The Nuance of 'No Nitrates or Nitrites Added'
For many health-conscious shoppers, the label "no nitrates or nitrites added" seems like a clear sign of a nitrate-free product. However, this phrase does not mean the product is entirely devoid of these compounds. Under USDA regulations, manufacturers must use this specific phrasing if they preserve meat with naturally occurring sources of nitrates, rather than synthetic sodium nitrite or potassium nitrate. This labeling requirement often leads to consumer confusion, as the end result is still a product containing nitrates.
So, while a Boar's Head "All Natural" turkey breast carries this label, a footnote on the ingredient list clarifies the presence of "nitrates or nitrites... naturally occurring in cultured celery powder and sea salt". This is a common practice across the meat industry, where vegetable-based alternatives are used to meet consumer demand for 'cleaner' labels without sacrificing the preservation benefits of nitrates.
The Role of Cultured Celery Powder
Cultured celery powder has become a popular natural curing agent for manufacturers who wish to avoid synthetic preservatives. Celery is naturally high in nitrates. Fermenting celery juice with a starter culture converts its nitrates into nitrites. These naturally derived nitrites function like synthetic ones, inhibiting bacteria, extending shelf life, and creating the characteristic color and flavor of cured meats.
How Natural and Synthetic Nitrates Differ in Your Body
Chemically, nitrites from cultured celery powder are identical to synthetic nitrites once consumed. The body processes them the same way. When nitrites in meat are heated, they can form nitrosamines, which the WHO classifies as probable carcinogens. While some studies suggest antioxidants like vitamin C can inhibit nitrosamine formation, the amount in processed meats cured with celery powder may be insufficient, especially with high-temperature cooking. Many experts recommend caution with all processed meats, regardless of nitrate source.
Products and Processing: Boar's Head Turkey
Boar's Head offers various turkey products with different preservation methods. Understanding the labeling is key:
- Oven Roasted Turkey Breast: Typically uses traditional curing methods without a "no nitrates added" label.
- *All Natural Oven Roasted Turkey Breast**: Features a "No added nitrites or nitrates‡" label, with a footnote explaining the presence of naturally occurring nitrates from sea salt and/or cultured celery powder.
- Organic Oven Roasted Turkey Breast: A USDA Certified Organic product with the same "no added nitrates or nitrites" label and footnote as the All Natural variety.
- Golden Roasted Turkey Breast: Marketed as "preservative free," checking the ingredient list for natural nitrate sources is essential.
- Uncured Turkey Bacon: Labeled as uncured, indicating the use of natural nitrate sources for preservation.
Cured vs. Uncured Turkey: A Comparison
| Feature | Traditionally Cured Turkey | Boar's Head 'Uncured' Turkey | Truly Unprocessed Turkey (Cooked at Home) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Preservation Method | Uses synthetic additives like sodium nitrite or potassium nitrate. | Uses natural sources like cultured celery powder or sea salt. | None; relies on cooking and proper refrigeration for safety. |
| Nitrate Source | Synthetic chemical additives. | Nitrates naturally occurring in vegetable sources and salt. | Trace amounts from vegetables in diet; none added directly to the meat. |
| Shelf Life | Extended, due to synthetic preservatives. | Shorter than traditionally cured, but longer than fresh meat. | Very short; must be consumed within a few days. |
| Flavor | Distinctive salty, savory "cured" flavor profile. | Similar to traditionally cured due to the action of natural nitrites. | Natural, roasted turkey flavor; varies based on seasoning. |
| Labeling | May be labeled simply as "cured" or list chemical nitrates explicitly. | Labeled "Uncured" or "No nitrates added, except for those naturally occurring...". | "Fresh" or "all natural" with no curing agents listed. |
Finding Truly Nitrate-Free Turkey
To completely avoid nitrates, choose fresh, unprocessed turkey and cook it yourself. For deli meat, look for products explicitly labeled preservative-free and meticulously check ingredients for celery powder or other vegetable-derived nitrates. Some brands utilize methods like high-pressure processing (HPP) without curing agents.
Conclusion
It's a common misunderstanding that all Boar's Head turkey is nitrate-free. Products labeled "no nitrates or nitrites added" use natural sources like cultured celery powder and sea salt, which contain naturally occurring nitrates, instead of synthetic ones. Therefore, these products are not truly nitrate-free. Consumers aiming to avoid nitrates entirely should opt for fresh, unprocessed turkey or carefully examine labels for alternatives without any added nitrates, natural or synthetic.
Optional Resources
To learn more about the health effects of nitrates and nitrites, you can read more on the CDC Archive on Nitrate/Nitrite Toxicity.