Is cream cheese natural or processed?

According to the EPA, cream cheese is considered a type of unripened, natural cheese. However, the level of processing varies significantly between homemade versions and commercial products, which is why many still question: is cream cheese natural or processed?.

Quick Summary

Cream cheese is a fresh, soft cheese with a varying degree of processing depending on its production method. While the base is simple dairy, many commercial versions are moderately processed with stabilizers and preservatives, unlike homemade options.

Key Points

• Categorization: Cream cheese is typically considered a processed food, but the extent of processing depends on whether it's homemade or commercially produced.

• Homemade vs. Commercial: Homemade cream cheese is minimally processed, while commercial versions are moderately processed due to the addition of stabilizers and preservatives.

• Commercial Additives: Common additives in commercial cream cheese include stabilizers like carob bean gum and xanthan gum, as well as preservatives like sorbic acid.

• Not Ultra-Processed: Commercial cream cheese is not in the same category as highly or 'ultra-processed' foods, which contain more extracted ingredients and artificial additives.

• Choose Minimally Processed: To consume cream cheese in a more 'natural' state, seek out versions with minimal ingredients or consider making it yourself at home.

The Meaning of 'Processed'

To understand if cream cheese is natural or processed, it's crucial to define what 'processed' means. The term is broad, encompassing any food that has been altered from its original state. The level of processing is what matters most. The Nova food classification system, for instance, categorizes foods based on the degree to which they are processed.

• Minimally Processed: Foods that have undergone slight alterations like washing, cutting, or pasteurization without added ingredients.
• Processed Ingredients: Substances like oil or salt derived from nature but modified for use in cooking.
• Processed Foods: Products made by adding processed ingredients to minimally processed foods, such as cheese or fresh bread.
• Ultra-Processed Foods: Formulations made mostly from ingredients extracted from foods, with additives for flavor, color, and shelf life.

Cream cheese falls into a gray area within this spectrum. While it's not an ultra-processed product like frozen pizza, commercial versions are more processed than a simple, homemade alternative due to added ingredients and extensive manufacturing steps.

Homemade vs. Commercial Cream Cheese

The key to understanding cream cheese's processing level lies in the difference between artisanal, homemade versions and industrially manufactured ones. Both start with simple ingredients, but the production process diverges significantly.

The Artisanal Method

Making cream cheese at home is a straightforward process requiring only a few ingredients and minimal processing.

1. A blend of heavy cream and whole milk is heated.
2. An acid, such as lemon juice or vinegar, is added to curdle the milk.
3. The curdled mixture is strained through cheesecloth to separate the solids (curds) from the liquid (whey).
4. The remaining curds are whipped and salted to achieve the familiar creamy texture and flavor.

This method is minimally processed, essentially involving coagulation and straining, much like other fresh cheeses such as cottage cheese.

The Industrial Method

Commercial production is a more complex, controlled process designed for consistency, safety, and a long shelf life.

1. Milk and Cream Standardization: The fat content of milk is adjusted to meet specific standards.
2. Pasteurization: The mixture is heated to kill harmful bacteria, extending shelf life.
3. Fermentation: Lactic acid bacteria cultures are added, which ferment the dairy, lowering the pH and causing the milk proteins to coagulate.
4. Heating and Homogenization: The curd is heated and agitated to create a smooth, consistent texture.
5. Stabilizers and Preservatives: Crucially, stabilizers like carob bean gum, guar gum, and xanthan gum are added to prevent the product from separating and to improve mouthfeel. Preservatives, such as sorbic acid, are included to inhibit mold growth.
6. Packaging: The finished product is packaged, often via hot or cold filling methods, which also affects shelf life.

While the core steps resemble the natural cheesemaking process, the addition of multiple additives and extensive heating/homogenization pushes commercial cream cheese further along the processed food scale.

Comparison: Homemade vs. Commercial Cream Cheese

Feature	Homemade/Artisanal Cream Cheese	Commercial Cream Cheese
Ingredients	Whole milk, cream, and an acid (lemon juice, vinegar) or starter culture.	Pasteurized milk and cream, whey protein concentrate, salt, stabilizers (gums), and preservatives.
Processing Level	Minimally processed. Ingredients are simply combined, cultured, and strained.	Moderately processed. Includes pasteurization, homogenization, and multiple additives for texture and shelf life.
Texture	Lighter and often tangier, can vary slightly in consistency based on straining time.	Consistently smooth, dense, and creamy due to homogenization and stabilizers.
Shelf Life	Very short, typically 1-2 weeks when refrigerated.	Extended, lasting for several weeks or months due to preservatives.
Flavor	A fresher, more pronounced dairy and tangy flavor.	Generally milder and more consistent, sometimes with a slightly processed aftertaste.

The Role of Additives in Commercial Cream Cheese

Commercial cream cheese contains several ingredients that are not part of a traditional recipe but serve important functions in a mass-market product.

Common Additives

• Stabilizers (e.g., Carob Bean Gum, Xanthan Gum, Guar Gum): These are added to maintain the cream cheese's texture and prevent it from separating during its shelf life.
• Preservatives (e.g., Sorbic Acid): Used to prevent mold growth and extend the product's longevity.
• Whey Protein Concentrate: This can be added to commercial versions to achieve a higher protein and lower fat content, often indicated as 'modified milk ingredients'.
• Salt: Included for flavor and preservation.

These additions are the primary reason commercial cream cheese is classified as a processed food, moving it beyond the simple state of fresh curds.

Conclusion

So, is cream cheese natural or processed? The answer is nuanced and depends on how it's made. Homemade or artisanal cream cheese, created from just milk, cream, and a starter culture, is minimally processed. However, the vast majority of cream cheese sold commercially is moderately processed due to the addition of stabilizers and preservatives to ensure a consistent texture and long shelf life. This does not mean it is unhealthy, but it does mean it is not in its most natural, unaltered state. For those seeking the least processed version, making it at home or finding a brand with minimal ingredients is the best option.

For more information on processed foods, you can review guides from sources like the NHS.(https://www.nhs.uk/live-well/eat-well/how-to-eat-a-balanced-diet/what-are-processed-foods/)

---

Disclaimer: Nutritional information varies by product. Consult a healthcare professional for personalized dietary advice.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Philadelphia cream cheese processed?

Yes, Philadelphia cream cheese is a processed food. While it starts with milk and cream, its ingredient list includes stabilizers like carob bean gum and guar gum, and preservatives like sorbic acid, which categorize it as processed.

What is the difference between fresh cheese and processed cheese?

Fresh cheese, like ricotta or homemade cream cheese, is meant to be consumed soon after production with minimal alteration. Processed cheese, like American cheese slices, is made by blending natural cheeses with emulsifying salts and other ingredients to create a shelf-stable, consistent product.

Are all cream cheeses processed the same?

No, the level of processing varies. Homemade cream cheese is minimally processed, while commercial brands are moderately processed with additives. The specific manufacturing techniques and additives can also differ between brands.

Does processed cream cheese have any benefits?

Processed cream cheese offers convenience, a longer shelf life, and a reliably consistent texture. For some, it may also provide a slightly lower lactose content compared to other dairy products.

Can you make cream cheese at home to avoid processing?

Yes, making cream cheese at home using just milk, cream, and an acid like lemon juice is a way to create a minimally processed alternative. This method gives you complete control over the ingredients.

Why do commercial cream cheeses need additives?

Additives like stabilizers and preservatives are used in commercial cream cheese to ensure a uniform texture, prevent separation, and extend its shelf life. These are necessary for mass production and distribution.

Is cream cheese healthier than other processed foods?

Cream cheese is not heavily processed like some ultra-processed foods, but its healthiness depends on context. It's high in fat and calories, so moderation is key. Healthier alternatives like cottage cheese or Neufchâtel may offer better nutritional profiles.