Skip to content

Is manuka honey really that good? An evidence-based analysis

4 min read

Produced in New Zealand and Australia, genuine manuka honey contains significantly higher concentrations of methylglyoxal (MGO), a potent antibacterial compound, than regular honey. But beyond the buzz and premium price tag, is manuka honey really that good, and what does the science truly say about its benefits?

Quick Summary

Manuka honey is renowned for its high methylglyoxal content, which delivers potent antibacterial and anti-inflammatory effects for specific uses like wound and oral care. Its limited production and certified potency contribute to a high cost, requiring a critical look at whether the expense is justified for your needs.

Key Points

  • Unique Potency: The high concentration of methylglyoxal (MGO) and non-peroxide activity sets manuka honey apart from regular honey for powerful antibacterial effects.

  • Grading Matters: Authenticity and potency are guaranteed by testing and rating systems like UMF™ and MGO, with higher numbers indicating greater therapeutic strength.

  • Clinically Proven for Wounds: Medical-grade manuka honey is widely used and proven effective for treating wounds, burns, and antibiotic-resistant infections.

  • Benefits Beyond Wounds: Research supports its use for oral health, soothing sore throats, and offers promise for digestive and immune system support.

  • The Cost Factor: Manuka is considerably more expensive due to its limited harvest season, specific origin, and rigorous testing process.

  • Not a Universal Cure: While powerful for specific applications, the high cost is not always justified for everyday use or general wellness compared to regular honey.

  • Safety Precautions: Avoid giving any honey to infants under one year old, and those with allergies or diabetes should exercise caution and consult a professional.

In This Article

The Science Behind Manuka Honey's Unique Power

Unlike standard honey, which primarily derives its antibacterial properties from hydrogen peroxide, manuka honey possesses a unique non-peroxide activity. This potency is primarily attributed to a high concentration of Methylglyoxal (MGO), a compound that is formed naturally from Dihydroxyacetone (DHA) found in the nectar of the manuka flower. The higher the MGO content, the stronger the antibacterial effect. This unique composition is what sets it apart and fuels its reputation as a powerful superfood.

The Importance of MGO and UMF Ratings

Not all manuka honey is created equal, and discerning its quality relies on standardized rating systems. The two most common are MGO and UMF™.

  • MGO (Methylglyoxal): This system directly measures the concentration of methylglyoxal in milligrams per kilogram (mg/kg). A higher MGO number, such as MGO 550+, indicates a higher potency and stronger antibacterial effect.
  • UMF™ (Unique Manuka Factor): This is a comprehensive system that measures MGO along with other key compounds like Leptosperin and DHA to ensure authenticity, purity, and potency. The UMF™ mark is also a certification that the honey was produced and packed in New Zealand under strict quality control.

Proven and Potential Health Benefits

Manuka honey's unique chemical profile has led to extensive research, validating several health claims and exploring others.

Evidence-Backed Uses

  • Wound Healing: One of the most well-researched applications, medical-grade manuka honey is used in wound dressings to promote healing, fight infection (including antibiotic-resistant strains like MRSA), reduce pain, and decrease scarring. Its high osmolarity helps draw moisture out of the wound, creating an environment unfavorable for bacterial growth.
  • Oral Health: Studies have shown that manuka honey can effectively attack harmful oral bacteria responsible for plaque formation and gingivitis, a gum disease. Its potent antibacterial properties can help inhibit bacterial growth, leading to improved oral hygiene.
  • Soothing Sore Throats: With its natural antibacterial and anti-inflammatory effects, manuka honey is an effective way to soothe a sore or scratchy throat. It works by coating the throat, reducing irritation and combating the bacteria that may be causing the infection.

Areas of Promising Research

  • Digestive Health: Some research suggests manuka honey may aid in balancing gut bacteria and soothing inflammatory conditions like irritable bowel syndrome (IBD) by reducing inflammation and supporting beneficial microbes. It is also being studied for its potential against H. pylori, the bacteria responsible for stomach ulcers.
  • Immune Support: The rich antioxidant content in manuka honey helps combat free radicals, which can harm cells and lead to inflammation. Regular consumption may help support the immune system and protect against certain infections.
  • Skin Care: Manuka honey is a popular ingredient in skincare products due to its antimicrobial and anti-inflammatory properties, which can help manage acne and soothe inflammatory skin conditions like eczema.

Manuka Honey vs. Regular Honey: Is the Extra Cost Justified?

Feature Manuka Honey (High Grade) Regular Honey (Processed) What this means for you
Origin Nectar of Manuka bush (Leptospermum scoparium) from New Zealand or Australia. Nectar from a variety of flowers, globally sourced. Manuka's unique origin and limited flowering season (2-6 weeks) contribute to scarcity and cost.
Processing Often raw; must be rigorously tested and certified (UMF/MGO). Often pasteurized and micro-filtered, potentially removing beneficial enzymes. Manuka retains its natural enzymes and compounds due to minimal processing and specific handling.
Antibacterial Potency High, primarily from stable MGO. More potent than regular honey. Variable and lower; relies mostly on hydrogen peroxide, which can degrade with heat or light. Manuka is more reliable for targeted antibacterial effects, especially in medical settings.
Taste Strong, earthy, and sometimes slightly bitter. Milder, sweeter, with a taste profile that varies greatly by floral source. Manuka's distinctive flavor may not be for everyone, though some find it complex and enjoyable.
Cost Significantly more expensive due to rarity, testing, and limited harvest. Affordable and widely available. Manuka is an investment for specific therapeutic uses, while regular honey is a cost-effective everyday sweetener.
Target Use Therapeutic, targeted wellness (wounds, sore throats, etc.). General wellness, cooking, and everyday sweetening. Your intended use should determine if the premium cost is warranted.

Important Considerations and Cautions

  • Not for Infants: Honey of any kind should not be given to children under 12 months old due to the risk of infant botulism.
  • High Sugar Content: All honey is high in natural sugars, and excessive intake should be avoided, particularly for individuals with diabetes. Always consult a doctor if you have blood sugar concerns.
  • Allergic Reactions: Individuals with a bee or honey allergy should avoid manuka honey to prevent a reaction.
  • Medical-Grade vs. Culinary: For topical application on burns or wounds, only use sterilized, medical-grade manuka honey preparations. The jar in your pantry is for consumption, not a DIY first-aid kit.

For further scientific details on manuka honey's antibacterial properties, explore the research available on the National Institutes of Health website(https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6613335/).

The Verdict: So, Is Manuka Honey Really That Good?

Manuka honey’s reputation is certainly not just a marketing ploy. The evidence shows that its high concentration of MGO and other compounds provides potent antibacterial, anti-inflammatory, and wound-healing benefits that exceed those of regular honey. For targeted therapeutic uses like wound care, oral health, or soothing a serious sore throat, the high-grade version is a highly effective and proven natural remedy.

However, for general, day-to-day use as a sweetener or for minor ailments, the premium price is likely not justified. In these cases, a good quality raw, local honey offers excellent antioxidant benefits and is a much more economical choice. The answer to whether manuka honey is "that good" lies in your specific needs and priorities, weighing its proven potency against its significant cost.

Frequently Asked Questions

Manuka honey contains a significantly higher concentration of methylglyoxal (MGO), a compound responsible for its unique and potent antibacterial properties, which are more stable and powerful than the hydrogen peroxide found in most regular honeys.

These are quality and potency rating systems. The MGO rating measures the concentration of methylglyoxal (mg/kg), while the UMF™ system is a more comprehensive test that verifies MGO content, authenticity, and purity from a New Zealand origin.

Yes, medically-certified manuka honey is widely used and proven to aid in wound healing by providing a protective, antibacterial barrier. It can fight infection, including some antibiotic-resistant strains, and promote tissue regeneration.

Its high price is due to several factors: limited geographic production in New Zealand and Australia, a short flowering season (only 2-6 weeks), and rigorous testing and certification processes to verify authenticity and potency.

Some studies suggest manuka honey may help with gut health by balancing bacteria and reducing inflammation. Research is ongoing, but it has shown some potential for soothing gastrointestinal discomfort and combating bacteria like H. pylori.

Infants under 12 months should not consume any honey due to botulism risk. Individuals with bee allergies should be cautious, and those with diabetes should consult a doctor before use due to its high sugar content.

Look for a certified MGO or UMF™ rating on the label. High-quality brands often provide transparency and traceability, sometimes with a QR code, linking the product to its lab testing results.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.