Skip to content

What foods can cause closed comedones?

3 min read

According to a 2016 survey, a large percentage of people believe that diet affects acne. Emerging research suggests that understanding the link between food and inflammation is key to managing breakouts, including closed comedones, which are a type of whitehead caused by clogged pores.

Quick Summary

This article explores the dietary factors, such as high-glycemic foods, dairy, and processed items, that are scientifically linked to increased sebum and inflammation, contributing to closed comedone formation.

Key Points

  • High-Glycemic Foods: Refined carbs and sugars can trigger hormonal responses that increase sebum production and inflammation, contributing to closed comedones.

  • Dairy Products: Hormones in milk, especially skim milk and whey protein, are linked to higher levels of IGF-1, which can exacerbate acne breakouts.

  • Processed & Fast Foods: The combination of unhealthy fats and high sugar in processed meals can lead to chronic inflammation and increased oil production.

  • Omega Fatty Acid Balance: An imbalance with excessive omega-6 (from corn/soy oil) compared to omega-3s can contribute to inflammation related to acne.

  • The Chocolate Myth: The sugar and dairy in milk chocolate are the likely triggers for breakouts, not the cocoa. Dark chocolate (70%+ cocoa) is a better, lower-sugar option.

  • Individual Triggers Vary: Not all people react the same way to dietary changes, so identifying personal trigger foods is key to managing closed comedones.

In This Article

The Link Between Diet and Clogged Pores

For decades, the connection between diet and acne was largely dismissed by the medical community. However, numerous recent studies have shown a definitive link, proving that what you eat can significantly impact your skin's health, particularly in the formation of comedones. Closed comedones, or whiteheads, are formed when a hair follicle becomes completely blocked with a mixture of excess oil (sebum) and dead skin cells. Certain foods can trigger hormonal responses or inflammation that directly contribute to these blockages, making diet a crucial component of effective acne management.

High-Glycemic Foods and the Insulin Cascade

Foods with a high glycemic index (GI) are a primary dietary culprit behind comedonal acne. These foods cause rapid spikes in blood sugar, triggering the body to release insulin. This process, in turn, can lead to an increase in insulin-like growth factor (IGF-1), a hormone that boosts sebum production and promotes inflammation. This overproduction of oil and inflammation creates a perfect storm for clogged pores and the development of closed comedones.

Common high-GI foods to be mindful of include:

  • White bread, bagels, and pastries made with refined flour
  • Sugary drinks, like sodas and juices
  • Sweets, such as candy and cakes
  • Certain breakfast cereals with added sugar
  • Instant rice and white pasta
  • Processed snacks like pretzels and corn chips

Dairy and Hormonal Triggers

Another well-documented link exists between the consumption of dairy products and acne, with some evidence suggesting that skim milk may be particularly problematic. The hormones naturally present in milk can elevate the body's levels of IGF-1, which exacerbates acne. This effect is seen not only with milk itself but also with dairy-derived products like whey protein, which is often used in fitness supplements. Fermented dairy like yogurt and cheese, however, may be better tolerated by some individuals and show a less significant link to comedone formation.

The Inflammatory Effects of Processed and Fast Foods

Processed and fast foods are often packed with high-glycemic carbohydrates, added sugars, and unhealthy fats. This combination can trigger a chronic inflammatory response in the body, which is an underlying factor in the development of comedonal acne. These foods can disrupt the gut microbiome and throw off the body's hormonal balance, further contributing to skin issues. Examples include:

  • Burgers and fried chicken
  • French fries and potato chips
  • Salty and sugary snacks
  • Pre-packaged meals and desserts

Comparing Acne-Prone vs. Skin-Friendly Foods

Category What to Reduce/Avoid What to Embrace (Generally)
Carbohydrates Refined carbs (white bread, pasta), sugary drinks, sweets Whole grains (oatmeal, brown rice), fruits, vegetables, legumes
Dairy Skim milk, whey protein supplements Fermented dairy (in moderation), plant-based alternatives (almond, oat milk)
Fats Fast food, fried foods, excessive omega-6 oils Omega-3 rich foods (salmon, flaxseeds, walnuts), cold-pressed vegetable oils
Snacks Chips, pretzels, candy, sugary desserts Nuts, seeds, berries, whole fruits
Chocolate Milk chocolate (high sugar/dairy) High-cocoa dark chocolate (70%+), in moderation

Other Contributing Factors and the Chocolate Debate

Beyond high GI foods and dairy, other factors like an unbalanced omega-6 to omega-3 fatty acid ratio and smoking can also contribute to comedonal acne. While the omega-6 fats found in corn and soy oil are essential, an overabundance relative to anti-inflammatory omega-3s can worsen skin inflammation. As for chocolate, earlier flawed studies wrongly exonerated it. Today, experts believe that the high sugar and dairy content in most milk chocolate products is what exacerbates breakouts in some individuals, not the cocoa itself.

Conclusion: Finding Your Skin-Friendly Diet

It is clear that for many individuals, diet plays a role in the formation of closed comedones. High-glycemic foods, certain dairy products, and processed items can increase inflammation and oil production, leading to clogged pores. While a "cure-all" diet for acne does not exist, and genetic and hormonal factors also play a significant part, making mindful dietary changes can be a powerful tool. The best approach is often to observe your own body. Keeping a food journal can help you identify specific triggers. Remember to consult a dermatologist or registered dietitian for personalized advice tailored to your skin's needs. Incorporating more whole, anti-inflammatory foods while reducing your intake of high-glycemic and processed items is a sensible step toward clearer, healthier skin. For a deeper dive into the relationship between diet and acne, you can explore the insights of this observational study on patient beliefs(https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4866623/).

Frequently Asked Questions

The primary dietary cause often involves a high glycemic load diet, characterized by refined carbohydrates and sugars. This increases insulin and IGF-1 levels, which in turn leads to higher sebum production and inflammation.

Yes, research shows a link between dairy consumption, particularly skim milk and whey protein, and an increased incidence of acne. Hormones like IGF-1 in milk are thought to be the cause.

Processed and fast foods often contain a mix of high-glycemic ingredients, unhealthy fats, and sugars that contribute to systemic inflammation and increased oil production, which can exacerbate closed comedone formation.

The link is controversial, but recent evidence suggests that the sugar and dairy in milk chocolate are the more likely culprits for acne flare-ups. High-cocoa dark chocolate is often better tolerated.

An imbalance with too many omega-6 fatty acids (from vegetable oils like corn and soy) relative to anti-inflammatory omega-3s can increase inflammation in the body, which contributes to acne.

Keeping a food journal can help you track your intake and observe any patterns in your breakouts. This allows you to identify specific items that might be worsening your closed comedones.

Non-dietary causes include hormonal fluctuations, genetics, certain skincare products that clog pores, high humidity, and smoking. A holistic approach considering diet, skincare, and lifestyle is most effective.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.