The Science Behind Cheese pH
To understand what cheese has the highest pH, it is essential to first grasp the basics of how pH is controlled during cheesemaking. All cheese production begins with milk, which has a naturally high pH. The cheesemaking process involves introducing starter cultures of bacteria that consume the milk's lactose and produce lactic acid, which lowers the pH. The final pH is a result of a complex interplay between the starter cultures, moisture content, salting, and specific ripening processes. Cheeses with a low pH, like Cheddar, are more acidic and tend to have a firmer, more crumbly texture and a sharper flavor. In contrast, cheeses with a high pH, or more alkaline cheeses, are often softer and milder.
The Highest pH Cheeses: Soft-Ripened and Washed-Rind Varieties
Many surface-ripened and washed-rind cheeses achieve the highest pH levels due to the specific types of bacteria and molds that thrive on their rinds during aging. In these cheeses, the initial acidity created by lactic acid bacteria is later neutralized and even reversed by the metabolic activity of surface molds and bacteria. These microorganisms produce ammonia through the deamination of amino acids, which effectively raises the pH from the outside-in.
Some of the highest pH cheeses include:
- Limburger: This classic washed-rind cheese can reach a pH in the range of 6.2 to 6.5, with the surface potentially reaching even higher levels during advanced ripening. The characteristic strong aroma is a direct result of the surface bacteria, Brevibacterium linens, which thrives in this higher pH environment.
- Camembert and Brie: These soft-ripened cheeses have a bloomy, white rind of Penicillium candidum. As they ripen, the mold breaks down proteins and consumes the lactic acid, causing the pH to rise significantly from its initial acidic state to a more neutral or even alkaline range of 6.5–7.0 in the rind.
- Blue Cheeses (e.g., Roquefort, Gorgonzola): The blue mold, Penicillium roqueforti, metabolizes fats and proteins, leading to the production of ammonia and a corresponding increase in pH to a range of 6.0–7.0. This rise in pH is crucial for developing the cheese's signature flavor and soft, creamy texture.
How High pH Affects Cheese Quality
The pH level is one of the most crucial factors affecting a cheese's final characteristics. A higher pH creates a distinctive sensory profile and impacts several aspects of the cheese.
Impacts of High pH:
- Texture: The protein network in cheese becomes softer and more elastic at higher pH levels. This is why soft-ripened and washed-rind cheeses are known for their creamy, gooey textures. A high pH also affects the retention of calcium, resulting in a less dense protein matrix.
- Flavor and Aroma: Higher pH cheeses generally have a milder flavor profile compared to their acidic counterparts. In surface-ripened and blue cheeses, the elevated pH enables specific bacterial activity that creates pungent, earthy, or aromatic flavors and aromas.
- Moisture: Higher pH levels can increase the water-holding capacity of the protein matrix, resulting in a softer, more moist cheese. This is partly why cheeses like Brie and Camembert have their signature runny centers when ripe.
- Food Safety: The pH of cheese is critical for inhibiting pathogenic bacterial growth. While starter cultures create an initial acidic environment to inhibit pathogens, the later rise in pH in soft-ripened cheeses requires careful control and monitoring to ensure food safety.
High pH Cheeses vs. Low pH Cheeses: A Comparison
To illustrate the impact of pH, consider the stark differences between a high-pH, soft-ripened cheese and a low-pH, hard cheese. The manufacturing and ripening processes are fundamentally different, leading to distinct and predictable outcomes.
| Feature | High pH Cheese (e.g., Camembert) | Low pH Cheese (e.g., Cheddar) |
|---|---|---|
| Final pH Range | 6.5–7.0 (rind) | 5.1–5.4 |
| Texture | Soft, creamy, often with a gooey interior | Firm, dense, and crumbly |
| Flavor Profile | Milder, with earthy, pungent, or buttery notes | Sharper, more tangy, and acidic |
| Aging Process | Surface bacteria and mold raise the pH and break down proteins | Bacteria produce lactic acid, maintaining a low pH |
| Moisture Content | Higher moisture content | Lower moisture content |
| Calcium Content | Lower calcium levels (more is lost during acidification) | Higher calcium retention |
Factors Influencing the Final pH of Cheese
Several elements in the cheesemaking process can be manipulated to control the final pH and achieve a specific cheese type.
- Starter Culture: Different strains of lactic acid bacteria and molds have varying effects on acid production. Cheesemakers select specific cultures to achieve the desired pH trajectory.
- Ripening Environment: Controlling temperature and humidity during aging is crucial. For surface-ripened cheeses, specific ambient conditions encourage the growth of alkaline-producing microorganisms.
- Washing the Curd: In some cheesemaking, washing the curds removes residual lactose and lowers the potential for acid development, which can lead to a higher final pH. Gouda is an example of a washed-curd cheese.
- Salt Content: The amount of salt used and the method of salting affect bacterial activity and moisture levels, both of which influence the final pH.
Conclusion
Ultimately, the cheese with the highest pH is not a single variety but a category of soft-ripened and washed-rind cheeses, such as Limburger, Brie, and Camembert, that can reach or exceed a neutral pH of 7.0. This high pH is not an accident; it is the direct result of a carefully controlled ripening process where surface microbes produce ammonia to neutralize the initial acidity. This alkaline environment is fundamental to developing the soft, creamy textures and complex, pungent flavors that distinguish these unique cheeses. Understanding the pivotal role of pH helps appreciate the craftsmanship and science involved in producing the vast diversity of cheeses enjoyed worldwide.
Visit Cheese Science Toolkit to explore more about cheese pH.
