Skip to content

Is it okay to eat green Yukon gold potatoes?

4 min read

According to the National Capital Poison Center, green potatoes are not safe to eat if the greening is widespread or if they taste bitter, as this can indicate a high level of the natural toxin solanine. This raises a critical question for home cooks: is it okay to eat green Yukon gold potatoes, or should they be immediately discarded?

Quick Summary

When potatoes turn green from light exposure, they produce chlorophyll and, more importantly, the toxic compound solanine. While small green patches can be carefully removed by peeling, extensively green or bitter-tasting potatoes should be discarded to avoid potential health risks. Proper storage prevents this issue entirely.

Key Points

  • Green Color is a Warning Sign: The green hue on a Yukon Gold potato is caused by harmless chlorophyll, but it signals the potential presence of the toxic compound solanine.

  • Solanine is Concentrated Near the Skin: Most of the toxin is found in and just under the skin of the potato, making thorough peeling an effective method for removing it.

  • Taste is a Critical Indicator: If a cooked potato tastes bitter or causes a burning sensation, it is a sign of high solanine levels and should not be eaten.

  • Extensive Greening Means Discard: If a Yukon Gold potato is heavily green or green throughout, the risk is higher, and it is best to throw it away entirely.

  • Store Potatoes Correctly to Prevent Greening: Keeping potatoes in a cool, dark place away from light is the most effective way to prevent them from turning green.

  • Cooking Does Not Destroy Solanine: The toxin is heat-stable, so boiling, baking, or frying a potato will not make it safe if it has a high solanine content.

In This Article

Potatoes, including the popular and buttery Yukon Gold variety, are a kitchen staple. However, discovering a green tinge on a few spuds can cause concern. The green color is a visual cue that a natural process has occurred, but it’s the invisible partner to this process that poses a potential health risk: the production of a toxin called solanine.

The Science Behind Green Potatoes

The greening of a potato is a response to light exposure. Just like any other plant, potatoes contain chlorophyll. When the potato, which is normally shielded from light while growing underground, is exposed to it during storage, it begins to produce chlorophyll, causing the green color. This process is not inherently harmful. However, the same light exposure that triggers chlorophyll production also triggers the production of glycoalkaloids, primarily solanine.

The Role of Solanine

Solanine is a natural plant toxin that acts as a defense mechanism against insects and fungi. In high concentrations, solanine can be poisonous to humans, causing gastrointestinal distress, headaches, and other symptoms. The concentration of solanine is highest in the peel and the area directly beneath it, as well as in the potato's sprouts. While the green color of chlorophyll is a helpful warning sign, it's not a perfect indicator of solanine levels. A potato could have high levels of solanine without being visibly green, which is why a bitter taste test is crucial.

How to Assess and Handle Green Yukon Gold Potatoes

When you find a green Yukon Gold potato, your course of action depends on the extent of the discoloration. Ignoring the greening is never recommended, as it signals a potential increase in solanine. Here’s a breakdown of how to handle different scenarios.

Scenarios for Green Potatoes

  • Slight Green Tinges: If only small, superficial green spots are visible, you can often salvage the potato. The key is to peel the potato thoroughly, cutting away all green areas and removing any sprouts. Solanine is concentrated near the surface, so aggressive peeling can remove the majority of the toxin.
  • Extensive Greening: If a large portion of the potato is green, it is best to discard it entirely. The higher concentration of chlorophyll suggests a correspondingly high concentration of solanine, and attempting to salvage it by peeling may not be sufficient to remove all the toxin.
  • Bitter Taste: Always taste a small piece of the cooked potato after preparation. If it has a bitter or off-putting taste, or if it causes a burning sensation in your mouth or throat, throw it out immediately. The bitterness is a strong indicator of high solanine content.

A Comparison of Green Potato Solutions

Handling Method Safety Level Efficacy Notes
Thoroughly peeling Safe for slight greening High Removes most of the solanine, which is concentrated near the surface. Also remove sprouts.
Cooking with skin on Not recommended Low Solanine is heat-stable and will not be destroyed by cooking, like boiling, frying, or baking.
Discarding Highest safety Complete Eliminates all risk, especially for heavily green or bitter potatoes.
Refrigerating Poor storage Low Refrigeration can negatively affect potato starch and cause a sweet flavor. A cool, dark place is better for preventing greening.

Preventative Measures for Storing Yukon Gold Potatoes

The best way to deal with green potatoes is to prevent them from becoming green in the first place. Proper storage is the most effective defense against solanine production. Follow these simple guidelines to keep your Yukon Gold potatoes fresh and safe for consumption.

  • Store potatoes in a cool, dark, and dry place. A pantry, cellar, or cupboard is ideal. Avoid direct sunlight or other light sources.
  • Maintain good air circulation. Store potatoes in a paper bag, mesh bag, or open container, rather than a sealed plastic bag, to prevent moisture buildup.
  • Keep potatoes away from onions. Storing these two together can accelerate sprouting in potatoes.
  • Check your potatoes periodically for any signs of greening, sprouting, or softness and use the oldest ones first. This 'first-in, first-out' (FIFO) method helps ensure freshness.

Conclusion

While finding a green Yukon Gold potato can be concerning, it does not always mean a trip to the trash. For minor green spots, thorough peeling and trimming are sufficient to remove the concentrated solanine and make the potato safe to eat. However, if the greening is extensive or the potato tastes bitter, it is a clear sign that solanine levels are too high, and the potato should be discarded. The safest approach is always prevention through proper storage in a cool, dark place. By following these simple kitchen safety measures, you can continue to enjoy your Yukon Gold potatoes without worry.

For more information on food safety, you can consult resources like the FDA's website for food safety guidance.

Handling Guidelines

  • Inspect and Assess: Examine potatoes for any green spots, sprouts, or soft areas before cooking to determine the level of solanine risk.
  • Peel Extensively: For slight greening, use a peeler to remove the entire skin and a deeper layer of flesh to eliminate all green-colored parts.
  • Trim Away Sprouts: Remove any visible sprouts, or 'eyes,' with a paring knife, as they contain high concentrations of solanine.
  • Test for Bitterness: Before adding to a meal, taste a small, cooked piece of the potato. A bitter flavor indicates high solanine and requires disposal.
  • Properly Store: Keep potatoes in a cool, dark pantry or cellar with good ventilation to prevent them from turning green in the first place.
  • Discard When in Doubt: If the greening is widespread or you are unsure about its safety, it is always safest to discard the potato to prevent any potential illness.
  • Avoid Risk Groups: Individuals in high-risk categories, such as small children, the elderly, or those with compromised immune systems, should avoid any green potatoes, even lightly-tinged ones.

Frequently Asked Questions

Yukon Gold potatoes turn green when they are exposed to light during storage. This triggers the production of chlorophyll, the harmless green pigment, and also signals the potato to produce the toxic alkaloid solanine.

Yes, if the greening is minor and superficial, you can cut away all the green parts and sprouts, and the rest of the potato is likely safe to eat. However, if the greening is extensive, it's safer to discard the entire potato.

The primary risk is solanine, which is toxic in large amounts. However, the conditions that cause greening can also lead to sprouting, and sprouts also contain high concentrations of solanine.

Solanine poisoning can cause gastrointestinal issues like nausea, vomiting, and abdominal pain. In more severe, though rare, cases, it can cause headaches, fever, and neurological problems.

No, cooking methods like boiling, baking, or frying will not destroy solanine, as it is heat-stable. Peeling and trimming are the only effective ways to remove the toxin.

No, you should not store potatoes in the refrigerator. The cold temperatures can cause the starches to convert to sugar, negatively affecting the taste and texture. Instead, store them in a cool, dark place.

Not necessarily. The green color itself is harmless chlorophyll. It is the potential presence of increased solanine that is the concern. The bitterness of a cooked potato is a more reliable sign of high solanine levels.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.