What are Bioengineered Food Ingredients?
In the United States, a food labeled as containing bioengineered (BE) ingredients means it includes detectable genetic material that has been modified through laboratory techniques. These modifications are not something that could be achieved through conventional breeding or found in nature. The term "bioengineered" was officially established by the USDA's National Bioengineered Food Disclosure Standard (NBFDS) to replace the more commonly known, but less formally defined, term "genetically modified organism," or GMO.
Bioengineering is a form of genetic modification used to give crops and animals desirable traits, such as resistance to pests and diseases, tolerance to herbicides, or enhanced nutritional value. For example, bioengineered corn might be resistant to certain insects, while some bioengineered papayas were developed to resist the ringspot virus. The USDA maintains an official list of foods that have been bioengineered and are commercially available, which includes key crops like:
- Alfalfa
- Canola
- Corn
- Soybean
- Sugar beet
- Papaya (ringspot virus-resistant varieties)
- Squash (some varieties)
- Potato (some varieties)
- AquAdvantage Salmon
Understanding the Disclosure Methods
The NBFDS provides manufacturers with several options for disclosing the presence of bioengineered ingredients, leading to different indicators on food packaging. A consumer can encounter one of the following methods:
- Text disclosure: A simple, clear text statement near the ingredients list, such as “Bioengineered food” or “Contains a bioengineered food ingredient”.
- Symbol disclosure: The USDA-designed circular symbol containing the word “BIOENGINEERED”. This symbol can be found in color or black and white.
- Electronic or digital link: A QR code that, when scanned with a smartphone, takes the user to a webpage with the disclosure information. The law requires this page to appear immediately and not contain marketing or promotional content.
- Text message or phone number: An instruction to text a command word to a number or call a phone number to receive the bioengineered food information. This option is primarily available to small food manufacturers.
Comparing Bioengineered Disclosure Options
| Disclosure Method | Pros for Consumers | Cons for Consumers | How to Access Information |
|---|---|---|---|
| Text | Easiest to read and understand at a glance. Directly on the package. | May not provide a detailed explanation of the modification. | Read the ingredient or information panel on the package. |
| Symbol | Visually recognizable and prominent. Can be spotted quickly. | Some consumers may not be familiar with the symbol's meaning. | Look for the green and white circular symbol with the word "BIOENGINEERED". |
| Electronic (QR Code) | Provides detailed information via a web page. Standardized first-screen display. | Requires a smartphone and internet access. Less transparent and quick than text or symbol. | Scan the QR code with your phone's camera. |
| Text/Phone | Useful for consumers without reliable internet or a smartphone. | Inconvenient and slower than on-package options. | Call or text the number provided on the package. |
Important Exemptions and Nuances
Not all foods that are related to genetic engineering are required to carry a BE label. These exemptions are key to understanding why some products derived from genetically modified crops may not be marked.
- Highly refined ingredients: If an ingredient is derived from a bioengineered crop but is so highly refined that it no longer contains detectable modified genetic material, it is exempt from mandatory labeling. This includes common items like sugar derived from sugar beets and corn oil. A manufacturer may, however, voluntarily disclose these using the phrase “derived from bioengineering”.
- Animal products: Products from animals that consumed bioengineered feed are exempt. For example, milk or eggs from animals fed bioengineered corn do not require a disclosure.
- Small manufacturers and restaurants: Very small food manufacturers and food served in restaurants or similar retail food establishments are not required to provide a disclosure.
- Meat, poultry, and egg products: Foods where meat, poultry, or eggs are the most predominant ingredient (or second most after water/broth) are regulated by other statutes and are therefore exempt.
Safety of Bioengineered Foods
The topic of bioengineered foods has been a source of public debate, but a strong scientific consensus exists regarding their safety. Leading scientific organizations, including the National Academies of Sciences, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA), and the World Health Organization (WHO), have all concluded that bioengineered foods currently available on the market are safe for consumption and pose no more risk than their conventional counterparts. Extensive safety evaluations and long-term studies have found no substantiated evidence that bioengineered crops are less safe to eat. These products must meet the same stringent safety standards as traditional foods.
Making Your Choice
For consumers who wish to avoid bioengineered ingredients, the NBFDS provides the tools to make informed decisions. However, due to the various exemptions, relying on the mandatory BE label alone is not a foolproof method. A more definitive approach is to look for third-party certifications or choose USDA-certified organic products. The USDA Organic seal is a reliable indicator, as organic standards prohibit the use of genetically modified organisms. Another option is the Non-GMO Project Verified label, which is a third-party certification that confirms a product meets a specific non-GMO standard.
For additional information about the standard and a list of bioengineered foods, refer to the USDA's Agricultural Marketing Service website.
Conclusion
When a package says “contains bioengineered food ingredients,” it means the product includes a food with detectable genetic modifications, as defined and required by the USDA's NBFDS since 2022. While the standard offers several ways for manufacturers to disclose this information—including text, symbols, and digital links—its effectiveness is limited by exemptions for certain refined products, small businesses, and food served in restaurants. For those prioritizing a diet free of genetically engineered foods, supplementing the mandatory BE label with third-party certifications like USDA Organic or Non-GMO Project Verified is the most comprehensive strategy. Ultimately, the label serves as a starting point for consumers to understand and choose their food. The scientific community generally considers bioengineered foods safe, but the disclosure empowers individuals to align their dietary choices with their personal preferences.