, it's possible to enjoy Jersey Mike's without derailing your diet. By choosing lean proteins, controlling portions, and leveraging customization, you can turn a potentially high-calorie, high-sodium indulgence into a reasonably balanced meal. With mindful ordering, you can still enjoy the fresh-sliced taste that makes Jersey Mike's so popular. For more tips on making healthier choices at popular sandwich shops, you can consult expert-recommended guides online.

Conclusion

Ultimately, a Jersey Mike's sandwich is not inherently healthy or unhealthy. Its nutritional impact is determined by the choices you make when ordering. While some hot subs and Italian varieties are high in calories, fat, and sodium, options like leaner turkey and roast beef on wheat bread, or even a 'Sub in a Tub,' offer a much healthier alternative. Smart customizations and awareness of portion sizes allow you to enjoy a flavorful meal that aligns with your dietary needs, making it a viable option for a balanced diet in moderation.

Visit Eat This Not That for more recommendations on healthier fast-food choices.

Note: All nutritional information should be confirmed on the official Jersey Mike's website for the most up-to-date data, as menu items and ingredients can change.

Frequently Asked Questions

The healthiest cold sub options include the Turkey Breast & Provolone, Ham & Provolone, or Roast Beef & Provolone. For a hot sub, the Mike's Chicken Philly or Portabella Chicken Cheese Steak can be healthier choices if ordered without high-sodium cheese or dressing modifications.

To reduce sodium, choose leaner meats like turkey over Italian varieties, ask for no extra salt in the seasoning, and limit or omit high-sodium additions like American cheese.

A 'Sub in a Tub' is any sandwich ordered as a salad, with all the standard fillings—meat, cheese, and vegetables—served in a bowl without the bread.

In general, yes. Many hot subs, particularly those with added cheese and sauces like the Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak, tend to be significantly higher in calories, fat, and sodium than cold sub alternatives.

Mike's Way includes an olive oil blend, red wine vinegar, oregano, and salt. While the oil and vinegar add flavor and some healthy fats, the added salt can increase sodium content. You can request less oil or salt to customize your sub.

Yes, but with care. To stay on track, opt for a mini or regular sub instead of a giant, choose lean proteins like turkey, and consider a 'Sub in a Tub' to reduce carbs and calories.

Instead of traditional potato chips, healthier side options include baked chips like Sun Chips or a baked chip variety, which are lower in saturated fat.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.